Review – Solo Leveling, vol 5

Posted May 19, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Solo Leveling, vol 5

Solo Leveling

by Chugong

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels
Pages: 272
Series: Solo Leveling (light novel) #5
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Jinwoo's received some amazing gifts from the system, but the latest one might prove to be the greatest one yet—a key to the double dungeon where it all started. Perhaps a second visit might provide him with answers for once. He's got some time to kill until he can use the item though, but before he can tackle another gate, unexpected movement from the shadow soldiers guarding Jinah sets his alarm bells ringing...

I’d slightly misremembered how things would come together in volume five of Chugong’s Solo Leveling, so I didn’t quite get the longer-form explanations I was craving — though those will come with time. Various things happen in this book, but the main feature is Jinwoo’s return to Cartenon Temple, to come face to face with the person who created the system.

I really loved the scene with the other hunters leaving Jinwoo to sort everything out and just smoking, tearing up and blaming the smoky atmosphere. There is some genuine tension in this volume — we’ve heard dark warnings about the nature of Jinwoo’s power, after all, and we see part of this volume through the eyes of characters like Haein and Jinchul — and that scene is a lovely way of showing its release.

Of course, there’s more going on, and the world doesn’t solely revolve around Jinwoo. We’re beginning to see a much larger plot taking shape here, and I can’t wait to get to those bits.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Top Ten Tuesday: Favourite Secondary/Minor Characters

Posted May 19, 2026 by Nicky in General / 11 Comments

This week’s theme from Top Ten Tuesday is all about secondary/minor characters, and I love it — secondary and minor characters can add so much to a world, help to flesh out the major characters, and bring in interesting themes and ideas that the main character alone can’t support.

Sooo let’s dig into some favourites.

Cover of The Goblin Emperor by Katherine Addison Cover of A Natural History of Dragons by Marie Brennan Cover of Heaven Official's Blessing by MXTX Cover of The Scum Villain's Self-Saving System vol 3 by MXTX Cover of volume one of Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation by Mo Xiang Tong Xiu

  1. Csevet Aisava, from The Goblin Emperor (Katherine Addison).
    He appears early in the story and from that point on, he’s constantly in support of Maia, helping him find his feet in the court and enacting his will in the most efficient way possible. We don’t see a lot of his inner life, but we see enough tantalising glimpses to know that he has one, and his competence and loyalty are very enticing. I’d love to know more about Csevet.
  2. Tom Wilker, from The Memoirs of Lady Trent (Marie Brennan).
    Wilker’s start in A Natural History of Dragons isn’t a terribly promising one: he comes across as trying to gatekeep Isabella’s part in her husband’s expedition, and disrespectful of her suggestions and the expertise she can offer. Over time, though, it becomes clear that he’s afraid of losing his own chance: as a lower-class scientist, he’s (at the start of the series) not taken seriously by other naturalists. As the series goes on, he and Isabella begin to support one another and work together to overcome their disadvantages, and watching his character grow is one of the satisfactions of the series for me. He and Isabella are perfect work partners, and complement one another’s strengths.
  3. Mu Qing and Feng Xin, from Heaven Official’s Blessing (Mo Xiang Tong Xiu).
    I’m discussing these two together because I don’t want to pick just one: they’re pretty inseparable, even as they seem to hate each other, and their relationship (and their relationship with Xie Lian) adds a lot of spice and complexity to the story, giving us another emotional arc beyond the testing of Xie Lian’s principles or his love story with Hua Cheng. The two generals are both loyal to Xie Lian, but in different ways, with Mu Qing’s practicality offending Feng Xin’s idealism, and Feng Xin’s privilege and lack of subtlety annoying Feng Xin at every turn. Half the time, they just need to communicate, but they’re both completely stubborn. They are complete idiots, Your Honour: I love them.
  4. Liu Qingge, from The Scum Villain’s Self-Saving System (Mo Xiang Tong Xiu).
    I am incredibly fond of Liu Qingge’s character, and I think it’s all in the way he will defend Shen Qingqiu no matter what (loyalty is my catnip; you might have noticed). To Liu Qingge, it doesn’t matter what Shen Qingqiu is accused of, or who exactly he is now that he is very clearly not the original flavour: Shen Qingqiu saved him, they are martial brothers, and so he will defend Shen Qingqiu against all comers. He doesn’t pretend that this isn’t a potential burden or beat around the bush about it: he straight-up tells Shen Qingqiu that yeah, I know, you’re afraid of being a burden to us, but we’re not afraid of that. The fact that he considers Shen Qingqiu worth it no matter what is such a big moment, such a beautiful thing to say, and I haven’t seen enough talk about that moment. He doesn’t lie and tell Shen Qingqiu he’s not a burden, he says so what if you are? I will support you anyway.
  5. Jiang Cheng, from Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation (Mo Xiang Tong Xiu).
    Jiang Cheng is a bit of an exception on this list because he isn’t loyal to Wei Wuxian, but turns against him, but I enjoy the character a lot (even if I don’t always like him) because he’s very understandable. He grows up being second fiddle to Wei Wuxian, and resentment builds up — assuaged when Wei Wuxian promises that it will always be the two of them against the world, a promise which Wei Wuxian ultimately breaks to save the Jiang clan from being associated with his actions. His resentment turns into hatred when Wei Wuxian’s actions ultimately lead to the death of their sister and her husband. Throughout the story, he is brash, irrational, and nothing like as clever as Wei Wuxian, but he loves his family deeply and in the end he comes through for Wei Wuxian in a critical moment as well, even after everything that comes between them. It’s kind of a sad thing for him that in a world where Wei Wuxian didn’t exist, Jiang Cheng would absolutely be a hero himself.
  6. Faramir, from The Lord of the Rings (J.R.R. Tolkien).
    I have to bring up Faramir here because I think reading LotR was one of the first times I latched onto a side-character so firmly. I have such opinions about the movies because of how they presented Faramir! He represents the best of his family’s line, the bravery coupled with the cleverness, the willingness to serve Gondor without the need for self-aggrandisement, and all of that made me love the character immediately. I know why it was changed for the movie, it makes loads of sense, especially for that medium — but I love the Faramir of the books, and the fact that he never sways from his path and his loyalty to Gondor, Gandalf and (ultimately) Aragorn, even as he unquestionably loves his brother and his father and does his best by them.
  7. Mervyn Bunter, from the Lord Peter Wimsey mysteries (Dorothy L. Sayers).
    To be honest, I don’t actually want more information about Bunter, and I think the character would actually agree with me that it’s not his place! Hideously classist, of course, but Bunter seems to enjoy serving Lord Peter, and putting Peter (and the world) in their proper places, and that provides some moments of comedy amidst it all. He is always loyal to Peter, though the bond between them is forged off-the-page and the reasons for it just briefly referenced, and he acts as the perfect support through the mysteries that Peter tries to unravel (and his courting of Harriet Vane as well). Somehow Bunter always has the right thing at the right moment. He’s a caricature of the perfect servant, but written in a way that I think is aware of that and sometimes gently, quietly poking fun at it: Bunter knows what he’s doing (and Sayers did too).
  8. Lord Ruthven, from the Dr Greta Helsing series (Vivian Shaw).
    I was torn between Ruthven and Fastitocalon here, but I think Ruthven’s my favourite, in part because we see a bit more of him and he’s active all throughout the first three books. (I haven’t read the newest yet, and I don’t think he plays a part in Bitter Waters that I can remember, but he’s still a major character in the trilogy.) I love the difficulty he clearly has with his long existence, and the way he’s put that to learning and helping people most of the time… but, very humanly (despite being a vampire), also sometimes just mopes. I love that he gives his unsuitable boyfriend a second chance at life and being a reasonable person, I love that he’s ready to support Greta no matter was, and I love that ultimately he’s happy to get his hands dirty (not to mention risk his unlife) helping people as well as just throwing large quantities of money at problems.
  9. Beru, from Solo Leveling (Chugong).
    I never thought I would ever, could ever, find an undead shadow minion based on a giant warrior ant so cute, but his loyalty to Jinwoo (and Jinwoo’s family), his interest in traditional court dramas and his general behaviour (plus his appearance at times in the manhwa) is just adorable. He’s not an especially complex character, so I thought about picking Yoo Jinho or Woo Jinchul instead for their unforced loyalty and support of Jinwoo… but, yeah, sorry, Beru’s cuter.
  10. Seivarden, from the Imperial Radch series (Ann Leckie).
    Seivarden is a hot mess. She isn’t a particularly good person, mired in privilege and — once that’s stripped away — self-pity. However, she learns to rely on Breq, and then comes the loyalty (you knew that word was coming, surely). She was never a favourite of Breq’s, she’s still fucking up a lot of things, but she begins to really, really try to drop her addiction, to treat people better, and to help Breq even while Breq is essentially dismantling a lot of the things that gave Seivarden her privilege and her place in the world. Ultimately, betraying Breq would be easier, but Seivarden grows and learns and tries. I love her journey, even though I do not think one would enjoy knowing Seivarden, unless Seivarden recognised one as being of equal or higher status and thus behaved appropriately within the bounds of acceptability. Once you step outside that, she’s more than a little careless.

Cover of The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien Cover of Strong Poison by Dorothy L. Sayers Cover of Strange Practice by Vivian Shaw Cover of Solo Leveling manhwa vol 14 by Dubu Cover of Ancillary Justice by Ann Leckie

Okaaaay, that’s enough of the mini-essays! I’m very curious to see the characters that other people choose.

Tags: ,

Divider

Review – The Keeper of Magical Things

Posted May 18, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – The Keeper of Magical Things

The Keeper of Magical Things

by Julie Leong

Genres: Fantasy, Romance
Pages: 368
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

An almost-mage discovers friendship—and maybe something more—in the unlikeliest of places in this delightfully charming novel from the USA Today bestselling author of The Teller of Small Fortunes.

Certainty Bulrush wants to be useful—to the Guild of Mages that took her in as a novice, to the little brother who depends on her, and to anyone else she can help. Unfortunately, her tepid magic hasn’t proven much use to anyone. When Certainty has the chance to earn her magehood via a seemingly straightforward assignment, she takes it. Nevermind that she’ll have to work with Mage Aurelia, the brilliant, unfairly attractive overachiever who’s managed to alienate everyone around her.

The two must transport minorly magical artifacts somewhere safe: Shpelling, the dullest, least magical village around. There, they must fix up an old warehouse, separate the gossipy teapots from the kind-of-flaming swords, corral an unruly little catdragon who has tagged along, and above all: avoid complications. The Guild’s uneasy relationship with citizens is at a tipping point, and the last thing needed is a magical incident.

Still, as mage and novice come to know Shpelling’s residents—and each other—they realize the Guild’s hoarded magic might do more good being shared. Friendships blossom while Certainty and Aurelia work to make Shpelling the haven it could be. But magic is fickle—add attraction and it might spell trouble.

I was really eager about The Keeper of Magical Things because I really loved Julie Leong’s previous book, The Teller of Small Fortunes. And indeed there was much to enjoy here, with this relatively low-stakes fantasy: a pretty cute romance plotline, the personal development of mostly just one of the characters, the story of a community regaining life and vigor after a disaster, and a small-stakes revenge plot. The worst thing that happens is that a tavern is burned down, with some personal consequences — this isn’t crowns and kingdoms.

I didn’t love it quite as much as The Teller of Small Fortunes, because I didn’t find it quite as creative in positioning the magic of the story. Tao’s story stuck out to be because her power of seeing the future is approached in a somewhat unique way: she tries to just see innocuous stuff, like the purchase of a new dress in the near future, but this can sometimes reveal far more than she expects. There’s less of that here: though Certainty’s power is small, the ability to speak to objects, it didn’t feel as clever/surprising, I suppose.

The characters were also a bit less compelling, while being pretty charming: Certainty’s a former farm girl with a need to prove herself and become a mage, while Aurelia is a mage who has problems relating to others, and messed up majorly. I think the most interesting magic angle in this story was actually perhaps in the necklace which helps her to focus. It really works, but it also comes with voices in her head (which sound like her parents) whispering that she’s going to be a failure, forcing her to focus through shame. For a cosy book, though, that’s quite the horrible little object.

Overall, I still had fun, don’t get me wrong — I got invested in the way the two of them ended up using the magical objects to revitalise the town of Shpelling, and in the will-they-won’t-they of their relationship. I loved that the community ultimately stuck up for them, recognising the good they brought even before — well, no more spoilers!

It winds up nicely and is a pretty satisfying read, but it didn’t stand out for me in quite the same way as Leong’s previous novel.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Fantasy with Friends: Fairytale Retellings

Posted May 18, 2026 by Nicky in General / 5 Comments

Fantasy With Friends: A Disccusion Meme hosted by Pages Unbound

It’s Monday, and that means Fantasy with Friends! The prompts are hosted at Pages Unbound, and this time we’re talking about fairytale retellings:

Do you like reading fairy tale retellings? What, in your opinion, makes a good retelling?

Broadly speaking, yes! I find retellings fascinating, because what the author chooses to keep the same and what they choose to change tells you a lot. Sometimes they’re pure nostalgia, basically little different from the Disney movie adaptations, and that’s an interesting choice too — sometimes it can be pretty fun and cosy, other times it just feels kinda repressive.

Cover of Rose Daughter by Robin McKinleyObviously it’s not just an academic curiosity, though that’s there too: I enjoy fairytales in general because they have a familiar shape, so you know roughly what you’re expecting. If the author leans into that, it can be comforting; if they don’t, then you get the fun of trying to guess where it’s going exactly, where it’s going to echo the original and where it’s going to depart.

Some of the earliest fairytale retellings I read were by Robin McKinley, and that’s especially fun because she actually retold “Beauty and the Beast” at least twice — once in Beauty, and then differently (and with more complexity) in Rose Daughter. You can argue for an influence of “Beauty and the Beast” in some of her other stories too (Sunshine and Chalice spring to mind). It’s obvious that something in the story really resonates with her and sticks in her head.

Cover of Hemlock & Silver by T. KingfisherMore recently, there’s T. Kingfisher. I really liked Hemlock & Silver, which a “Snow White” story… kinda. She takes a different POV, adds new characters, and gets wildly inventive about the worldbuilding, using “Snow White” as the barest beginning for a total flight of fantasy. It almost doesn’t feel like a retelling at all, but sometimes you get these sly little references to remind you where it jumped off from…

I also like books which aren’t quite retellings, but which riff on fairytale worlds and tropes, like Amy Coombe’s Stay for a Spell in which the protagonist’s parents send all the princes of the realm to kiss the cursed princess, imagining that will break her curse.

I think sometimes fairytale retellings and stories using fairytale tropes can be lazy, like pretty much any other book, story or subgenre — and sometimes even the lazy ones can be fun in a cosy sort of way. It’s kinda like the same reason I enjoy classic crime stories: there’s ultimately a kind of predictability to them: you know what you’re getting.

At the same time, fairytale retellings can be transformative in any number of ways, creating queer-positive worlds, playing with gender roles, etc… It all depends on what you do with them.

So what do I think makes a good fairytale retelling? I think my favourites all try to delve deeper into the story, whether it’s by adding psychological realism, adding new points of view, queering it up or developing a whole new world to transform the story. There’s so much that can be done, and I enjoy watching people be inventive about it.

Tags: ,

Divider

Review – Dinosaur Sanctuary, vol 1

Posted May 17, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Dinosaur Sanctuary, vol 1

Dinosaur Sanctuary

by Itaru Kinoshita

Genres: Manga, Science Fiction
Pages: 194
Series: Dinosaur Sanctuary #1
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

A richly detailed manga about a rookie zookeeper learning how to care for dinosaurs of all shapes and sizes, sure to delight dinosaur lovers!

Dinosaurs are alive! In 1946, a remote island was discovered where dinosaurs never went extinct. Through breeding and genetic manipulation, dinosaur populations increased and dino-mania reached a fever pitch worldwide
until a certain terrible incident occurred. Afterward, dinosaur reserves like Enoshima Dinoland fell on hard times. Enter Suma Suzume, a kindhearted rookie dino-keeper! Can she be the one to save Dinoland from extinction?

The first volume of Itaru Kinoshita’s Dinosaur Sanctuary was definitely the light reading I needed on the particular day I finally picked it up. It’s aimed at a younger audience, but it’s a lot of fun, including the fact files in between chapters by an actual dinosaur expert. I love that they have a dinosaur expert consulting on it!

Obviously there’s a hint at big potential drama, from the fact that two of the characters (at least) are linked to a big and deadly incident that’s been alluded to several times… but it’s fairly low stakes. Mostly it’s about taking care of dinosaurs, which, yeah. Obviously I am very into that, and the theorising about what they might need in order to be kept in what is essentially a zoo.

I actually found this by stumbling onto a thread on Bluesky about how they translate thagomizer in the Japanese version (the answer is ” ă‚”ă‚Žăƒžă‚€ă‚¶ăƒŒ/sagomaizaa”, apparently). And they say Bluesky doesn’t sell books!

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – My Heart in Braille

Posted May 16, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – My Heart in Braille

My Heart in Braille

by Joris Chamblain, Pascal Ruter, Anne-Lise Nalin

Genres: Graphic Novels, Young Adult
Pages: 74
Rating: one-star
Synopsis:

Victor loves vintage cars and belting out songs in his garage band, but school is harder for him and he seems to always say the wrong thing. When he meets the cello-playing, straight-A student Marie-Jo, the two strike up an unlikely friendship, and before long both his grades and his attitude improve. But when Marie-Jo confesses a terrible secret to him, Victor will have to return the favor and do a little rescuing of his own.

There’s some pretty art in Joris Chamberlain’s My Heart in Braille, but I didn’t really think much of the story. I gather it’s actually based on a novel, which might make more sense of it; it didn’t really feel like it’d been written/structured to be a graphic novel to begin with.

Overall, it feels like there’s some lacking context for the characters and like certain aspects of the story just get totally dropped, or elided. There isn’t strong character development or relationship development, and Victor’s personal development (and coping with his ?ADHD) is essentially ditched in favour of Marie’s feel-good story about getting to go to music school.

Overall, not strong at all.

Rating: 1/5 (“didn’t like it”)

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Divider

Stacking the Shelves & The Sunday Post

Posted May 16, 2026 by Nicky in General / 29 Comments

Happy weekend! And happy reading time? Well, for some of us at least.

Books acquired this week

I had no intention of getting anything this week, except maybe some more poetry from the library, but then I realised that volume three of the Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint novel was out… and volume ten of the manhwa. How is a person of flesh and blood supposed to resist?

Cover of Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint vol 10 by Umi, SleepyC and singNsong Cover of Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint vol 3 by singNSong

I did also get some more poetry from the library, since I’m trying to use some short books to fill gaps in my day, so there they are:

Cover of If All the World and Love Were Young by Stephen Sexton Cover of The Weather Wheel by Mimi Khalvati Cover of Obit by Victoria Chang

I’ve already dug into two of those, so I’m sure I’ll have more loans soon. Hurrah for libraries!

Posts from this week

First the review posts, as per usual:

As ever, these aren’t necessarily recent reads, since I store up reviews to spread out the genres I’m posting about as much as possible. See below for the books I’ve been reading this week!

And of course there have been some other posts:

What I’m reading

Things are still a bit quiet on the reading front, and let’s admit it, it’s at least partly due to my newfound special interest in hidden object games. Oh well: I don’t read as part of a curriculum or obligation or whatever, but for my own enjoyment… and these things come and go. And I did do quite a bit of reading this week all the same — here are the books I finished!

Cover of Brigands and Breadknives by Travis Baldree Cover of Ambush at Still Lake by Caroline Bird Cover of A Palace Near the Wind by Ai Jiang

Cover of If All the World and Love Were Young by Stephen Sexton Cover of Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint vol 9 by Umi, SleepyC and singNsong Cover of Obit by Victoria Chang

This weekend I’m planning to finish up An Ancient Witch’s Guide to Modern Dating and A History of the World in 50 Pieces, for the latter of which I might switch to audiobook, especially if the audiobook has any snippets of the actual pieces. I’m being somewhat hindered in following the text by not knowing all the music, and there doesn’t seem to be a handy playlist or anything.

Other than that, I do also want to dig into volume ten of the Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint manhwa, and probably read another couple of shortish reads: a manga or comic, probably, and another poetry collection (the Mimi Khalvati collection is rather calling to me).

That said, I might be slowed up this weekend by the arrival of yarn for a new crochet project. It’s been a while, but I ended up sorely tempted by this beautiful pattern, and I didn’t see any reason not to give it a shot. Listening to the audiobook of A History of the World in 50 Pieces might be a good accompaniment to that, once I’ve got started and sorted out my initial stitch count. The whole width is worked for each row, so I’ll want to concentrate to make sure I get that right.

And of course, I’m sure I’ll be playing plenty of hidden object and puzzle games, too!

Linking up with Reading Reality’s Stacking the Shelves, Caffeinated Reviewer’s The Sunday Post, the Sunday Salon over at Readerbuzz, and It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? at The Book Date.

Tags: , ,

Divider

Review – Somewhere There Is A Sky For Us

Posted May 15, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Somewhere There Is A Sky For Us

Somewhere There Is A Sky For Us

by Joelle Taylor (editor)

Genres: Poetry
Pages: 170
Rating: two-stars
Synopsis:

This anthology gathers the many voices and textures of Language is a Queer Thing, a 3-year long poetic dialogue between queer voices from India and the UK, unfolding over three years of exchange, residencies and performance.

These poems are prayers, protests, lullabies, warnings, duets, sonatas and satires.

Somewhere There Is A Sky For Us is the product of a three-year project involving queer poets from India and the UK sharing their work, doing residencies and exchanges, etc. It’s an interesting spread of poems, and often plays with form (sometimes a bit difficult to read in print form, since they’ve turned it sideways on the page so you have to turn the book). It’s mostly in English, but other languages are mixed in here and there.

Overall it wasn’t quite my thing — I think I’m more of a traditionalist about poetry at times, and don’t love ones that play with shapes on the page or go very abstract. There’s a few prose-poems, which I can enjoy, but didn’t really stand out to me.

As ever, there are a few images and lines that stand out, and I’m glad I gave it a shot! Just not my personal cup of tea. Which is perhaps an unfair figure of speech, as I’ve never met a cup of tea I liked; rest assured that I didn’t read this expecting not to like it, as it’s a pretty cool sounding project.

Rating: 2/5 (“it was okay”)

Tags: , , ,

Divider

Review – Craftland

Posted May 14, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Craftland

Craftland: A Journey Through Britain's Lost Arts & Vanishing Trades

by James Fox

Genres: History, Non-fiction
Pages: 360
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Britain has always been a craft land. For generations what we made with our hands defined our identities, built our communities and shaped our regions. Craftland chronicles the vanishing skills and traditions that once governed every aspect of life on these shores.

Travelling the length of Britain, from the Scilly Isles to the Scottish Highlands, James Fox seeks out the country’s last remaining master craftspeople. Stepping inside the workshops of blacksmiths and wheelwrights, cutlers and coopers, bell-founders and watchmakers, we glimpse not only our past but another way of life — one that is not yet lost and whose wisdom could shape our future.

For as long as there are humans, there will be craft. It is all around us, hiding in plain sight, enriching even the most modest things. And in this increasingly digital age, it is perhaps more valuable than ever. Craftland is a celebration of that deeply necessary connection between our creative instincts and the material world we inhabit, revealing a richer and more connected way of living.

James Fox’s Craftland is a celebration of the “crafts” we’re losing in Britain — wheelwrighting, stone wall laying, watchmaking, etc. He speaks elegaically, referring to people as craftsmen even when they dislike that term for themselves (which he notes almost in the same paragraph as referring to it as a craft). I think in some cases he’s creating a virtue out of something that people just feel should be kept alive for their own reasons, and that they may not all be comfortable with how they’re portrayed here, based on his own words about them.

That said, it’s still interesting, especially when he goes into the details of how things are done, and how the traditional methods might help reduce the use of plastic and move toward more sustainable systems, e.g. in fishing. That sort of thing could well be important in returning to something like a sustainable fishing industry.

I wasn’t quite sure about some of his claims, though, e.g. re: watchmaking and saying the man he talked to was one of the last two watchmakers in Britain. I read Rebecca Struthers’ The Hands of Time not that long ago (and it’s an excellent and not obscure book), and she and her partner are both watchmakers (though often working on repairing watches). Maybe he meant that they came out of nowhere and magically taught themselves — I don’t remember the details well enough to be sure they didn’t just appear from nowhere after the point where he says the master and apprentice he writes about were the only two watchmakers in the British Isles. Still, it doesn’t quite suit his narrative of experts literally dying as he lines up interviews with them, and leaves me with some questions.

As far as his sources go, a lot of it is “because I went and saw it myself, so there’s no source but my say-so”, but there are numbered footnotes, sparser in some chapters than others.

A decent celebration of the historically necessary and vital work people have done, haunted by a few questions for me, overall.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Meteorite Hunters

Posted May 13, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 4 Comments

Review – The Meteorite Hunters

The Meteorite Hunters

by Joshua Howgego

Genres: Non-fiction, Science
Pages: 272
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Want to join the ultimate cosmic treasure hunt?

Meteors, with their ethereal, glowing trails slashing through the atmosphere, have entranced us for centuries. But these extraterrestrial visitors are also inestimably valuable. Not just for collectors, who can make their fortunes tracking them down, but for scientists too. Meteorites are the most ancient objects we know, unblemished time capsules from the birth of the solar system.

Following in the footsteps of passionate hobbyists, ground-breaking scientists and intrepid adventurers, Joshua Howgego takes a rollicking ride through the world of meteorite hunting. Join the seasoned practitioners braving the elements as they scour the Sahara and ice sheets of Antarctica. Discover how, closer to home, one unlikely hero – a self-taught jazz guitarist – is uncovering the countless micrometeorites scattered across the rooftops of our cities. And meet the professor searching for the rarest of the rare: fossil meteorites, entombed in rock since the days of the dinosaurs.

Finding these stones from space is just the beginning. As scientists tease out their secrets, they piece together an unexpected new history of the solar system, with implications that extend to one of the most fundamental questions we can ask: how did life on earth begin?

I liked Joseph Howgego’s The Meteorite Hunters a lot more than I liked the other book I read about meteorites recently (Helen Gordon’s The Meteorites), and I think it’s largely because it stayed more focused on the popular science side of things: the chemical composition of meteorites, and what that can tell us about our own origins, the formation of the universe, etc.

Howgego’s pretty good at explaining things — I will never properly retain the differences between types of meteorites from one book to another, it’s just not something I’ve ever needed to properly log in my brain, but Howgego made it clear enough without repeating himself too much. He does lean a little sometimes on telling us about people he’s going to speak to (I do not need so much detail about someone’s band), which sometimes caused it to drag for me at times, because I’m not that interested in The Big Personalities (TM) Of Meteorite Hunting.

I think he also does a good job at indicating what’s contested, what’s speculative, where we’re going next in studying meteorites, and what certain discoveries might mean. The sources for each chapter are discussed in a “notes from sources” chapter which isn’t numbered, but does make it clear where each bit of info comes from.

Overall, I quite enjoyed it!

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider