Review – The Brothers

Posted May 28, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – The Brothers

The Brothers

by Sheelue Yang, Le Nhat Yu

Genres: Children's
Pages: 32
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

In this Hmong folktale, two brothers venture into a remote jungle, hunting food for their hungry family. But the jungle is full of dangerous wild animals. The older brother vows to keep his younger brother safe . . . or die trying. With clever text and easy-to-follow panels, Discover Graphics: Global Folktales are perfect for graphic novel fans new and old.

I read Sheelue Yang and Le Nhat Yu’s adaptation of a Hmong folktale, The Brothers, because I’d recently read a couple of things about Hmong traditions but really knew almost nothing, and this happened to catch my eye on Comics Plus. I’m not a big reader of children’s books in general, but I think this was well done? It has a bit of an explanation about how to read graphic novels like this at the front, and at the back there’s some discussion questions to help kids talk over the story with their parents.

The art and colouring is pretty good, and it was all well laid out and easy to read. The story itself has a bittersweetness to it, and I think if parents do read it with kids, it’d be good to be ready to have a conversation about loss, given the twist of the story.

I did see it coming, since it’s not that unusual as a story twist, but I thought it was told well (and would probably come as more of a surprise to a kid).

Overall, interesting read!

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – An Interesting Detail

Posted May 28, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – An Interesting Detail

An Interesting Detail

by Kimberly Campanello

Genres: Poetry
Pages: 80
Rating: one-star
Synopsis:

An important and timely collection spanning time and space, pain and power, from an innovative poetic voice

The poems in An Interesting Detail confront our shared, layered past (both planetary and human) and its knotty relationship to the present, stretching from today to prehistory, in a voice that is knowing and yearning, sincere and sardonic, and at times defiant. Campanello's prose poems, brief lyric outbursts, and poetic sequences ludically navigate catastrophe and sweep us up in the minutiae of everyday life, which includes pain and illness, machinations of power and moments of suspended connection.

Kimberly Campanello’s An Interesting Detail was a random choice from the National Poetry Library’s catalogue, which I’m using to help me try out new poets and broaden my horizons a bit.

The collection is mostly made up of prose poetry, and unfortunately I’m not a fan of the style at all: there are some interesting images, linked by non-sequiturs, and I found that deeply frustrating. It felt disjointed for the sake of being disjointed, unintelligible for the sake of being unintelligible, and I just couldn’t get into it — in theory, I like prose poems (and have always liked writing them), but these just felt like they went nowhere.

As ever, since this is poetry, it could be a defect on my part — failing to understand the poet, or what the poem in question was trying to do. Still, not my thing.

Rating: 1/5 (“didn’t like it”)

Tags: , , ,

Divider

WWW Wednesday

Posted May 27, 2026 by Nicky in General / 1 Comment

Linking up with Taking On A World of Words.

Cover of Mistakenly Saving the Villain vol 1 by Feng Yu NieWhat have you recently finished reading?

Last night I pretty much mainlined volume one of Mistakenly Saving the Villain (Feng Yu Nie), and… this is why I hesitate to start series which haven’t been finished or fully released in translation or whatever reason there might be for me not being able to read the whole thing. I did order volume two, which is out, but volume three isn’t until the end of June, and volume four not until autumn. Sob!

As you can guess, I had fun with it — Song Qingshi and Yue Wuhuan are completely unhinged about each other, even while Song Qingshi is kinda oblivious to why either of them are that way. I am suspicious of everything about An Long, and very curious where other things are going. I will probably read volume two pretty soon after it arrives — or I hope so, anyway; I can’t always keep up the momentum.

Cover of The Unicorn Murders by John Dickson CarrWhat are you currently reading?

I’m actually currently in a state where I’m technically reading a lot of books, in that they’re marked as “currently reading”, but I haven’t touched any of them in a little bit. I think my next target to try to focus on and finish is John Dickson Carr’s The Unicorn Murders, which was this month’s British Library Crime Classic and should be a fun one. I slightly stalled at first because the main character pretty much launched the book by lying about something kinda high stakes (pretending he is indeed a spy when a mistake is made by an old acquaintance), and I hate that… but it’s classic crime, so, you know, the emotional part of things is likely to be skated over reasonably lightly. It’ll be fiiiine (they said, in hopeful tones).

Cover of Dressing the Queen: Two Hundred Years of Makers and Monarchy by Kate StrasdinWhat will you be reading next?

I think I’m going to try to focus to get the currently reading pile under control, really. It feels pretty blocked-up and like it’s unfun to have so many books on the go. Some of it might be being realistic and going “clearly it isn’t the time for this book” and deciding to DNF or put it back onto the TBR. Some of it might just be picking something to focus on — like Kate Strasdin’s Dressing the Queen, which I am in fact pretty enthusiastic about!

Tags: ,

Divider

Review – The Fourth Island

Posted May 26, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – The Fourth Island

The Fourth Island

by Sarah Tolmie

Genres: Fantasy
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Huddled in the sea off the coast of Ireland is a fourth Aran Island, a secret island peopled by the lost, findable only in moments of despair. Whether drowned at sea, trampled by Cromwell's soldiers, or exiled for clinging to the dead, no outsiders reach the island without giving in to dark emotion.

Time and again, The Fourth Island weaves a hypnotic pattern with its prose, presaging doom before walking back through the sweet and sour moments of lives not yet lost. It beautifully melds the certainty of loss with the joys of living, drawing readers under like the tide.

Belatedly posting a review of a book I wrote a while ago and somehow never posted!

The Fourth Island is a fascinating book which is clearly frustrating for a lot of people who want a story that goes from A to B to C, and comes to a solid conclusion. For me, it read like the author started with the idea of the Aran sweater whose pattern nobody recognised, and then explored from there — how could such a thing come to be? And what does that mean?

In the end, if you want a solid answer — this thing happened for that reason — then it’s somewhat unsatisfying. It’s not clear how each character who ends up on the Fourth Island gets there, why they’re chosen and not others. In part it reads like it’s questioning that: why are some people saved and not others? That is how our world works, and we always crave to know why and see a higher purpose in it, but here Tolmie makes it small: why would people be chosen to come to this tiny island when lost? And does that have a weight on the world, a cost?

It’s not a traditional fantasy story, for sure; I guess you could say it’s magic realism. There’s some beautiful writing in it, and I was totally absorbed in the mystery of it, without needing it to also give me the answers.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , ,

Divider

Top Ten Tuesday: Favourite Books by Favourite Authors

Posted May 26, 2026 by Nicky in General / 20 Comments

This week’s Top Ten Tuesday theme is a tricky one: listing not only your top ten favourite authors, but also choosing your favourite book of theirs! I can’t promise that mine’s a definitive list — I’m certain I’m missing out authors I would smack my forehead about if you reminded me. But it is a list of some of my favourite authors, and my favourites among their books.

Cover of The Tombs of Atuan by Ursula Le Guin Cover of Heaven Official's Blessing vol 6 by MXTX Cover of Band Sinister by K.J. Charles Cover of Tropic of Serpents by Marie Brennan Cover of Death of an Author by E.C.R. Lorac

  1. Ursula Le Guin: The Tombs of Atuan.
    The problem with picking a favourite among Le Guin’s stories is the sheer number and range of them, but for me it isn’t really in doubt — there’s a magic in The Tombs of Atuan that got under my skin from the start, right from the beginning with Arha’s beginnings as a priestess. I love A Wizard of Earthsea very much too, don’t get me wrong, and that book informs how I try to approach life and dealing with my anxiety… but I’d still say The Tombs of Atuan beats it out as a favourite.
  2. Mo Xiang Tong Xiu: Heaven Official’s Blessing.
    This is a really tough pick, because The Scum Villain’s Self-Saving System was my introduction to danmei as a whole, and I’ll probably look back at it as formative to my reading tastes. And there are aspects of Heaven Official’s Blessing that are frustrating (the flashbacks). Still, in terms of the depth of the characters, the different arcs and stories that wind through it, and of course the love between Hua Cheng and Xie Lian, I think it’s probably my favourite.
  3. KJ Charles: Band Sinister.
    I love a lot of Charles’ work, and I’m not sure Band Sinister would always be my recommendation for a starting point (though it’s not a bad one, it’s more purely a romance than most of her work). But it’s one I have very fond memories of, including the first time I read it while I couldn’t sleep, giggling and curling my toes in glee at it while trying not to wake up my wife!
  4. Marie Brennan: Tropic of Serpents.
    It’s hard to pick one book out of this series, really, because they all build up the story to a heck of an ending. Still, Tropic of Serpents is the one that changed my opinion from liking the series well enough to continue and see where it went to being eager for each new book, and deeply invested in Isabella and her adventures — and the different types of dragon she studies and discovers.
  5. E.C.R. Lorac: Death of an Author.
    This is a bit atypical among Lorac’s novels and possibly wouldn’t be the one I’d recommend to others — but it’s the one I’ve rated the highest, and it probably counts as my favourite if I had to name a single one. Mostly what I love about her work is the way she sets up characters who feel like people you can root for (or dislike), rather than cyphers, and the sense of deep connection to places… neither of which are so present here, because this is just a really solid mystery that had me on the hop the whole time. Mostly, her Inspector Macdonald books would be where I’d turn for a satisfying mystery I can care about, but this one is pretty dang good.
  6. Dorothy L. Sayers: Strong Poison.
    This one has strong competition from several other books in the series, including Have His Carcase (which has a great opening paragraph)… but ultimately I think I love this one best, as Peter puzzles out the murder method, the motive, and the means while racing against the clock because of Harriet’s trial. The banter between the two of them is amazing, as are the moments when it breaks down and Harriet is just human and scared. For me, it finished the work that Clouds of Witness started in making me care deeply about Peter (who spends that book trying to save his brother from hanging), and introduced a heck of a love interest for him, a fascinating character in her own right.
  7. Mary Stewart: Madam, Will You Talk?
    I remember reading The Gabriel Hounds while being in Italy, which was just after I finished my first degree (yeesh, so long ago now). She’s just so good at evoking the sense of a place: brightness, dust, old ruins both cared for and not, dark and smoky rooms, a busy market, a cool drink in the shade… Madam, Will You Talk? is probably my favourite, though I couldn’t tell you why, especially because the love interest starts things off very badly and frightens the main character for way too much of a book. Maybe it’s just that Charity is really cool, with her quick thinking and fast driving.
  8. Ann Leckie: Ancillary Mercy.
    It’s hard to pick a favourite from this trilogy, because they are all part of the same story, and it’s the whole that I really love. Maybe this should really just be considered picking the whole trilogy. It’s so inventive, and I love the way that Leckie has thought through the world of the story — events outside Breq’s knowledge or interest are going on simultaneously, a whole sprawling empire is living, dying, struggling, and every so often we get little reminders of that. Still, Mercy might be a favourite, due to the way the cultures on Athoek Station are introduced and inform the plot, and the strategic annoying queueing which speaks to my oh-so-British heart.
  9. Cat Sebastian: We Could Be So Good.
    It’s a little hard to choose between this and You Should Be So Lucky, both of which are really, really good. The characters and romances just feel so carefully built, until you can’t help but root for them in their messy glory, and hope that things will turn out well for them and that they can find a way to carve out happiness — which they realistically find, even given the period they live in, without it glossing over the dangers and worries they face as well.
  10. Jo Walton: Farthing.
    This was the first book I read by Walton, and combines alternative history with a mystery story that nods to Sayers. Sadly, the rising fascism of the story has only become more relevant, even while the book has slipped out of view a bit. I highly recommend the trilogy, though Farthing is my favourite. Walton’s told a lot of different stories, and I could also be very tempted to give the nod to Among Others (which is a book that felt like it saw me) or My Real Children or the Tir Tanagiri books… and Lifelode is so rich and underappreciated too (and sees me as well, in a different way: my lifelode is learning, it’s pretty clear, and reading Lifelode made me think, y’know what, that’s okay). But ultimately, Farthing was where my experiences with Walton’s books started, and it’s terrifyingly and urgently relevant.

Cover of Strong Poison by Dorothy L. Sayers Cover of Madam, Will You Talk? by Mary Stewart Cover of Ancillary Mercy by Ann Leckie Cover of We Could Be So Good by Cat Sebastian Cover of Farthing, by Jo Walton

Oof, I’ve been super talkative again — I hope my musings have been of interest, and I would definitely love to hear others’ thoughts if you have the time to stop and chat!

Tags: ,

Divider

Review – Guardian, vol 1

Posted May 26, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Guardian, vol 1

Guardian

by Priest

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels, Mystery, Romance
Pages: 408
Series: Guardian #1
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Zhao Yunlan heads up a covert division of the Ministry of Public Security that deals with the strange and unusual, blurring the line between the mortal realm and the Netherworld. His cocky, casual attitude conceals both a sharp mind and an arsenal of mystical tools and arcane knowledge.

While investigating a gruesome death at a local university, Zhao Yunlan crosses paths with the reserved Professor Shen Wei. Zhao Yunlan is immediately intrigued by Shen Wei’s good looks and intense gaze, and the attraction between them is immediate and powerful, even as Shen Wei tries to keep his distance. Shen Wei and his secrets are a puzzle Zhao Yunlan feels compelled to solve as mysterious circumstances throw them together, and their connection becomes impossible to deny.


Wow, volume one of Priest’s Guardian certainly brings the yearning. I wasn’t entirely sure at first, since Zhao Yunlan’s mooning after Shen Wei seemed a little one-sided (though there were some hints), but after about halfway through it’s clear there’s more going on and that the yearning is more than mutual — if anything, Shen Wei is more deeply in love than Zhao Yunlan.

Shen Wei had been restraining himself for too long. In the perfect silence, he couldn’t help letting go for once. Lying there with Zhao Yunlan so tantalisingly near, his thoughts spun out of control. He imagined gathering that warm body close, pressing kisses to those eyes, that hair, those lips… tasting and partaking of every part.
He imagined possessing Zhao Yunlan utterly.
The fantasy alone was enough to make Shen Wei’s breathing unsteady. He yearned with the desperate fervour of someone dreaming of hot soup as they froze to death.
But he didn’t move a muscle. Just looking at Zhao Yunlan and thinking about him was seemingly enough.

Ooof. Wow.

The relationship between Zhao Yunlan and Shen Wei is definitely a draw, but I’m enjoying the world and story as well: I figured out the identity of the Emissary ahead of time, but a lot of the details remain unclear, along with Zhao Yunlan’s last life, etc, and the various artefacts that Zhao Yunlan is presumably going to keep being drawn into encountering.

I will say that there’s a lot of stuff about Daqing (a cat) being really fat, calling him fatty, etc. The character isn’t solely comic relief and clearly has power of his own, and Zhao Yunlan insults everyone (especially Guo Changcheng, whose anxiety and awkwardness is frequently mocked), but… even the narrative gets in on calling Daqing fat all the time, and it’s definitely worth being aware of, as it’s clearly meant somewhat negatively/comically.

I’m definitely eager for the second book, in any case — I love Shen Wei, the yearning is palpable, and I’m curious where the story goes as well.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Fantasy with Friends: Movie Talk

Posted May 25, 2026 by Nicky in General / 11 Comments

Fantasy With Friends: A Disccusion Meme hosted by Pages Unbound

Once more it’s Monday, and time for Fantasy with Friends! The prompts are hosted at Pages Unbound, and this time we’re talking about movie adaptations:

Are there any fantasy books that you think had a movie adaptation that was even better than the book? If not, what are some of your favorite and least screen favorite adaptations?

I don’t really watch movies (or TV), so I am poorly equipped to answer this one! I did watch more when I was younger, but nowadays I’m lucky if I watch a single movie in a whole year (and I’ve watched one for 2026: Rian Johnson’s Wake Up Dead Man, which is great but not fantasy). Sooo this will be a short post.

We’ve discussed The Lord of the Rings before, and I think that’s a broadly good adaptation that made a couple of choices I didn’t love (e.g. regarding Faramir’s character, but also the omission of Glorfindel in order to give Arwen a bigger part to play). There were reasons those choices were made, often really good reasons, and I’m not a purist about it: adaptations are adaptations, and can change things without that being a bad thing.

Another example, though not a movie, is the BBC radioplay adaptation of The Dark is Rising — the one that aired when I was a kid, not the more recent one — which cut out most of Will’s brothers and simplified his family significantly, but managed to nonetheless capture the sense of threat, struggle and wonder of that book beautifully. The casting was amazing, especially Merriman and the Rider. I love Will’s family, but I accept the need to adapt and the ways that was good for the story.

On the other hand, we don’t speak of The Seeker, which I never even tried to watch because it was apparent even from trailers that it completely mangled the story.

Studio Ghibli have mixed examples for me: their adaptation of Ursula Le Guin’s Earthsea books just isn’t worth watching to me, as it didn’t stay remotely true to the spirit of the story. Buuut though their adaptation of Diana Wynne Jones’ Howl’s Moving Castle is completely different from the book, losing aspects that are deeply important to me (Howl’s Welshness, for instance), I love that one — even though it adds in themes that I don’t think are there in the original. Maybe it’s because Howl and Sophie are true to their book-selves, despite all the changes, as is their relationship.

I had more to say than I thought, though not about any recent movies! I’m kinda curious to see what other people think and what adaptations they think have been worth the time.

Tags: , ,

Divider

Review – Dinosaur Sanctuary, vol 2

Posted May 24, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – Dinosaur Sanctuary, vol 2

Dinosaur Sanctuary

by Itaru Kinoshita

Genres: Manga, Science Fiction
Pages: 164
Series: Dinosaur Sanctuary #2
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

A richly detailed manga about a rookie zookeeper learning how to care for dinosaurs of all shapes and sizes, sure to delight dinosaur lovers!
Dinosaurs are alive! In 1946, a remote island was discovered where dinosaurs never went extinct. Through breeding and genetic manipulation, dinosaur populations increased and dino-mania reached a fever pitch worldwide...until a certain terrible incident occurred. Afterward, dinosaur reserves like Enoshima Dinoland fell on hard times. Enter Suma Suzume, a kindhearted rookie dino-keeper! Can she be the one to save Dinoland from extinction?

The potential drama from the first volume of Itaru Kinoshita’s Dinosaur Sanctuary passes over really quickly, actually, giving us a bit more of the characters’ backstories and motivations without major personal drama.

It’s still overall fairly low-stakes, with one of the main stories being Suma getting to look after a baby dinosaur who imprinted on her. Benkei is adorable, and Suma’s arc of understanding what Benkei’s good at and what might be good for him was pretty fun.

It remains really cute and fun, including the dinosaur expert’s bits. I love that they had a consultant to make sure the facts and art look right (as far as we can be sure).

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – A Boy Named Rose

Posted May 23, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – A Boy Named Rose

A Boy Named Rose

by Gaëlle Geniller

Genres: Graphic Novels, Historical Fiction
Pages: 212
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Paris. The 1920s. Rose is a boy and, like all the girls he's spent time with since he was born, he wants to dance at "Le Jardin", the cabaret managed by his mother.

As Rose blossoms into a young man, he discovers love and tries to find his place in a society that's not ready to welcome true love between two men.

Gaëlle Geniller’s A Boy Named Rose is really, really cute. I like the art and colours, and I like how protective and warm the found family at Le Jardin feels. Rose’s character is nuanced, never perfect, but overall positive and sweet, and thoughtful about his identity (which comes out when he’s interviewed). It’s not that he doesn’t get any pushback for being male and wearing dresses or dancing on stage like the women, or even quite that he dismisses it, but he takes his own perspective on it.

I also liked that his relationship with Aimé wasn’t explicitly romantic all the time, that it seemed to be companionship above all for the two of them, with potential for something more — and perhaps a hint of Aimé being interested in how free Rose feels to be who is, and maybe even longing for it himself (even if he doesn’t express it in the same way).

There’s a line from the summary that made me think it was going to be significantly angstier than it actually is: “As Rose blossoms into a young man, he discovers love and tries to find his place in a society that’s not ready to welcome true love between two men.”

But… nope. Mostly it’s gentle and happy. It’s not perfect, and sometimes Rose gets upset or afraid, but… his family and Aimé are there to help him.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Stacking the Shelves & The Sunday Post

Posted May 23, 2026 by Nicky in General / 26 Comments

Happy Saturday from surprisingly sunny Yorkshire! At least, it was a surprise to me, after all the grey and rainy days. I’m not looking forward to the high temperature forecast for Monday, but this morning I’m sat by the window with a fresh breeze, so things feel pretty good.

Books acquired this week

A quiet week on this front, but I did just borrow a couple more books from the National Poetry Library for the weekend! So here they are: first the translated poetry I read earlier in the week, and the two I just picked up for weekend reading.

Cover of Flowers of a Moment by Ko Un

Cover of Eleanor Among the Saints by Rachel Mann Cover of The Home Child by Liz Berry

I wasn’t initially drawn to The Home Child, and then I spotted it was a verse novel. Given that I did enjoy The Black Flamingo, I thought I’d give a totally different verse novel a chance too and see what I think. Not sure if the National Poetry Library has any others I might be interested in, but I’ll take a look next time I have a loan slot free.

Posts from this week

Let’s start with the reviews as usual:

As ever, those aren’t the books I’ve been reading this week, for the most part. Those are below in the next section!

Aaand the other posts:

What I’m reading

It wasn’t a great week for reading, via a combination of getting a bit blocked by a book I wasn’t settling down with but was stubborn to finish plus my new crochet project. The former I’m finally just 50 pages or so from finishing (and things are coming together better than I’d feared), and the latter… well, it’s still going to steal a lot of my time, but I understand the technique and how to read/interpret the pattern now, so each row goes a little faster and smoother than at the start.

Anyway, here’s what I did manage to read since my last post!

Cover of Paper Planes by Jennie Wood Cover of The Weather Wheel by Mimi Khalvati Cover of The Brothers by Sheelue Yang Cover of Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint vol 10 by Umi, SleepyC and singNsong Cover of Flowers of a Moment by Ko Un

Which looks like quite a bit, but they were all fairly short reads, especially The Brothers, which is a kid’s book — I’d got curious about it because it’s a retelling of a Hmong myth, and references to the Hmong have come up in various bits of reading lately.

For this weekend, I hope to finish Cecilia Edward’s An Ancient Witch’s Guide to Modern Dating and Tom Service’s A History of the World in 50 Pieces. I’d love to fit in reading some comics and poetry around that as well, but (as ever) it’s down to my whim. There’s also a possibility I’ll just snag something random from the books I’m currently reading, curl up and go to town on finishing it. I’d love for that to happen, because I am starting to feel a biiiit overwhelmed by the number of books I have on the go, heh.

But of course there’ll be plenty of casual video games and crochet, too. Or so I hope!

Linking up with Reading Reality’s Stacking the Shelves, Caffeinated Reviewer’s The Sunday Post, the Sunday Salon over at Readerbuzz, and It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? at The Book Date.

Tags: , ,

Divider