Genre: Mystery

Review – Murder in the Maze

Posted October 19, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Murder in the Maze

Murder in the Maze

by J.J. Connington

Genres: Crime, Mystery
Pages: 240
Rating: two-stars
Synopsis:

When twin brothers Roger and Neville Shandon are murdered by poisoned darts in Whistlefield's famous hedge maze, Sir Clinton Driffield arrives to restore order. He finds two terrified witnesses - visitors to the estate - and clues aplenty in this brilliantly conceived and meticulously realized country-house mystery.

J.J. Connington’s Murder in the Maze is the second book I’ve read by him, if I recall correctly, and I admit I’d expected slightly better from what I remembered of The Ha-Ha Case — though admittedly that was a later book. This is the first one featuring Sir Clinton Driffield, and it suffered from both culprit and detective being incredibly obvious.

There are a few efforts at misdirection that just don’t come off because they’re incredibly obvious. I think the story does try to lampshade this a bit by the “Watson” character realising what Driffield’s up to belatedly, but… the reader understood chapters and chapters ago, and much of what’s coming up is obvious too. I could almost predict every step, from the fake attacks to a side character’s romantic feelings, and it was clumsy as well that several characters (like the two who find the bodies at the start, along with the man they find in the maze) simply slip out of sight.

The whole thing isn’t particularly ingenious, in part because it relies on ye olde exotic poisons (curare, in this case), which immediately narrows the field due to access. It’s never pointed out that, for example, it rules out a particular character — but where would he have got curare from?

I don’t want to spoiler people who might be interested, so I won’t go into too many specifics — suffice it to say, I was disappointed with the quality of this one, and it wore out its welcome pretty quickly. Besides that, the dramatic denouement is then somewhat spoiled by a lengthy debriefing (detective speaks to the various former suspects to explain everything) and by the detective taking justice into his own hands because he knows best, a bugbear of mine in these stories.

Rating: 2/5 (“it was okay”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Duke of York’s Steps

Posted October 10, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – The Duke of York’s Steps

The Duke of York's Steps

by Henry Wade

Genres: Crime, Mystery
Pages: 280
Series: Inspector Poole #1
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Henry Wade's The Duke of York's Steps intricately weaves a tapestry of suspense, intrigue, and social commentary set against the backdrop of post-World War I England. The novel is marked by Wade's sharp prose and attention to psychological depth, creating multifaceted characters whose lives intersect in unexpected ways. The narrative unfolds with a sense of foreboding, as the protagonist navigates the underbelly of society, exposing themes of loyalty, betrayal, and the societal changes of the time, showcasing both the personal and communal challenges faced by the British populace in a rapidly evolving landscape. Henry Wade, notable for his mastery of detective fiction, brings his own experiences and keen observations of English society to his writing. Having served as a soldier during the war, Wade deftly captures the disillusionment that many felt upon returning home. His deep understanding of the human psyche and social dynamics informs the nuanced characters and plot twists that are hallmarks of his style. As an accomplished author whose works reflect a keen awareness of contemporary issues, Wade's insights elevate his narrative beyond mere entertainment. Readers seeking a gripping blend of mystery and social exploration will find "The Duke of York's Steps" to be an essential addition to their collection. Wade's engaging narrative invites the reader into a world rich with complexity and moral ambiguity, challenging them to ponder the implications of personal choices against the broader societal shifts of the period. This is not just a novel of suspense but a commentary on the human condition, making it a compelling read for those interested in literature that reflects both timeless themes and specific historical contexts.

The Duke of York’s Steps is a classic crime story written by Henry Wade, an alias for a baronet (Sir Henry Aubrey-Fletcher, 6th Baronet) who wrote a surprising number of detective novels which are surprisingly hard to find — I got this one via Kobo Plus US, and none of his books seem to be available on Kobo at all in the UK, and precious few elsewhere. I’d have expected a crime writer baronet to have a bit more novelty value!

In any case, I quite enjoyed The Duke of York’s Steps; it’s fairly slow and methodical, with Inspector Poole working carefully to unpick the mystery and avoid jumping to too-obvious conclusions. There are a few oddities, like all the male characters being attracted to Inez Fratten, daughter of the deceased… including her own “half-brother” (who, in the course of the story, is revealed to be no blood relation of hers — and almost as soon as he learns that, they’re clearly headed somewhere romantic, which is more than a bit weird, even if she already knew).

I mostly found myself liking the characters, at least in the limited sense where they seemed enough like decent and interesting people to give me firm opinions about who I wanted to be the culprit, and who I decidedly did not. I was kind of sad about the outcome, though it made perfect sense once that piece was finally revealed. I’d been to some degree “taken in” by that character; overall, the way it works itself out is pretty neat, if dramatic, albeit with a convenient “instant karma” death that adds little.

Overall, I’d happily read more of Wade’s work — if I could! It’s not fast-paced stuff, but I enjoy this kind of methodical mystery.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Rasp

Posted September 27, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – The Rasp

The Rasp

by Philip MacDonald

Genres: Crime, Mystery
Pages: 240
Series: Colonel Gethryn #1
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

The Rasp introduces the world to the amazing Anthony Gethryn, an ex-secret service agent, and occasional newspaper correspondent. He is assigned to cover the story of a cabinet minister, John Hoode, who was found murdered in the library of his country house, battered to death with a wood-rasp. Scotland yard has only one suspect Hoode’s secretary Alan Deacon. But Gethryn is convinced that Deacon did not do it. To prove that he’ll have to investigate himself and find the real killer. But everyone else who might have had a motive has a cast-iron alibi. Can he crack the case and bring the killer to justice?

I picked up Philip MacDonald’s The Rasp because he’s a Golden Age crime writer I hadn’t read yet, and I do love to read even an indifferent classic crime story when I’m in a bit of a funk. This book introduces his series detective, Anthony Gethryn, who ends up being asked to enquire in a private capacity by a friend who works for a newspaper. He ends up more deeply involved than that after a love-at-first-sight moment with someone who seems to be part of the whole mystery, leading to a couple of dramatic moments.

All in all, I quite liked it; it reminded me most of Sayers’ work, in part because Gethryn’s very prone to quotation and piffle. I find him somewhat less charming than Wimsey, all the same, perhaps because the two characters are handled in different ways. Gethryn’s meant to be charming and plausible and people are (for the most part) enjoying his tendency to quotation, and overall he comes across as maybe a bit too perfect and a bit too much to everyone’s taste — while Wimsey is both presented as getting irritating sometimes (which he surely would in real life) and with self-deprecation that somehow helps the reader swallow it all and find him charming anyway. Sayers is probably the better writer, even if she was a bit too in love with Wimsey herself.

Still, it was entertaining. I’d say the murderer is a bit of a cheat because I don’t think the evidence is presented to the reader with enough weight to really be fair-play, though I did myself guess who it was going to be based on who I was pretty sure it wasn’t. Someone else says that you can’t guess because the person is never investigated, and that’s sort of true. I did figure out what happened with the titular rasp before it actually got to that, though, so there are clues.

The denouement being mostly a long letter from Gethryn that elucidates everything a bit really slows everything down and wasn’t the best choice, while the romances are fairly shrug. Like Wimsey, Gethryn falls in love more or less at first sight, but he doesn’t nearly earn his happy ending in the same way.

It’s perhaps unfair comparing this to Sayers, given she was deservedly one of the Queens of Crime, and is a favourite of mine besides… but it’s the comparison that felt inevitable given the givens. It’s still fun, all the same.

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – Tenant for Death

Posted September 20, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Tenant for Death

Tenant for Death

by Cyril Hare

Genres: Crime, Mystery
Pages: 200
Series: Inspector Mallet #1
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Two young estate agent's clerks are sent to check an inventory on a house in Daylesford Gardens, South Kensington. Upon arrival, they find an unlisted item - a corpse. Furthermore, the mysterious tenant, Colin James, has disappeared.

In a tale which uncovers many of the seedier aspects of the world of high finance, Hare also introduces his readers to the formidable Inspector Mallett of Scotland Yard.

Cyril Hare’s Tenant for Death was apparently adapted from a play, but it works well in the novel format too, and introduces Hare’s Inspector Mallett (not to be confused with Mary Fitt’s Superintendent Mallett — and I think there may be another Mallett in classic detectives stories somewhere, too?). Like Suicide Excepted, which I actually read first (the order doesn’t really matter as there’s little character/plot progression), it’s worked out pretty cleverly, though does less by way of character study.

To say too much is to spoil it, as usual with a mystery, but the whole thing hinges on one useful coincidence — in a way that works really well rather than feeling contrived. The rest is a fair amount of routine questioning, following the police as they try to work out whodunnit and why. There are plenty of motives floating around, since the deceased is a scammer and twister, and is thoroughly unlikeable in the tradition of victims throughout vintage crime stories.

I think Hare does actually have a decent touch with character, even when they’re a bit sketched in: when it came to Suicide Excepted I was quite invested in what happened to Anne, and found here that I was holding my breath (metaphorically) to figure out what Harper’s involvement was, because he seemed like a decent guy.

Overall it’s a little bit less engaging and innovative than Suicide Excepted, but very solid; I’m glad I’ve given Cyril Hare’s work a try!

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – Suicide Excepted

Posted September 15, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – Suicide Excepted

Suicide Excepted

by Cyril Hare

Genres: Crime, Mystery
Pages: 220
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Inspector Mallett's stay at the country house hotel of Pendlebury Old Hall has been a letdown, room, food and service, and he longs for it to end. His last trial is to listen when a boorish old man, whose family once owned the house, joins his table. The next day the man is dead and Mallett finds himself investigating the suspicious 'suicide'.

I can’t remember where exactly Cyril Hare’s Suicide Excepted popped up that led me to add it via Kobo Plus — maybe it was just recommended by Kobo! I hadn’t come across Hare before, at any rate, but he was writing during the Golden Age of Crime Fiction, and therefore falls into my interests pretty neatly, and picking up Suicide Excepted proved to be a good decision.

The story is a bit unusual in that it opens following a police detective who gets caught up in a mystery: someone speaks to him the night before they’re found dead in portentous tones that seem to render a verdict of suicide the most likely and sensible outcome. The book then switches to the perspective of Anne and Stephen, the man’s children, as they try to figure out a way to overturn that verdict in order to gain the man’s life insurance money.

I had two theories in mind throughout, and considered one more likely than the other just because of the structure of the book… but in the end it was my second theory which turned out to be correct, which was a nice surprise — I thought the mystery aspect was really well handled. I feel really sorry for Anne, given the way her brother and fiancé were behaving, and given how things turned out. I don’t quite understand exactly what she figured out, but she was pretty badly treated by both men all round, and I do wish we’d seen a glimpse of her moving on.

In any case, I enjoyed how it worked out and had a good time with this one; I’ll read more of Cyril Hare’s work in future.

Rating: 4/5 (“really like it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Party at No. 5

Posted August 30, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – The Party at No. 5

The Party at No. 5

by Shelley Smith

Genres: Crime, Mystery
Pages: 189
Series: British Library Crime Classics
Rating: one-star
Synopsis:

Sharing your home with an unwanted guest can be murder.

Elderly Mrs. Rampage lives alone in a large London house full of the antiques and heirlooms she’s collected over the years. But she’s struggling to cope, and as her only daughter lives thousands of miles away, she is persuaded to advertise for a housekeeper and companion. Reluctantly, she accepts the courteous and capable Mrs. Roach into No 5 to help her.

With few possessions of her own, Mrs. Roach is in desperate need of a place to stay, but she soon has her own ideas about how things should be run in the house. And as Mrs. Rampage grows increasingly protective of her knick-knacks, and pushes at the boundaries of her new companion’s personal privacy, the pair’s initially amicable relationship soon turns sour. Before long, both women are thoroughly miserable, but stuck in unhappy coexistence with nowhere else to go. When Mrs. Roach digs in and makes it her duty to stay, the lives of both women become entangled in catastrophic circumstances.

Oof, this one’s a bit tough to rate and review. The Party at No. 5 is the first book I’ve read by Shelley Smith, I think, and I can see that it’s well done: well structured, well planned, with characters that are psychologically realistic (if sometimes a bit exaggerated).

It’s also very difficult to enjoy for me personally, since I just don’t enjoy the Payment Deferred style “someone commits a crime and then tries to conceal it” shenanigans, and I don’t particularly enjoy reading about unpleasant people either. There is a certain satisfaction in watching Mrs Rampage and Mrs Roach unravel, especially the latter, revealing her self-serving thoughts and plans.

It’s also unfortunate that what’s clearly a lesbian relationship between Eleanor and Norah is treated as rather grotesque, and Eleanor’s devotion to Norah is treated as being strange. It isn’t used to justify what happens, at least, but there’s a sense that it’s part of the slow revelation of what Mrs Roach is really like to the reader, and I found it unpleasant.

I ended the book feeling vaguely begrimed and anxious, honestly; I think overall I’m going to have to go with rating based on how much I liked it, as usual, which is “not at all”. That said, for someone more interested in reading for the craft of it, it is well done in its way.

Rating: 1/5 (“didn’t like it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Album of Dr. Moreau

Posted August 27, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 4 Comments

Review – The Album of Dr. Moreau

The Album of Dr. Moreau

by Daryl Gregory

Genres: Crime, Mystery, Science Fiction
Pages: 176
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Daryl Gregory's The Album of Dr. Moreau combines the science fiction premise of the famous novel by H. G. Wells with the panache of a classic murder mystery and the spectacle of a beloved boy band.

It’s 2001, and the WyldBoyZ are the world’s hottest boy band, and definitely the world’s only genetically engineered human-animal hybrid vocal group. When their producer, Dr. M, is found murdered in his hotel room, the “boyz” become the prime suspects. Was it Bobby the ocelot (“the cute one”), Matt the megabat (“the funny one”), Tim the Pangolin (“the shy one”), Devin the bonobo (“the romantic one”), or Tusk the elephant (“the smart one”)?

Las Vegas Detective Luce Delgado has only twenty-four hours to solve a case that goes all the way back to the secret science barge where the WyldBoyZ’ journey first began—a place they used to call home.

I got surprisingly into Daryl Gregory’s The Album of Dr Moreau; I don’t actually remember where I heard about it or why I picked it up, but I know I added it to my Kobo Plus a while ago, and decided to read it on something of a whim. I expected something… I don’t know, less serious, even given the source material and the fact that it’s a sci-fi murder mystery: given the concept of a boyband of animal-human hybrids, which the story fully leans into, it could have been considerably wackier.

But no, it goes for something sincere, even while there are silly animal puns and cutesy bits with Bobby O, the ocelot band member, and with the detective’s kid. By sincere, I definitely don’t mean that it’s po-faced or anything like that: at times it is silly.

But it also engages with the darkness of the original story of Doctor Moreau’s island, and with the seriousness of a murder mystery (even as it rejects T.S. Eliot’s “rules” for detective fiction, which, good). The band members were abused and have been exploited, and the solution to the story comes out of the darkness of the past, one which looms up behind them slowly even as the detective sometimes seems to be dealing with an entire circus.

I don’t think I should say more about the resolution of the story, but overall, I found it pretty satisfying and well done!

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Magic-Lantern Murders

Posted August 7, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – The Magic-Lantern Murders

The Magic-Lantern Murders

by Carter Dickson, John Dickson Carr

Genres: Crime, Mystery
Pages: 269
Series: British Library Crime Classics
Rating: two-stars
Synopsis:

On the eve of his wedding to Evelyn Cheyne, who he met and fell in love with during the course of The Unicorn Murders, former spy Kenwood Blake is summoned to Devon by spymaster Sir Henry Merrivale, and asked to take part in an undercover operation. Despite being assured he’ll be back in London in time for the wedding the following morning, Blake is unconvinced.

Once in Torquay, he is sent to investigate Paul Hogenauer, a local scientist of German heritage, who has been dabbling in spiritualism and the occult – a man Merrivale and Devon’s Chief Constable Colonel Charters suspect of anti-British espionage. But, on entering his house, he finds Hogenauer dead in a chair in his sitting room, showing all the signs of strychnine poisoning.

When he finds Hogenauer’s friend and confidant Dr Keppel dead in his hotel room in Bristol, also apparently from strychnine poisoning, he has a seemingly impossible mystery to unravel. Can he solve the clues, bring the killer to justice and still get to the church in time to get married in the morning?

After a while, and a few false starts, I did get into some of Carter Dickson AKA John Dickson Carr’s work, but it transpires I haven’t wholly lost my distaste for them. This is one of the Henry Merrivale ones, which are already not my favourites, and my best description of it while reading was that I felt like the soundtrack should be “Yakety Sax”. Coincidences (the worst possible ones for the protagonist) abound, sometimes for the mystery and sometimes for comic effect, and the whole thing is spent running up and down the country chasing will-o-the-wisps.

It perhaps doesn’t help that I don’t find Kenwood Blake that enticing as a character: spending The Unicorn Murders with him was quite enough, thank you. I wouldn’t have minded a bit more focus on Evelyn Cheyne, but she’s just “the wench”, convenient for bringing along a change of clothes and sounding the alert, it seems. Bah.

At least I liked Stone, even though that took a while to solidify for me: he seems a good man.

I am very wary of this kind of ending, as well — I shan’t say too much about it because of spoilers, but I don’t like it when detectives take the law into their own hands, and I especially didn’t like how it was played here.

Overall, not one I can recommend, even though aspects of the mystery were interesting (if you stripped back some of the Yakety Sax moments).

Rating: 2/5 (“it was okay”)

Tags: , , , , , ,

Divider

Review – A Case of Fear and Favour

Posted August 2, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – A Case of Fear and Favour

A Case of Fear and Favour

by Sally Smith

Genres: Crime, Historical Fiction, Mystery
Pages: 368
Series: The Trials of Gabriel Ward #3
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

A priceless medieval book has been stolen from the Inner Temple. The librarian has been murdered at his desk. Once again, Sir Gabriel Ward KC must provide answers.

Gabriel meanwhile is preparing to represent a tiny sweetshop in Brighton brought to the brink of ruin by the postponed coronation of King Edward VII. Winning the case will save the sweetshop and change the law for ever. Yet for once he does not object to being pressed into acting as detective, because another miscarriage of justice may be on the cards.

The Temple authorities already have their prime suspects: Jitendra Shah, an Indian law student, and Lesley Roberts, the scandalously female assistant librarian, neither of whom fit the profile of a 'true' member of the Temple. Both were in the library at the time the murder must have taken place. Each claims not to have seen the other. At least one of them must be lying. But does this make them a killer?

Gabriel is convinced there is far more to this case than meets the eye. And in matters of murder, Gabriel is very seldom wrong…

I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

When I got offered an eARC of Sally Smith’s latest Gabriel Ward book, A Case of Fear and Favour, there was noooo way I wasn’t jumping on it right away. I’ve loved the previous books and their loving but sometimes critical depiction of life in the Inner Temple, the ancient rules and regulations of the lawyers there, and of course, of Gabriel Ward himself, a bit stuffy but ultimately a very good man.

Over the course of the novels, Gabriel’s found himself getting more involved in the wider world beyond the Inner Temple, and that results here in him amazing everyone and himself by taking a pro bono case. I love that we get an explanatory note afterwards discussing the real law around that case and the historical precedent, which is carefully considered!

Other than Gabriel’s pro bono case, there’s also a mystery in the library of the Inner Temple, with the death of the librarian and the disappearance of some priceless documents. It turns out to be (unsurprisingly, given it’s a novel) not unconnected with Gabriel’s case, as well, and everything proceeds veeery neatly.

I enjoyed the introduction of the characters Lesley Roberts (a proto-feminist) and Jitendra (a figure based partially on some of the experiences of Gandhi), which tugged Gabriel out into the world just a little more, and opened his eyes to more injustices he’d never considered before.

Overall, a good entry to the series, and definitely a series I recommend to mystery lovers — especially if being set in a rather odd location (the Inner Temple, a long-standing inn of court) and around the time of the delayed coronation of King Edward VII appeals!

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Review – Sweet Poison

Posted July 11, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Sweet Poison

Sweet Poison

by Mary Fitt

Genres: Crime, Mystery
Pages: 198
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

Sweet Poison takes its title from a line in King John: "Sweet, sweet, sweet poison for the age's tooth". It refers not only to the fact that the central character dies of poison, thought to be self-administered, but also to the fact that this character is a man obsessed with the past.

Augustus Gale was a man in love - in love with a woman of genius who had been dead for over a century. This macabre devotion poisoned both his own life and the lives of those around him: his son and daughter, his beautiful second wife, and even his devoted mother. Yet it was a strictly confined obsession, and when a party of archaeologists sought permission to excavate a Roman mosaic pavement on Augustus's land, they were met with blunt and contemptuous refusal. It might be said that Augustus Gale was a man who deserved to die, but if so, whose was the hand that killed him and with what motive?

I’ve been eager to read more of Mary Fitt’s work for a while, after really enjoying The Banquet Ceases, so I was glad to see a bunch on Kobo Plus. Sweet Poison appealed because it’s set on an archaeological dig, and the archaeological conundrum (a mosaic which passes below a boundary wall and into a private estate) offers one potential motive for the murder that follows.

I must admit, so far The Banquet Ceases has been my favourite; in both Strong Poison and Clues to Christabel, the female characters were almost universally offputting — in retrospect, there’s a similar problem in The Banquet Ceases, except that the main character’s wife is alright, and I hadn’t read enough of Fitt’s work to see a pattern yet. It’s not that the male characters are perfectly likeable either, but there’s something unhinged about most of her female characters in a way that’s starting to feel a bit samey to me — and though Dulcibella is level-headed and cares deeply about her children, and could be an interesting character given room to shine, her main object is escape and once that’s attained, she quickly discards Roger and exits the story. We see more of Cornelia, and, well…

Fitt did a pretty great job of setting up an atmosphere, in part because of that growing unease about the sanity of one of the female characters, and the way it all worked made sense and hung together well… but, yeah, I’m starting to wonder if Fitt liked women. Which is kind of a funny thing to say about a lesbian writer!

I’m still enjoying her books, and the mix of settings and set-ups for the mysteries, but… yeah. I’m hoping to see her do some more interesting things with her female characters.

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider