Tag: book reviews

Review – The Library of Ancient Wisdom

Posted April 22, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 10 Comments

Review – The Library of Ancient Wisdom

The Library of Ancient Wisdom

by Selena Wisnom

Genres: History, Non-fiction
Pages: 448
Rating: five-stars
Synopsis:

More than half of human history is written in cuneiform, but only a few hundred people on earth can read it. In this captivating new book, Assyriologist Selena Wisnom takes us on an immersive tour of this extraordinary library, bringing ancient Mesopotamia and its people to life. Through it, we encounter a world of astonishing richness, complexity and sophistication. Mesopotamia, she shows, was home to advanced mathematics, astronomy and banking, law and literature. This was a culture absorbed and developed by the ancient Greeks, and whose myths were precursors to Bible stories - in short, a culture without which our lives today would be unrecognizable.

When a team of Victorian archaeologists dug into a grassy hill in Iraq, they chanced upon one of the oldest and greatest stores of knowledge ever seen: the library of the Assyrian emperor Ashurbanipal, seventh century BCE ruler of a huge swathe of the ancient Middle East known as Mesopotamia. After his death, vengeful rivals burned Ashurbanipal's library to the ground - yet the texts, carved on clay tablets, were baked and preserved by the heat. Buried for millennia, the tablets were written in cuneiform: the first written language in the world.

The Library of Ancient Wisdom unearths a civilization at once strange and strangely familiar: a land of capricious gods, exorcisms and professional lamenters, whose citizens wrote of jealous rivalries, profound friendships and petty grievances. Through these pages we come face to face with humanity's first civilization: their startling achievements, their daily life, and their struggle to understand our place in the universe.

Selena Wisnom’s The Library of Ancient Wisdom examines the world of ancient Mesopotamia by using the famed library of Ashurbanipal as a jumping-off point. This isn’t as futile as you might think: the ancient baked clay tablets have survived beautifully, with even shattered tablets being pieced back together, so we actually have quite a wide spread of literature available to us. The British Library wouldn’t survive nearly as well in the same circumstances: paper might be more versatile, but baked clay has serious staying power.

There’s a range of texts in what we have from that ancient library, in any case: medical texts, religious texts, literature, letters both domestic and foreign. It’s necessarily a somewhat limited picture, all the same, focusing primarily on the king and his family, so it’s important to remember that the extraordinary level of preservation still doesn’t tell us anything about the world further afield.

I liked that Wisnom reminds the reader several times that the Mesopotamian world wasn’t primitive; though they had beliefs that seem to us wild superstition, they didn’t believe them in spite of the world they could readily observe around them. Their gods were capricious and imperfect, and could make mistakes and change their minds — and thus the omens and portents they saw around them were warning and possibilities, not set in stone. Lamentations, prayers and sacrifices could avert evil. And in fields like astronomy and maths, they knew things which took “Western civilisation” millennia to recover.

Given my interests, I was especially interested to note their views on hygiene, including carefully washing your hands. They didn’t attribute it to microbes, of course, but to curses which could be transferred between people — but that’s a pretty good understanding for practical purposes! Contrast with the modern Western world, where Ignaz Semmelweiss was literally treated as insane for suggesting an evidence-based approach to pueperal fever. No, I’m not kidding: he proposed that doctors should wash their hands with disinfectant between performing autopsies on rotting bodies and delivering babies, and he literally died in an insane asylum (of septic shock; you can’t make it up, can you?).

My only caveats here would be that obviously it’s a deeply biased way to see Mesopotamian society since you only really see what concerns the king (even if that does give you glimpses of his family and advisors, they’re all high ranking too), and that it can be difficult to keep track of the geopolitics sometimes if you don’t have a good head for it — keeping a map handy and writing notes might have helped me a bit there!

Rating: 5/5 (“loved it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – Blue Horses

Posted April 22, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – Blue Horses

Blue Horses

by Mary Oliver

Genres: Poetry
Pages: 83
Rating: five-stars
Synopsis:

Maybe our world will grow kinder eventually. Maybe the desire to make something beautiful is the piece of God that is inside each of us. In this stunning collection, Mary Oliver returns to the imagery that has defined her life's work. Herons, sparrows, owls and kingfishers flit across the page in meditations on love, artistry and impermanence. Whether considering a bird's nest, the seeming patience of oak trees or the paintings of Franz Marc, Mary Oliver reminds us of the transformative power of attention and how much can be contained within the smallest moments. Blue Horses asks what it truly means to belong to this world and to live in it attuned to all its changes. 'To be human,' she shows us, 'is to sing your own song'.

Mary Oliver’s work is definitely a proof that poetry doesn’t have to be impenetrable — there’s something very open and airy about her work, something that invites you in, and she seemed to take such joy in the world and to have had a curiosity about everything.

Here’s the end of one poem that stuck with me:

I’ll just leave you with this.
I don’t care how many angels can
dance on the head of a pin. It’s
enough to know that for some people
they exist, and that they dance.

Definitely going to read more of her collections; kind of wish I’d picked up one or two more at the same time during my trip to Gay’s the Word!

Rating: 5/5 (“loved it”)

Tags: , , ,

Divider

Review – Jack on the Gallows Tree

Posted April 21, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – Jack on the Gallows Tree

Jack on the Gallows Tree

by Leo Bruce

Genres: Crime, Mystery
Pages: 204
Series: British Library Crime Classics
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

“If Carolus Deene catches so much as a whiff of murder he will be on the scent with all the persistence and gusto of a dachshund in search of truffles.”

While Senior History Master of Queen’s School, Newminster, Carolus Deene has a troubling hobby as a criminologist and sometime sleuth. Even more troublingly, he has jaundice. But with the papers shouting of the crimewave sweeping the seaside resorts of England, sending him to the coast to recover is too risky for the Headmaster – he will be much further from trouble in the inland spa resort of Buddington.

But before long Buddington is rocked by a twisted double-murder – two elderly women found dead on the same night at the same time, each with a white lily by their side. Perhaps things are looking up for the curious Deene?

First published in 1960, Leo Bruce’s classic mystery hums with his trademark wit and comedic flair, centred around an intelligent puzzle and a memorable cast of Buddington’s best.

I wasn’t sure if I’d like Jack on the Gallows Tree, as Leo Bruce is also the author of the Sergeant Beef stories, which I’ve never enjoyed much when I came across them in British Library Crime Classics collections. Fortunately this one is based around his other series detective, Carolus Deene, who I find more enjoyable as a character, with his sense of civic duty and the sense that he genuinely suffers strain during a case, and genuinely feels conflicted about pointing to a murderer.

In many ways it’s a pretty typical classic crime story, and I quickly figured out the motive in the same way as the character does — that part wasn’t exactly a mystery, though I think there’s a biiit of a dearth of clues pointing you to the right character (since three have motives which fit the bill). Possibly I missed something, but it felt to me like we didn’t have all the evidence until the circle of suspects was convened in classic mystery style, and then it was starting to feel a bit ponderous.

Still, I enjoyed it overall: Deene works quite well as a detective, some of the character observations are funny, along with the rather metafictional bit where Priggley tells Deene the circle-of-suspects thing is why he’s not one of Julian Symons’ top detectives. I’d definitely read more Carolus Deene books, though I still hope I won’t have to subject myself to a whole novel of Sergeant Beef.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Review – Snake-eater

Posted April 19, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 8 Comments

Review – Snake-eater

Snake-eater

by T. Kingfisher

Genres: Fantasy, Horror
Pages: 352
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

In an isolated desert town, a young woman seeking a fresh start is confronted by ancient gods, malevolent supernatural forces, and eccentric neighbours. A witty horror-tinged fantasy, perfect for fans of Silvia Moreno-Garcia, Chuck Tingle, and Rachel Harrison.

When Selena travels to the remote desert town of Quartz Creek in search of her estranged Aunt Amelia, she is desperate and short of options. Fleeing an unhappy marriage, she has exactly twenty-seven dollars to her name, and her only friend in the world is her dog, Copper.

On arrival, Selena learns Amelia is dead. But the inhabitants of Quartz Creek are only too happy to have a new resident. Out of money and ideas, Selena sees no harm staying in her aunt’s lovely house for a few weeks, tending to her garden and enjoying the strange, desolate beauty of the desert. The people are odd, but friendly, and eager to help Selena settle into her new home.

But Quartz Creek’s inhabitants share their town with others, old gods and spirits whose claim to the land long predates their human neighbours. Selena finds herself pursued by disturbing apparitions, visitations that come in the night and seem to want something from her.

Aunt Amelia owed a debt. Now her god has come to collect.

I saw someone describing T. Kingfisher’s Snake-eater as “cosy horror”, and that does make sense to me, weird as it sounds. There’s something very tempting in the life that Selena manages to find for herself, the friends she makes, and the sense of being home that Kingfisher somehow manages to communicate with every word of description (making her acknowledgements section note about returning to high desert areas pretty unsurprising, though I hadn’t known that she was returning to somewhat familiar ground when she moved).

I love the community described as well — Grandma Billy especially, and Father Aguirre, but really all of them. They’re so kind and welcoming, usually without forcing Selena into anything (even if Grandma Billy’s a bit of a forceful personality, she still gives Selena her space).

One thing that might give people pause in reading this is that Selena’s recovering from an abusive relationship, in which her partner (Walter) tried to control her, often doing so by telling her she’s terrible with people, can’t tell when people are uncomfortable or dislike her, etc, or by acting like she’s mentally ill for having emotions and breaking down under the strain of him treating her that way. A couple of reviewers said that she’s “obviously” suffering from autistic burnout, which I can’t speak to; mostly it looked like someone coming out of a terrible relationship that made them doubt themselves, to me.

And then, of course, there’s Snake-eater. That’s a lot cleaner peril than Walter, really: Selena’s aunt was in a relationship with a roadrunner god, who drained her energy and killed her. Now he wants Selena, and when she declines, he’s furious.

I worried that the two relationships would get knitted together the whole way, with some kind of confrontation with both Snake-eater and Walter, or Snake-eater using Walter — or even vice versa. It felt like that would have over-simplified things, and thankfully that’s not how it played out. I liked that the situation with Walter is ultimately resolved in a single chapter, using everything that Selena has learned about her community and her own ability to take care of herself.

I think there are some slight pacing issues with this one, in that it feels like a very slow build and then all of a sudden everything’s come to a head and it’s over… and I hadn’t quite got enough of a sense of building menace from the slow build (if anything, Selena’s growing comfort kind of gives us the opposite, even if she angers Snake-eater and has to deal with that situation). So that’s worth knowing — but even so it’s a book I flew through.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Irresistible Urge to Fall For Your Enemy

Posted April 19, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 10 Comments

Review – The Irresistible Urge to Fall For Your Enemy

The Irresistible Urge to Fall For Your Enemy

by Brigitte Knightley

Genres: Fantasy, Romance
Pages: 384
Series: Dearly Beloathed #1
Rating: two-stars
Synopsis:

A slow burn, enemies-to-lovers romantasy featuring a scholarly healer and a gentleman assassin, set in an exquisite fantasy world, perfect for fans of The Love Hypothesis and Emily Wilde's Encyclopaedia of Faeries.

Osric Mordaunt, member of the Fyren Order of assassins, is in dire need of healing. Naturally – such is the grim comedy of fate – the only healer who can help is Aurienne Fairhrim, preeminent scientist, bastion of moral good, and member of an enemy Order. Aurienne is desperate for funding to heal the sick - so desperate that, when Osric bribes her to help him, she accepts, even if she detests him and everything he stands for.

A forced collaboration ensues: the brilliant Woman in STEM is coerced into working with the PhD in Murders, much to Aurienne's disgust. As Osric and Aurienne work together to heal his illness and investigate the mysterious reoccurrence of a deadly pox, they find themselves ardently denying their attraction, which only fuels the heat between them.

The main problem for me with Brigitte Knightley’s The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy was that the characters were both insufferable. This would make absolute sense if it were only when we’re in one POV talking about the other, but one of Aurienne’s early chapters just made her sound like she was completely up herself:

It was hard, being perfect in an imperfect world, but Aurienne managed. If she had a flaw, it was that she was the Best, and she knew she was the Best. Some called it arrogance. She called it competence untainted by performative humility. But if she was the Best — as brilliant as she was beautiful, a researcher unparalleled, a daughter beloved, a lover sometimes (did anyone truly deserve her? Frankly, no) — why, pray, had she just been asked to care for the Worst? Tasked to heal [an assassin], of all the foul things in the world?

Frankly, she can go off and fuck herself, since she thinks she’s the only one who’s worthy.

Mostly in a romance, you expect some ability to actually like the characters. And also some chemistry between the two would be nice. Unfortunately, they’re both awful, and the chemistry between them isn’t great. That they dislike each other, I can believe; that that turns to attraction/love, I can’t, particularly as those sections go all purple prose (in comparison to the quippy banter of the rest of the thing).

You’d think I had absolutely no fun at all with that lead-in, but the weird thing is that I did have fun with it. I don’t know if I’ll read the next book, but I finished this one pretty quickly! It was fun in a trashy way (which I say because most people know what I mean by “trashy” and not actually as a value judgement on “trashy” books which can be deeply enjoyable), and I can kinda understand why some people adore it. It feels like a fanfic, for the very good reason that it was.

On which note, I will warn as well that the veneer is very thin at times. Harry Potter lingers on it like a bad smell. Not all of us pickled ourselves in that fandom, but there’s stuff even I realised was mostly find-and-replace (deofols = owls, for instance). If you don’t like accidentally finding yourself perpetuating the worship of a series written by a transphobe who uses her platform to try to hurt as many trans people as she can, children included — well. Now you’re warned!

Rating: 2/5 (“it was okay”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – Tied to You, vol 4

Posted April 16, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Tied to You, vol 4

Tied to You

by WHAT, Chelliace

Genres: Fantasy, Manga, Romance
Pages: 320
Series: Tied to You #4
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Wooseo's heart has been swayed, and Jigeon is determined to win it over completely, once and for all. But a meeting between Wooseo, Jiseok, and the Connector may throw a wrench in his plans when Jiseok reveals his brother has been deceiving Wooseo. The lies, the manipulations, the mind games--when all is laid bare to Wooseo, will he choose to stay tied to Jigeon?

Volume four of WHAT/Chelliace’s Tied to You brings everything to a head: Jigeon lays all his cards on the table, Jiseok does too, and Wooseo has to choose what he wants and decide whether he wants the Connector to change anything, or whether he loves his fated partner after all.

There could be some really fascinating stories in this world with non-fated partners, even without the existence of the Connector — Jigeon clearly doesn’t trust to fate, after all, so perhaps there are other pairs out there who make do with ring connections that don’t reflect their feelings. But in this one I don’t think there’s much doubt about what Wooseo will choose in the end…

Even though Jigeon confesses to manipulating the situation, it doesn’t suddenly become a healthy romance — even if Wooseo now chooses it open-eyed. Jigeon’s nature isn’t trusting, not even of fate; I think he’d treat Wooseo well, and carefully avoid any chance of things cooling by manipulating the situation, no matter what. It’s not a relationship I’d choose for myself, for darn sure!

But… maybe it’s good for them. Certainly it was satisfying to see the decision made, and for Wooseo to realise that he has feelings for Jigeon in his own right, not as a stand-in for Jiseok. Still, once more, a warning that this isn’t a fluffy romance (and isn’t intended to be).

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , , ,

Divider

Review – Domination

Posted April 15, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Domination

Domination: The Fall of the Roman Empire and the Rise of Christianity

by Alice Roberts

Genres: History
Pages: 432
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

This is the story of the fall of an Empire – and the rise of another.

Who spread Christianity, how, and why? In her quest to find the answer, Professor Alice Roberts takes us on a gripping investigative journey. From a secluded valley in south Wales to the shores of Brittany; from the heart of the Roman Empire in a time of political turmoil to the ancient city of Corinth in the footsteps of the apostle Paul; from Alexandria in the fourth century to Constantinople.

As the Roman Empire crumbled in Western Europe, a shadow of power remained, almost perfectly mapping onto its disappearing territories. And then, it continued to spread. Unearthing the archaeological clues and challenging long-established histories, Professor Roberts tells a remarkable story about the relationship between the Roman Empire and Christianity.

Lifting the veil on secrets that have been hidden in plain sight, this story is nothing short of astonishing.

It took me a little while to properly get into Alice Roberts’ Domination, because it wasn’t as directly related to my interests as the other books of hers I’ve read. Late Roman and Christian history isn’t really my thing for the most part, but I wanted to give it a shot because I liked her other books (like Crypt) so much — and ultimately I was glad I gave it a try, because once the stage is set (after a certain amount of digging through hagiographies and looking at place names), there’s some very interesting analysis.

My favourite part was the discussion of the famous “conversion” of Constantine. Did he in fact paint Christian symbols on the shields of his men, or put a Christian symbol on a banner, in order to bring his men victory? I hadn’t really thought about what evidence we had for this, which would’ve tipped me off right away that it sounded a bit weird: the info comes mostly from a biography of him written by a Christian after his death. But even with that, it still sounded like he used some Christian imagery, like the chi-rho, on his coins… right?

Well, no, again it’s more complicated than that. The same symbol was used by pagans before that to mean “archon”: it seems the use of it as “chi-rho” for Christ post-dates Constantine, possibly even invented in order to co-opt Constantine for Christianity.

At the same time, Roberts makes it clear that Constantine did definitely engage with the growing early Church, offer it support, and seems to have legitimately preferred to discourage blood sacrifices. So there is a basis for considering him a supporter of Christianity, if not a Christian himself — but it’s complicated by all the things people have wanted him to be, and the things they want his action to have meant.

For me, that was the most interesting part of the book, along with the conclusion (painstakingly teased out) that the Roman Empire didn’t so much fall as become transmuted into the Roman Catholic Church. Much of the things that pertained to being Roman, Romanitas, simply became Christian, Christianitas, instead. The state was never separate from religion (the emperor was a living god, starting with Augustus), and Christianity displaced paganism quite readily, taking over various aspects of managing towns and cities.

I did find a couple of things annoying: first, no footnotes, only selected bibliography. Blargh to that. And secondly, Roberts keeps chipping in to remind us not to talk about abstract concepts (“the Church” as a whole) as if they have agency, when things are actually being done by individual people. It’s fair enough, but when she keeps doing it and then correcting herself multiple times (rather than merely doing better about it and editing herself if need be, at least some of the time), it gets in the way of the narrative a bit.

I didn’t like this as much as her books focused on archaeology (and specifically on archaeology of human remains), but in the end, it gave me a lot of interesting new stuff to ponder.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – milk and honey

Posted April 15, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – milk and honey

milk and honey

by Rupi Kaur

Genres: Poetry
Pages: 204
Rating: two-stars
Synopsis:

milk and honey is a collection of poetry and prose about survival. About the experience of violence, abuse, love, loss, and femininity. It is split into four chapters, and each chapter serves a different purpose. Deals with a different pain. Heals a different heartache.

milk and honey takes readers through a journey of the most bitter moments in life and finds sweetness in them because there is sweetness everywhere if you are just willing to look.

I ended up picking up Rupi Kaur’s milk and honey collection because Let’s Talk Bookish will be discussing “instapoetry” (Instagram poetry) on Friday, and I hadn’t knowingly read any, so I figured I’d try one of the famous ones and see what I think.

I get that people look down on Instapoetry and similar so I want to be clear, I don’t dislike it because it’s instapoetry — actually, I think that’s kinda cool, in that it makes poetry accessible to different people, and it’s written and enjoyed by people who might not have written or enjoyed poetry in more “traditional” formats.

Personally, I didn’t connect that much with Rupi Kaur’s poetry: it’s certainly easy to read, and I kinda liked the way it was matched with sketches that expressed something about each poem. She does have a way of putting things sometimes that puts something stark and horrible out there (particularly in the early section where sexual assault is a major theme) in a way that’s very clear and just… encapsulates a dreadful moment. For the most part, though, I didn’t find her poetry really got to me: it tends to the simple, clear, freeform style, and in a way it sometimes just feels like reading her disjointed thoughts — which is not my thing, much as it’s a valid way of self-expression and of playing with words even when those aren’t your actual thoughts (important not to assume the two are always the same).

Overall, not for me, though I understand the appeal.

Rating: 2/5 (“it was okay”)

Tags: , , ,

Divider

Review – Murder Offstage

Posted April 13, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – Murder Offstage

Murder Offstage

by L.B. Hathaway

Genres: Crime, Historical Fiction, Mystery
Pages: 220
Series: Posie Parker Mystery #1
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

Like your mysteries cozy and set during the Golden Age of Crime? This is the first book in the Posie Parker mysteries, although this novel can be enjoyed as a stand-alone story in its own right. Set in London in 1921, 'Murder Offstage' is full of intrigue and red herrings. This is a classic murder mystery which will appeal to fans of Agatha Christie and Downton Abbey.

When Posie Parker’s childhood friend is robbed of a priceless jewel and becomes a suspect in a cold-blooded murder case, budding detective Posie vows she will clear his name. Aided by her seriously gorgeous assistant Len, Posie soon realizes things are not quite as they seem, and the darkly-glamorous world of London’s theatre and glittering nightclubs prove far more dangerous than she ever could have imagined.

Just who exactly is the dangerous Lucky Lucy Gibson? And who is it she has killed in the lobby of the Ritz Hotel? And more importantly, what on earth has happened to Mr Minks, the much-loved office cat?

I must admit I don’t quite remember why I picked up L.B. Hathaway’s Murder Offstage — possibly just when in a mood for mysteries, or looking for something to fill the Phryne Fisher-shaped void — but it definitely hung around on my shelves awaiting the right moment for quite a while. Even now, I actually picked it up on a bit of a whim, wondering whether maybe it was going to be an easy way to clear out a spot on my shelf with a DNF.

I found it was more compelling than I’d feared from reading a couple of reviews. I have a high tolerance for anachronism, which is what I’d seen other people complain of, and I was quickly curious how the mystery was going to work out… something about the friendly relationship between Rufus and Posie, the way she cared about him despite him being a bit of a wreck, I think. (I was less interested in the romantic relationship between her and Len, though.)

There were several factors that were annoying — rank lack of caution on Posie’s part, for example, taking risks and being taken in easily mostly for the sake of moving the plot to a conclusion rather than because they were sensible risks that a businesswoman/detective would take if they thought about it for two seconds. And of course the obvious problem with Babe, her secretary, plus the way she reacts at the end: acting deeply hurt and betrayed, even though she’d known all along there was something off? And on the other hand, her fervent and immediate defence of Dolly, despite not really having any history to base it on.

It just feels a little unpolished, disconnected, at times. That said, I was never tempted to DNF or skim, so it does have something going for it! I probably wouldn’t read more in the series, but it was a fun distraction.

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Hedgewitch of Foxhall

Posted April 12, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 4 Comments

Review – The Hedgewitch of Foxhall

The Hedgewitch of Foxhall

by Anna Bright

Genres: Fantasy
Pages: 389
Rating: two-stars
Synopsis:

Ffion is the last hedgewitch in Foxhall. To work her magic, she takes only what nature can spare, unlike the witches of the powerful Foxhall coven, who sacrifice whole forests to fuel their spells. But across the warring kingdoms of Wales, all magic is fading. Even the dragons have vanished.

Prince Taliesin would love nothing more than to watch magic die. But when his father charges Tal and his brother, Dafydd, with destroying King Offa’s dyke—the massive earthen wall raised by their Mercian enemies to the east, which may be the cause of magic’s disappearance—he begrudgingly seeks aid from a witch.

Because whichever prince succeeds in destroying the dyke will win the throne, and Tal is willing to do whatever it takes to become king. Even if the Foxhall coven refuses to help him. Even if he’s forced to team up with a spitfire hedgewitch who hates him almost as much as he hates her magic. And even if Dafydd proves to be a worthier rival than he anticipated…for the crown, and for Ffion’s heart.

Anna Bright’s The Hedgewitch of Foxhall caught my attention because it’s set in a historical-fantasy Wales, with Offa’s dyke presenting a huge problem because it affects magic. The main characters are Ffion, Taliesin and Dafydd, and yes… there’s a love triangle, alas.

In many ways it’s a very typical quest narrative, not very surprising, but the very Welsh setting adds some grounding to it. I mostly enjoyed that aspect, though I wasn’t always absolutely certain about the Welsh stuff. (E.g. does it make sense to ask another Welsh person, in Welsh, if they feel hiraeth, and then have to define hiraeth? Well… maybe, yeah, maybe you just hear the word and you don’t really know the full definition other than “homesickness, sort of”, so I’ll give it a pass. It did feel more like Welsh people speaking in English, though — I have absolutely asked another Welsh person if they feel hiraeth, and been asked too.) The historical grounding was probably all over the place, but I actually don’t know that much about that sort of period or Offa’s dyke, so that all got a pass from me, even though it might annoy others to no end.

There are some interesting concepts and interesting ways of handling the witchcraft, plus the various magical creatures; nothing groundbreaking, though I liked the fact that it was based on folksy songs etc. My main quibble was the constant POV-switching, and the love triangle. I just wasn’t into it and didn’t really believe in it as-given.

Warning: the pet fox Cadno dies in the first few chapters. It’s story relevant, and it’s not all it appears (trying not to spoiler), but Ffion grieves intensely, so it’s worth knowing about.

Rating: 2/5 (“it was okay”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider