Genre: Fantasy

Review – The Fourth Island

Posted May 26, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – The Fourth Island

The Fourth Island

by Sarah Tolmie

Genres: Fantasy
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Huddled in the sea off the coast of Ireland is a fourth Aran Island, a secret island peopled by the lost, findable only in moments of despair. Whether drowned at sea, trampled by Cromwell's soldiers, or exiled for clinging to the dead, no outsiders reach the island without giving in to dark emotion.

Time and again, The Fourth Island weaves a hypnotic pattern with its prose, presaging doom before walking back through the sweet and sour moments of lives not yet lost. It beautifully melds the certainty of loss with the joys of living, drawing readers under like the tide.

Belatedly posting a review of a book I wrote a while ago and somehow never posted!

The Fourth Island is a fascinating book which is clearly frustrating for a lot of people who want a story that goes from A to B to C, and comes to a solid conclusion. For me, it read like the author started with the idea of the Aran sweater whose pattern nobody recognised, and then explored from there — how could such a thing come to be? And what does that mean?

In the end, if you want a solid answer — this thing happened for that reason — then it’s somewhat unsatisfying. It’s not clear how each character who ends up on the Fourth Island gets there, why they’re chosen and not others. In part it reads like it’s questioning that: why are some people saved and not others? That is how our world works, and we always crave to know why and see a higher purpose in it, but here Tolmie makes it small: why would people be chosen to come to this tiny island when lost? And does that have a weight on the world, a cost?

It’s not a traditional fantasy story, for sure; I guess you could say it’s magic realism. There’s some beautiful writing in it, and I was totally absorbed in the mystery of it, without needing it to also give me the answers.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , ,

Divider

Review – Guardian, vol 1

Posted May 26, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Guardian, vol 1

Guardian

by Priest

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels, Mystery, Romance
Pages: 408
Series: Guardian #1
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Zhao Yunlan heads up a covert division of the Ministry of Public Security that deals with the strange and unusual, blurring the line between the mortal realm and the Netherworld. His cocky, casual attitude conceals both a sharp mind and an arsenal of mystical tools and arcane knowledge.

While investigating a gruesome death at a local university, Zhao Yunlan crosses paths with the reserved Professor Shen Wei. Zhao Yunlan is immediately intrigued by Shen Wei’s good looks and intense gaze, and the attraction between them is immediate and powerful, even as Shen Wei tries to keep his distance. Shen Wei and his secrets are a puzzle Zhao Yunlan feels compelled to solve as mysterious circumstances throw them together, and their connection becomes impossible to deny.


Wow, volume one of Priest’s Guardian certainly brings the yearning. I wasn’t entirely sure at first, since Zhao Yunlan’s mooning after Shen Wei seemed a little one-sided (though there were some hints), but after about halfway through it’s clear there’s more going on and that the yearning is more than mutual — if anything, Shen Wei is more deeply in love than Zhao Yunlan.

Shen Wei had been restraining himself for too long. In the perfect silence, he couldn’t help letting go for once. Lying there with Zhao Yunlan so tantalisingly near, his thoughts spun out of control. He imagined gathering that warm body close, pressing kisses to those eyes, that hair, those lips… tasting and partaking of every part.
He imagined possessing Zhao Yunlan utterly.
The fantasy alone was enough to make Shen Wei’s breathing unsteady. He yearned with the desperate fervour of someone dreaming of hot soup as they froze to death.
But he didn’t move a muscle. Just looking at Zhao Yunlan and thinking about him was seemingly enough.

Ooof. Wow.

The relationship between Zhao Yunlan and Shen Wei is definitely a draw, but I’m enjoying the world and story as well: I figured out the identity of the Emissary ahead of time, but a lot of the details remain unclear, along with Zhao Yunlan’s last life, etc, and the various artefacts that Zhao Yunlan is presumably going to keep being drawn into encountering.

I will say that there’s a lot of stuff about Daqing (a cat) being really fat, calling him fatty, etc. The character isn’t solely comic relief and clearly has power of his own, and Zhao Yunlan insults everyone (especially Guo Changcheng, whose anxiety and awkwardness is frequently mocked), but… even the narrative gets in on calling Daqing fat all the time, and it’s definitely worth being aware of, as it’s clearly meant somewhat negatively/comically.

I’m definitely eager for the second book, in any case — I love Shen Wei, the yearning is palpable, and I’m curious where the story goes as well.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Review – Solo Leveling, vol 5

Posted May 19, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Solo Leveling, vol 5

Solo Leveling

by Chugong

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels
Pages: 272
Series: Solo Leveling (light novel) #5
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Jinwoo's received some amazing gifts from the system, but the latest one might prove to be the greatest one yet—a key to the double dungeon where it all started. Perhaps a second visit might provide him with answers for once. He's got some time to kill until he can use the item though, but before he can tackle another gate, unexpected movement from the shadow soldiers guarding Jinah sets his alarm bells ringing...

I’d slightly misremembered how things would come together in volume five of Chugong’s Solo Leveling, so I didn’t quite get the longer-form explanations I was craving — though those will come with time. Various things happen in this book, but the main feature is Jinwoo’s return to Cartenon Temple, to come face to face with the person who created the system.

I really loved the scene with the other hunters leaving Jinwoo to sort everything out and just smoking, tearing up and blaming the smoky atmosphere. There is some genuine tension in this volume — we’ve heard dark warnings about the nature of Jinwoo’s power, after all, and we see part of this volume through the eyes of characters like Haein and Jinchul — and that scene is a lovely way of showing its release.

Of course, there’s more going on, and the world doesn’t solely revolve around Jinwoo. We’re beginning to see a much larger plot taking shape here, and I can’t wait to get to those bits.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Keeper of Magical Things

Posted May 18, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 4 Comments

Review – The Keeper of Magical Things

The Keeper of Magical Things

by Julie Leong

Genres: Fantasy, Romance
Pages: 368
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

An almost-mage discovers friendship—and maybe something more—in the unlikeliest of places in this delightfully charming novel from the USA Today bestselling author of The Teller of Small Fortunes.

Certainty Bulrush wants to be useful—to the Guild of Mages that took her in as a novice, to the little brother who depends on her, and to anyone else she can help. Unfortunately, her tepid magic hasn’t proven much use to anyone. When Certainty has the chance to earn her magehood via a seemingly straightforward assignment, she takes it. Nevermind that she’ll have to work with Mage Aurelia, the brilliant, unfairly attractive overachiever who’s managed to alienate everyone around her.

The two must transport minorly magical artifacts somewhere safe: Shpelling, the dullest, least magical village around. There, they must fix up an old warehouse, separate the gossipy teapots from the kind-of-flaming swords, corral an unruly little catdragon who has tagged along, and above all: avoid complications. The Guild’s uneasy relationship with citizens is at a tipping point, and the last thing needed is a magical incident.

Still, as mage and novice come to know Shpelling’s residents—and each other—they realize the Guild’s hoarded magic might do more good being shared. Friendships blossom while Certainty and Aurelia work to make Shpelling the haven it could be. But magic is fickle—add attraction and it might spell trouble.

I was really eager about The Keeper of Magical Things because I really loved Julie Leong’s previous book, The Teller of Small Fortunes. And indeed there was much to enjoy here, with this relatively low-stakes fantasy: a pretty cute romance plotline, the personal development of mostly just one of the characters, the story of a community regaining life and vigor after a disaster, and a small-stakes revenge plot. The worst thing that happens is that a tavern is burned down, with some personal consequences — this isn’t crowns and kingdoms.

I didn’t love it quite as much as The Teller of Small Fortunes, because I didn’t find it quite as creative in positioning the magic of the story. Tao’s story stuck out to be because her power of seeing the future is approached in a somewhat unique way: she tries to just see innocuous stuff, like the purchase of a new dress in the near future, but this can sometimes reveal far more than she expects. There’s less of that here: though Certainty’s power is small, the ability to speak to objects, it didn’t feel as clever/surprising, I suppose.

The characters were also a bit less compelling, while being pretty charming: Certainty’s a former farm girl with a need to prove herself and become a mage, while Aurelia is a mage who has problems relating to others, and messed up majorly. I think the most interesting magic angle in this story was actually perhaps in the necklace which helps her to focus. It really works, but it also comes with voices in her head (which sound like her parents) whispering that she’s going to be a failure, forcing her to focus through shame. For a cosy book, though, that’s quite the horrible little object.

Overall, I still had fun, don’t get me wrong — I got invested in the way the two of them ended up using the magical objects to revitalise the town of Shpelling, and in the will-they-won’t-they of their relationship. I loved that the community ultimately stuck up for them, recognising the good they brought even before — well, no more spoilers!

It winds up nicely and is a pretty satisfying read, but it didn’t stand out for me in quite the same way as Leong’s previous novel.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – Solo Leveling (light novel), vol 4

Posted May 11, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Solo Leveling (light novel), vol 4

Solo Leveling

by Chugong

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels
Pages: 300
Series: Solo Leveling (light novel) #4
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

"IT'S SHOWTIME."

The news has made headlines—"Korea and Japan join hands to exterminate the terrifying magic beasts on Jeju Island once and for all!" It's a monumental moment for the people of the country…and it has absolutely nothing to do with Jinwoo. Instead, the newest S-rank hunter's number one priority is bringing his recently recovered mother back home where she belongs at last. When the situation on Jeju Island takes a devastating turn for the worse, though, will the country's top hunters be strong enough to save the day without him?

Volume four of Chugong’s Solo Leveling covers the Jeju Island arc, and it’s a lot of fun — the other S rank hunters are so outclassed, even Ryuji Goto, and then Jinwoo swoops in… It’s wish fulfilment, there’s never any real chance that Jinwoo’s going to lose (or allow all Korean hunters to die), and it’s so satisfying to see that come to fruition.

I know others find that without any tension (because we know Jinwoo won’t lose) — or at least minimal tension, because some does come through from Haein Cha etc — the series isn’t so fun, but that’s a feature not a bug to me.

Speaking of bugs, hurrah, Beru! He’s super cute in the manhwa, a weird thing to be saying about a scary insect shadow soldier, so I’m curious about how he is in the source material too.

Plus, with the next volume (and a return to Cartenon Temple), we’re getting close to getting some explanations of what’s going on, so I’m very much looking forward to that.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Grendel Affair

Posted May 10, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – The Grendel Affair

The Grendel Affair

by Lisa Shearin

Genres: Fantasy, Mystery
Pages: 292
Series: SPI Files #1
Rating: two-stars
Synopsis:

We're Supernatural Protection & Investigations, known as SPI. Things that go bump in the night, the monsters you thought didn't exist? We battle them and keep you safe. But some supernatural baddies are just too big to contain, even for us...

When I moved to New York to become a world famous journalist, I never imagined that snagging a job at a seedy tabloid would change my career path from trashy reporter to undercover agent. I'm Makenna Fraser, a Seer for SPI. I can see through any disguise, shield, or spell that a paranormal pest can come up with. I track down creatures and my partner, Ian Byrne, takes them out.

Our cases are generally pretty routine, but a sickle-wielding serial killer has been prowling the city's subway tunnels. And the murderer's not human. The fiend in question, a descendant of Grendel--yes, that Grendel--shares his ancestor's hatred of parties, revelry, and drunkards. And with New Year's Eve in Times Square only two days away, we need to bag him quickly. Because if we don't find him--and the organization behind him--by midnight, our secret's out and everyone's time is up.

Lisa Shearin’s The Grendel Affair is a relatively typical urban fantasy sort of set-up, with much of the world unaware of magic and monsters, and others secretly working to keep that the case. The main character is a seer, working for a group run by a dragon and centered in New York, and the coolest thing about the book… is unfortunately spoilered by the title.

I’ve seen some reviews complaining about how useless Mac is, and I don’t think that’s entirely fair. She’s new to the job and not trained as a front-line agent, and though she’s definitely overconfident in the opening, she’s eager to learn and to listen to what those who are actually experts in the action say. She’s not the most useful combatant, but she does what she can, and she doesn’t shirk the danger when she is the right person for the job.

That said, I didn’t love her as a character either, mostly because I found her just kinda meh, a bit of a cipher. The same goes for pretty much all the characters, to be fair; Ian’s mostly just a cop stereotype who lost his partner etc etc. That’s partly because it’s the first book of a series and it needs time to grow, but it didn’t grab me.

Overall, it was fine, just not super exciting. I probably won’t read more.

Rating: 2/5 (“it was okay”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – Solo Leveling (light novel), vol 3

Posted May 3, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Solo Leveling (light novel), vol 3

Solo Leveling

by Chugong

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels
Pages: 320
Series: Solo Leveling (light novel) #3
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

JINWOO SUNG, OFFICIALLY S RANK

Leveling up in C-rank dungeons has become next to impossible for Jinwoo. But an E-rank hunter attempting anything higher? Well, that would raise some serious red flags…so the time has come for a reevaluation. And when the results are back, it’s official-Jinwoo is the tenth S-rank hunter from South Korea! An entirely new world, brimming with powerful magic beasts and elite hunters, is now open to him. But before he can immerse himself in it, there’s something absolutely vital he has to do…

Volume three of Chugong’s Solo Leveling covers Jinwoo’s re-evaluation, his time with the mining squad (and meeting with Haein Cha), and some more of his time in the Demons’ Tower. His time with Esil is still pretty funny (dude, she probably has a crush on you!) and I continue to love watching him just get more and more overpowered.

I feel like some things are maybe better handled here, in that I feel like we’ve been hearing about Jeju Island for longer in the light novel than we did in the manhwa, so it just makes sense that it’s the next thing on the horizon.

There’s nothing groundbreaking and new here: if you’re getting tired of Jinwoo’s overpowered adventures, then you probably want to stop here. If you’re enjoying that, and it’s just how Jinwoo will win and not can Jinwoo win, then this continues to be super fun.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – Fate’s Bane

Posted May 3, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Fate’s Bane

Fate's Bane

by C.L. Clark

Genres: Fantasy
Pages: 166
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

The clans of the fens enjoy a tenuous peace, and it is all thanks to Agnir, ward and hostage. For as long as she can remember she has lived among the enemy, learning their ways, growing strong alongside their children. When a burgeoning love for the chieftain’s daughter lures them both to a hidden spring, a magic awakens in them that could bind the clans under one banner at last—or destroy any hope of peace. By working their intentions into leather, they can weave misfortune for their enemies… just like the Fate’s Bane that haunts the legends of the clans.

Ambitions grow in their fathers’ hearts, grudges threaten a return to violence, and greedy enemies wait outside the borders, seeking a foothold to claim the fens for themselves. And though their Makings may save their families, the legend that gave them this power always exacts its price.

I’m still digesting what I think about C.L. Clark’s Fate’s Bane as I write. I knew going in that it was a sort of vaguely ancient British setting, with a tragic sapphic love story, and a peek ahead had told me about the multiple endings… but even having finished it, I find myself not entirely sure how that sits with me.

The romance itself didn’t entirely work for me, because it wasn’t a relationship between equals, even though one party pretended it was: Agnir is barely more than a slave, even if they want to pretend she’s a “ward” of Hadhnri’s father. She wears a collar, constantly, and though she’s protected a little bit more than the others of her clan who were taken at the same time she was, they are slaves and she is definitely not free. She’s, at best, a hostage.

Hadhnri makes choices the way she does because she is free, loved, and secure. If there are punishments, they will fall heavily on Agnir and lightly on Hadhnri — but she blames Agnir for not being brave, true and loyal, despite the fact that Hadhnri’s clan have treated her like a prisoner her whole life, and constrained how they taught her and what she’s been permitted to do.

As a result, and given that Hadhnri’s brother kills Agnir’s brother and then Hadhnri gets cross at Agnir about the situation, it was hard to entirely root for the romance.

There are fun aspects of the book stylistically, and the oral storytelling mode it’s calling on (especially at the end) fits the ambiguous ending. I liked some of the details, and the close descriptions of the physical draw between the two leads. But… still. The romance didn’t entirely sit right with me: it’s not that it’s not realistic, because I think it was, it’s just that I felt I was being asked for a lot more faith that Hadhnri had earned, and I wasn’t sure the narrative knew that Hadhnri was being unreasonable. That makes some sense since it comes from Agnir’s eyes, but still, it just… it didn’t have to be quite so unequal and still ask faith from me.

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , ,

Divider

Review – Delicious in Dungeon, vol 1

Posted May 1, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Delicious in Dungeon, vol 1

Delicious in Dungeon

by Ryoko Kui

Genres: Fantasy, Manga
Pages: 191
Series: Delicious in Dungeon #1
Rating: two-stars
Synopsis:

When young adventurer Laios and his company are attacked and soundly thrashed by a dragon deep in a dungeon, the party loses all its money and provisions... and a member! They're eager to go back and save her, but there is just one problem: If they set out with no food or coin to speak of, they're sure to starve on the way! But Laios comes up with a brilliant idea: "Let's eat the monsters!" Slimes, basilisks, and even dragons... none are safe from the appetites of these dungeon-crawling gourmands!

I didn’t really know much about Ryoko Kui’s Delicious in Dungeon going in, only that it featured a team of broke adventurers who need to learn to cook monsters in order to help them progress in a dungeon. I didn’t know about the whole “because a dragon has eaten the main character’s sister” part, which… to be fair… is not a major part of the story because they don’t seem to feel much urgency about it at all.

The pacing feels weird, as each chapter is essentially just a little episode in “what to cook next”. There are some fun touches, like the nutrition balance cards after the various meals, and the ingenuity of how to cook some stuff, and I really enjoyed the almost scientific interest Laios has in various creatures, figuring out how they work.

Overall, though, I felt a lack of character development (the most was Marcille, but it was mostly “whiny elf girl whines and then eats the food anyway”) and… direction? So I’m not sure I’ll read more. The lack of pace would probably have come across better if Laios’ sister wasn’t, you know, being digested. I know that they expect to just resurrect her but… yeah. Still.

Rating: 2/5 (“it was okay”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Village Library Demon Hunting Society

Posted April 26, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 4 Comments

Review – The Village Library Demon Hunting Society

The Village Library Demon-Hunting Society

by C.M. Waggoner

Genres: Fantasy, Mystery
Pages: 335
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

Librarian Sherry Pinkwhistle has a knack for solving murders – lots of them. Sometimes she’s concerned by just how many killers she’s had to track down in her quiet village, though none of her neighbours seem surprised by the rising body count…

But when someone close to Sherry ends up dead, and her cat becomes unexpectedly possessed by an ancient demon as irritating as it is infernal, Sherry decides that it’s time for action.

It will be a lesson for murderers and demons alike:

Never mess with a librarian.

C.M. Waggoner’s The Village Library Demon-Hunting Society takes the concept “what if there’s something sinister and deeper explaining all those murders in a sleepy little town?” and runs with it. At first, it seems like just a cosy mystery, but the main character (Sherry) keeps having strange thoughts/feelings, like a reminder that there’s something missing or something fundamentally wrong about everything, and it’s clear there’s something darker afoot.

That manifests itself in a way that’s still kinda cosy, despite the murders — a demon/ghost possesses Sherry’s cat, calling itself “Lord Thomas Cromwell” and acting like it is, due to her decision to name her cat Lord Thomas Cromwell. There’s still a fair bit of uneasiness and weirdness with the demon (and a heck of a confrontation scene), but altogether, it doesn’t get too far from a cosy mystery… just, also with demons.

It didn’t end up being something I loved, and I’m not sure why; maybe the pacing? In retrospect I guess it felt like there were some pretty slow bits, and like I didn’t really get to know the characters very well. They felt a bit more sketched in. If it turned into a series, I’d probably read more, but not in a big hurry, and I’d be looking for more characterisation.

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider