Tag: danmei

Review – The Wife Comes First, vol 2

Posted September 8, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – The Wife Comes First, vol 2

The Wife Comes First

by Lv Ye Qian He

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels, Romance
Pages: 323
Series: The Wife Comes First #2
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

On the brink of death, Prince Cheng is stunned to find the one person still by his side: his long-neglected princely consort, Mu Hanzhang. While Prince Cheng pursued power and countless lovers, Mu Hanzhang never wavered in his dedication as his wife, despite the future he lost. Prince Cheng knows he never deserved such loyalty.

But fate isn’t finished with him yet. When he awakens in the past—on the morning after their disastrous wedding night, with all his memories intact—Prince Cheng seizes the chance to set things right. This time, he’ll treasure Mu Hanzhang. This time, the wife will come first, the state second, and the husband last.

Yet winning Mu Hanzhang’s trust is only the first battle. Court conspiracies still run deep, and if they’re not careful, history may repeat itself…starting with a knife in the back.

Volume two of Lv Ye Qian He’s The Wife Comes First picks up directly from the previous volume, and mostly concerns Jing Shao and Mu Hanzhang going to war. Junqing spends a chunk of the story pretending to be just a ‘strategist’, since it usually isn’t permitted for generals to take their wives with them to war, but Jing Shao (great big puppy that he is) wheedles and begs his way into Junqing’s tent, and soon eveeeryone knows who he must be.

There are some really sweet moments between the two of them as they really solidify their relationship and speak honestly to one another about their feelings. I loved it; it’d be easy to introduce drama and a third act breakup, and I think in “Western” fiction that’d happen — but instead we just get to watch the two of them being ridiculously devoted to each other and an absolute power couple.

Also, Junqing gets a baby tiger cub.

There’s a fair bit of politicking and so on, so the plot also advances, hopefully carrying Jing Shao and Junqing past the difficulties that plagued Jing Shao’s past life. I’m kinda eh on the white lie about the previous attempt being a dream that Jing Shao had, but at least he’s found a way to explain some of his foreknowledge to Junqing, instead of leaving him out.

The problematic elements of consent and the treatment of women mostly aren’t carried through in this book, in part because I think only two named female characters show up in the whole thing (Ge Ruoyi and Hao Dadao’s wife). As mentioned, it’s really not the best-written, and I think that can also add to the problem, making the characterisation of a lot of characters flat. I’m here for Jing Shao and Mu Hanzhang (and their tiger cub), so your mileage may vary on how much it bothers you. My rating is definitely reflecting personal enjoyment and the way I raced through the book, not a considered critical response! Possibly if I went with my gut now, I’d lower it to 3/5… but I really had fun while reading it.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Book Blogger Hop: A Book That Deserves More Love

Posted September 4, 2026 by Nicky in General / 12 Comments

A banner for a "Book Blogger Hop", with a photo of a bunny wearing glasses and its paws on a book

It’s Friday, so it’s time for the Book Blogger Hop again, hosted by Billy @ Coffee Addicted Writer. I’ve made my own image from a stock photo (credit: Anna Shvets) to avoid adding images created via generative AI to my blog. Feel free to use it too if you would like!

This week’s prompt is about bigging up a book you love and think doesn’t get enough attention:

What book do you think deserves more love but flies under the radar?

This is really difficult! So I’m just going to go with a recent read that I actually had trouble finding other people talking about: Liu Gou Hua’s After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine. It’s a danmei novel in translation, in four volumes (three out so far), and despite the funny title, I think it’s one of the better danmei I’ve read recently.

If you haven’t read danmei before, or come across me talking about it, danmei are gay love stories which often mix in a variety of genres. Mo Xiang Tong Xiu’s works are set in a variety of fantasy worlds and often features elements of horror (the buried head in Heaven Official’s Blessing comes to mind) and mystery (in both Heaven Official’s Blessing and Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation, the protagonists spend a lot of time investigating things), while Priest’s Guardian is modern fantasy/mystery, others are more historical, etc.

After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine is mostly historical in tone, though there’s a fantasy element (one of the characters is a modern professor who transmigrates back into a period of history he’s studied). Once there, he quickly realises that he’s become a certain prince who was forced to marry a prisoner of war who later kills him and hangs his head off a wall, and the professor is very keen for that not to happen to him. He starts meddling in court politics and trying to help the prisoner of war heal and escape, trying to avert his fate — and, because it’s danmei, they end up falling in love. It’s an exquisite slow burn, and I can’t wait for volume four to be out in translation.

For those who are interested in danmei and know The Scum Villain’s Self-Saving System, there’s a bit of a Liushen vibe to Huo Wujiu and Jiang Suizhou.

But, since I know most people visiting my blog aren’t into danmei, I’ll offer another option as well — if you’re into Arthurian legends, Phyllis Ann Karr’s Idylls of the Queen is a very fun murder mystery and examination of the character of Sir Kay. I’ve been meaning to reread it for ages, since the last time I read it was when I was writing my dissertation chapter that featured it, (mumble) years ago now.

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – Mistakenly Saving the Villain, vol 3

Posted September 1, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Mistakenly Saving the Villain, vol 3

Mistakenly Saving the Villain

by Feng Yu Nie

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels, Romance
Pages: 308
Series: Mistakenly Saving the Villain #3
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

SOME MISTAKES ARE DESTINY

After a dramatic confrontation with An Long, Song Qingshi and Yue Wuhuan finally begin to speak openly about their feelings. Their relationship deepens—an oasis of tenderness in a world that has offered them little peace.

But shadows remain. Even with treatment, Yue Wuhuan’s illness still festers, and Song Qingshi faces his own sickness: the slow collapse of his cultivation. Worse yet, the system—the mysterious voice that first bound him to this story—is far from satisfied with his failure to save the “right” person.

As the truth behind Song Qingshi’s biggest mistake unravels, so does reality itself. Perhaps he and Yue Wuhuan are nothing more than puppets of fate, destined to be twisted and broken by the heavens. Is anything in the world strong enough to break that cycle?

Volume three of Mistakenly Saving the Villain opens on that horrible cliffhanger, and predictably the two of them solve it in the most stupid possible way, by not talking about it properly and just sort of sliding into a relationship anyway. I say this as someone who basically did that in my own relationship with my now-wife, to be clear: I am affectionately talking about it as the most stupid possible thing.

I love that Song Qingshi is not actually as ignorant of what Yue Wuhuan is thinking and feeling as he sometimes seems, and that he works out what Yue Wuhuan is doing, coaxes him to act on his feelings, and starts helping him distinguish between what is real and what is his trauma/illness. So far it hasn’t much stopped Yue Wuhuan getting worse, because Song Qingshi doesn’t do a good job of boundaries, but… Yue Wuhuan’s unhinged devotion to Qingshi is what we’re here for, right?!

This volume then… goes places. It’s quite the ride, and I have no idea how this is all going to wrap up: the system has reasserted itself (sort of), and we get a glimpse of the bigger picture, a whole bigger tangle that Yue Wuhuan (or whatever he’d like to be called now) and Song Qingshi are part of, which I assume will round things off.

I’m trying not to say too much because a) I’m not sure I’m fully following everything yet and b) I don’t want to spoiler the wild ride for anyone else. But I’m enjoying it a lot and very eager for the last volume in October.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , , ,

Divider

Review – Mistakenly Saving the Villain, vol 2

Posted August 18, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – Mistakenly Saving the Villain, vol 2

Mistakenly Saving the Villain

by Feng Yu Nie

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels
Pages: 271
Series: Mistakenly Saving the Villain #2
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

DOES TIME REALLY HEAL ALL WOUNDS?

After a near-fatal catastrophe, Song Qingshi awakens to find his home, the Medicine King’s Valley, almost unrecognizable. But not to fear. His devoted companion, Yue Wuhuan, remains by his side, ready to guide him through the changes.

Yue Wuhuan seems transformed as well. There are rumors that he’s become a ruined beauty and a madman, but he insists it’s all an act. To Song Qingshi, he seems more stable than ever before. Yet when the volatile and injured An Long storms into the valley, Yue Wuhuan’s carefully spun narrative begins to unravel. Soon, the two are at each other’s throats again.

In a desperate bid to restore peace, Song Qingshi proposes a vacation together. But beneath the surface of this idyllic escape, Yue Wuhuan is still scheming—determined to eliminate anyone who dares sully his beloved “Zunzhu.” And if An Long thinks he can stop him, he’s about to learn just how far Yue Wuhuan will go for love.

Feng Yu Nie’s Mistakenly Saving the Villain ended volume one with the critical injury of Song Qingshi, so volume two opens after years of healing, during which An Long and Yue Wuhuan have been fighting each other on the regular, with Yue Wuhuan concealing Song Qingshi’s condition and An Long knowing something must be the matter.

We get a lot more insight into An Long’s behaviour in this volume, and into his former disagreements with Song Qingshi. I actually have a lot of sympathy for him in this volume, given what we discover about him — he’s a brute, but he’s also genuinely struggling, fighting deep feelings and a sense of not having a place in the world. I kind of hoped that the interlude with Song Qingshi, An Long and Yue Wuhuan going on holiday together would end better, but… the way it did end makes a lot of sense.

As for Yue Wuhuan, it is fascinating to note the ways he’s got stronger, and the deep instability he’s still struggling with. I’m not sure if I hope that he gets fully better or not, because he’d have a long way to go for that and it feels… not entirely plausible, and not like the story’s driving in that direction at all. And given that it’s fiction, there’s something appealing about how unhinged he and Song Qingshi can be about each other: at times Song Qingshi really does match him on that.

(To be really clear, it’s not shaping up to be a super healthy relationship since there’s a lot of stuff going unsaid and I think Yue Wuhuan would happily lock Song Qingshi in a room and just bring him anything he needs, in order to keep him safe from real and perceived threats. One can enjoy this in fiction while knowing that one would have to try to get Song Qingshi to see the truth and act in self-preservation in reality.)

I’m very curious where this is going to go and how issues like Song Qingshi’s cultivation are going to kick in… and where the system is in all this, given that it’s been quite a while without any mention of it. I don’t think it came up at all in this volume!

So yeah, still having a lot of fun, but Yue Wuhuan is a whole bundle of red flags in the shape of a man, and Song Qingshi isn’t actually a whole lot better in some ways. Read with caution if that might trouble you.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Review – Mistakenly Saving the Villain, vol 1

Posted August 6, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Mistakenly Saving the Villain, vol 1

Mistakenly Saving the Villain

by Feng Yu Nie

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels, Romance
Pages: 298
Series: Mistakenly Saving the Villain #1
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

A mission gone wrong and a villain in need of serious therapy await in this heart-rending drama—finally available in English!

When medical student Song Qingshi dies and wakes up in a historical fantasy novel, he’s tasked with rescuing the tragic protagonist from a life of misery. There’s just one problem—he has no idea who the protagonist is.

Instead of saving the hero, Song Qingshi accidentally rescues Yue Wuhuan, an enslaved man renowned for his striking beauty and trained in the art of seduction. Now determined to help his traumatized new patient heal, Song Qingshi offers everything he can: Medicine, therapy, emotional support, even a shared bed—strictly for his patient’s well-being, of course.

But Yue Wuhuan wants more than healing. He wants revenge. And most of all, he wants Song Qingshi all to himself.

As enemies close in—and even heaven itself turns against them—Song Qingshi isn’t trying to change the story. He’s just trying to save the one person who needs him most.

Volume one of Feng Yu Nie’s Mistakenly Saving the Villain sets up a pretty fun scenario: a young man (a former medical student) who has died of motor neurone disease ends up transmigrating into the world of a novel, tasked with saving the protagonist….

Problem is, he isn’t genre-savvy at all, and ends up saving a man intended to be a minor antagonist at most, who should have simply died earlier in the story. Without knowing that, and committed to “getting a good grade”, Song Qingshi settles into his new role, blending modern medicine with the cultivation world’s techniques to try to nurse Yue Wuhuan back to health.

The two of them get close as Song Qingshi tries to heal him, but it’s slow going because Yue Wuhuan has suffered a lot of trauma, and has both physical and psychological healing to do. Progress is hindered by Song Qingshi’s friend, An Long, who seems to have ulterior motives, and by the fact that Yue Wuhuan considers himself dirty and tainted from all that has happened to him, and holds back information from Song Qingshi in order to avoid frightening/upsetting him.

It’s fairly dark, due to the aforementioned trauma, and Yue Wuhuan isn’t a straightforwardly good guy: he can be, for Song Qingshi, and he was certainly deeply, deeply wronged… but he’s more than a little unhinged. Mind you, Song Qingshi matches that energy, going to absurd lengths to protect and defend Yue Wuhuan. I enjoy both of them greatly, despite Yue Wuhuan’s sometimes erratic behaviour.

Despite that dark background, it all goes past quite lightly because there’s a touch of humour to it through Song Qingshi’s misunderstandings. I found it a lot of fun to read, and because I happen to know a couple of spoilers due to people comparing it to the love story of Heaven Official’s Blessing, I’m very curious how that’s all going to connect up.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , , ,

Divider

Top Ten Tuesday: Danmei and Baihe Covers

Posted August 4, 2026 by Nicky in General / 32 Comments

This week’s Top Ten Tuesday prompt is a freebie about book covers! I decided to highlight some fun/pretty/cute danmei and baihe covers (from my collection), because I often get comments about them.

For those who don’t already know, danmei and baihe are Chinese genres which have recently-ish started being translated into English a lot. The stories focus on same-sex love, but can be all kinds of genres other than that — historical, fantastical, modern, mystery, and various mixtures of the two.

My favourite theme is honestly the covers that show the tenderness and joy the main couples share…

Cover of Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation vol 5 by MXTX Cover of The Scum Villain's Self-Saving System vol 4 by MXTX Cover of Heaven Official's Blessing vol 6 by MXTX Cover of The Wife Comes First vol 3 by Lv Ye Qian He Cover of The Disabled Tyrant's Beloved Pet Fish vol 3 by Xue Shan Fei Hu

Buuut it’s worth highlighting some badassery as well!

Cover of Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation vol 2 by MXTX Cover of The Beauty's Blade by Feng Ren Zuo Shi Cover of Mistakenly Saving the Villain vol 2 by Feng Yu Nie Cover of The Husky and His White Cat Shizun by Rou Bao Bu Chi Rou Cover of Remnants of Filth vol 1 by Ruo Bao Bu Chi Rou

I haven’t read all of these yet (the last two are still on my TBR), but I can’t wait. And I’d love to read more baihe — I’m sad I’m only featuring one! If anyone has recommendations for baihe that’s been translated and traditionally published, I’d love to hear them.

Tags: , , ,

Divider

Review – The Wife Comes First, vol 1

Posted July 22, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – The Wife Comes First, vol 1

The Wife Comes First

by Lv Ye Qian He

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels
Pages: 396
Series: The Wife Comes First #1
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

As his life flashes before his eyes, self-obsessed Prince Cheng has a moment to reflect on something curious. Despite knocking at death’s door, only one person remains by his side: his all-but-abandoned prince-consort, Mu Hanzhang. Except, rather than celebrate that fact, Prince Cheng can only wonder… Why, after everything, is Mu Hanzhang still with him?

After all, Prince Cheng spent most of his life philandering and mastering political intrigue. Meanwhile, Mu Hanzhang had to discard his dreams of taking the Imperial Examination to become a minister, and was instead coerced to serve as male wife to a cruel prince!

Granted a second chance, Prince Cheng is miraculously reborn, waking up the morning after his wedding. As he does, the prince makes another vow: the wife comes first, the state second, and the husband last.

Where to start? Well first, he must kneel outside Mu Hanzhang’s bedroom door and beg to be let in, of course! Then again, after the sacrifices Mu Hanzhang’s had to make, will he even be willing to forgive his new husband?

I hadn’t heard much about Lv Ye Qian He’s The Wife Comes First before picking up volume one, but I was quickly hooked by the concept: it opens with Jing Shao’s death, with the body of his neglected but loyal first wife (his only male wife, Mu Hanzhang) in his arms, and then his awakening beside that same wife on their wedding night.

It starts in a bit of an uncomfortable place, truth be told: the wedding night didn’t actually go well, and Jing Shao injured Mu Hanzhang pretty badly. It’s not entirely clear how consensual that all was from the narrative: Mu Hanzhang doesn’t consider that he can say no, while Jing Shao was drunk… but I will say that in the rest of the novel, when Mu Hanzhang shows reluctance or says no, Jing Shao listens and does only what Mu Hanzhang is comfortable with (albeit maybe with a bit of pleading and cajoling). It’s all a bit difficult because of the setting: both of them were forced into the marriage, and it’s unclear how far either of them would’ve been able to meaningfully consent in the circumstances.

Personally, my read was that Mu Hanzhang would’ve been unlikely to give an outright no, and Jing Shao would likely have heeded it if he had — but it is ambiguous because it happens off-screen, and Jing Shao’s behaviour in hurting Mu Hanzhang (though later shown to be due to ignorance, at least in part) isn’t great, so keep all that in mind.

I would also note that there is some significant violence against women, largely off-screen, including Mu Hanzhang ordering for someone to be beaten to death for betraying him and Jing Shao. It isn’t treated as horrifying, just completely matter-of-fact — it’s almost easy to miss for how unremarkable it is. Most of the female characters are scheming and/or nasty, aside from one of Jing Shao’s servants (who works to protect Mu Hanzhang from the empress’ scheming) and Mu Hanzhang’s mother. Part of that is pretty much compelled by the plot: if only Mu Hanzhang stood by Jing Shao at the end, his other wives/concubines necessarily couldn’t stick by him… but it isn’t great.

That said, a lot of the rest is really sweet, and I actually really enjoyed it — for the number of words I’ve spent explaining these factors, they’re background to the story rather than the most prominent thing. Jing Shao quickly becomes fascinated with Mu Hanzhang, who is more reserved but quickly begins to have feelings for his husband as well, regardless of his fears around sex. The whole concept of “gentleman wives” (mandatory for the younger sons in certain families) and their gatherings is a nice touch, rather than just having Mu Hanzhang be some kind of exception. I also enjoyed that Jing Shao actually cares deeply about his elder brother, and we see their relationship grow as a result of his understanding (from his past life) that his brother cares for him.

Soo… overall, I enjoyed the relationship development and the court intrigue (and Mu Hanzhang’s scheming mind), and ended up flying through the book. I’m very curious to see how their relationship develops, and how the two of them manage to avoid the bad outcome that we see at the start, especially since Mu Hanzhang knows nothing about it (as least as far as we know, and the third person limited narrative seems to confirm that: Jing Shao is presumably the only one who got the “do-over”).

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Review – Guardian, vol 2

Posted July 1, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – Guardian, vol 2

Guardian

by Priest

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels, Mystery, Romance
Pages: 341
Series: Guardian #2
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

THE SLEEPING GOD STIRS

As snow quietly covers Dragon City in the final days of the lunar year, patients writhing in pain flock to the hospital. Baffled doctors call upon Zhao Yunlan and his team for help. As the case unfolds, Shen Wei and Zhao Yunlan discover that one of the Four Hallowed Artifacts, the Merit Brush, has appeared in the Mortal Realm. In the wrong hands, its power can be transformative.

While each step toward the artifact only pulls the pair deeper into a vortex of mysteries, Zhao Yunlan keeps stumbling upon a name: Kunlun. Who is Kunlun, and what is his connection to the Merit Brush? As Zhao Yunlan closes in on the answer, will he also uncover the truth behind Shen Wei's knowing gaze?

Book two of Priest’s Guardian gives us some major developments, both showing us who Zhao Yunlan really is and how he originally met Shen Wei, and getting into more detail on the bigger plot that’s bringing that to light. I must admit I probably need to skim the details again, but there’s a lot going on and a whole mythology here to figure out, but the way things are getting on is pretty intriguing.

We do get some more glimpses of the lives of the side characters Zhao Yunlan works with, and also of his family — his discussions with his parents about his sexuality and his relationship with Shen Wei are well done.

Aaaand we get some progression on the horrific pining, with Shen Wei and Zhao Yunlan moving toward an openly romantic relationship, with lots more pining and chemistry off the charts. I can’t wait to see how they sort themselves out and properly commit to something, with Zhao Yunlan aware of the history between them. I hope they get a really happy ending, given the tragedy that seems to have befallen them in the past. Only one more book for everything to resolve, and I can’t quite see how it can all be wrapped up in that time!

I do still dislike the way Zhao Yunlan (and maybe others) consistently call Daqing “fatty” and stuff like that, though. Sure, he’s a cat yao, not a human, but he’s a speaking character. I know that culturally it can come across differently, but it doesn’t seem to be meant positively here, so that’s worth being aware of.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – Guardian, vol 1

Posted May 26, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Guardian, vol 1

Guardian

by Priest

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels, Mystery, Romance
Pages: 408
Series: Guardian #1
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Zhao Yunlan heads up a covert division of the Ministry of Public Security that deals with the strange and unusual, blurring the line between the mortal realm and the Netherworld. His cocky, casual attitude conceals both a sharp mind and an arsenal of mystical tools and arcane knowledge.

While investigating a gruesome death at a local university, Zhao Yunlan crosses paths with the reserved Professor Shen Wei. Zhao Yunlan is immediately intrigued by Shen Wei’s good looks and intense gaze, and the attraction between them is immediate and powerful, even as Shen Wei tries to keep his distance. Shen Wei and his secrets are a puzzle Zhao Yunlan feels compelled to solve as mysterious circumstances throw them together, and their connection becomes impossible to deny.


Wow, volume one of Priest’s Guardian certainly brings the yearning. I wasn’t entirely sure at first, since Zhao Yunlan’s mooning after Shen Wei seemed a little one-sided (though there were some hints), but after about halfway through it’s clear there’s more going on and that the yearning is more than mutual — if anything, Shen Wei is more deeply in love than Zhao Yunlan.

Shen Wei had been restraining himself for too long. In the perfect silence, he couldn’t help letting go for once. Lying there with Zhao Yunlan so tantalisingly near, his thoughts spun out of control. He imagined gathering that warm body close, pressing kisses to those eyes, that hair, those lips… tasting and partaking of every part.
He imagined possessing Zhao Yunlan utterly.
The fantasy alone was enough to make Shen Wei’s breathing unsteady. He yearned with the desperate fervour of someone dreaming of hot soup as they froze to death.
But he didn’t move a muscle. Just looking at Zhao Yunlan and thinking about him was seemingly enough.

Ooof. Wow.

The relationship between Zhao Yunlan and Shen Wei is definitely a draw, but I’m enjoying the world and story as well: I figured out the identity of the Emissary ahead of time, but a lot of the details remain unclear, along with Zhao Yunlan’s last life, etc, and the various artefacts that Zhao Yunlan is presumably going to keep being drawn into encountering.

I will say that there’s a lot of stuff about Daqing (a cat) being really fat, calling him fatty, etc. The character isn’t solely comic relief and clearly has power of his own, and Zhao Yunlan insults everyone (especially Guo Changcheng, whose anxiety and awkwardness is frequently mocked), but… even the narrative gets in on calling Daqing fat all the time, and it’s definitely worth being aware of, as it’s clearly meant somewhat negatively/comically.

I’m definitely eager for the second book, in any case — I love Shen Wei, the yearning is palpable, and I’m curious where the story goes as well.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Disabled Tyrant’s Beloved Pet Fish, vol 4

Posted March 11, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – The Disabled Tyrant’s Beloved Pet Fish, vol 4

The Disabled Tyrant's Beloved Pet Fish

by Xue Shan Fei Hu

Genres: Fantasy, Light Novels, Romance
Pages: 443
Series: The Disabled Tyrant's Beloved Pet Fish #4
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

STILL WATERS RUN DEEP

With their union blessed by the emperor and four baby heirs in tow, Prince Jing is well on his way to clinching the position of crown prince. But Li Yu can’t pat himself on the back for a job well done just yet! Prince Jing’s crafty brother still lurks in the shadows plotting against him.

As Li Yu dives deeper into the sixth prince’s schemes, he uncovers a dastardly conspiracy that ripples from Prince Jing’s childhood, forming a tsunami poised to plunge the imperial palace (and its allies) into total chaos! Li Yu will have to use all the fishy tricks at his disposal if he wants to keep his new family safe!

The fourth volume of The Disabled Tyrant’s Beloved Pet Fish brings the whole thing to an end and wraps it up neatly with a bow, but dang, there’s a lot that happens in this volume still. After all, Prince Jing isn’t the crown prince yet, Li Yu still wants to have another baby, and there are those mysterious secrets that the fish-scamming system keeps showing him.

In general, I loved it. The babies are adorable, Li Yu and Mu Tianchi’s bond has become really strong (if sometimes in need of a tad more communication), and the political plot all works out and some of the secrets start to make sense.

I did want to address one thing, though: in this volume, the disabled tyrant is cured, in fact. Mu Tianchi’s mutism isn’t genetic, but has been caused by a low-dose poison he was given at birth. Once the poison is discovered and cured, he begins to be able to speak. You could argue that this is plot-necessary because otherwise he couldn’t become the emperor (at least not without becoming a tyrant), and also that Chinese culture isn’t in quite the same place about stuff like disability — but it’s still worth knowing, and worth knowing as well that there’s a brief mention of Li Yu telling the children that Mu Tianchi isn’t “different”, he’s “just sick”, implying it would be bad if he was disabled.

In the series as a whole, Li Yu never looks down on Mu Tianchi for being mute, and Mu Tianchi is always very capable — it’s just that it’s unacceptable for the emperor’s heir to be unable to speak. That said, that scene where Li Yu tries to explain away disability so as not to make the children think their dad is “different” suggests the author might treat permanent disability quite differently. So tread with care: there are some not-great attitudes toward disability swimming around the edges of the story and occasionally casting some shadows.

There are a few things that don’t entirely add up, plot-wise — e.g. the babies’ paternity was already confirmed on birth: Mu Tianchi offered his own blood for it rather than disturb Li Yu for his, I remember that scene clearly. Was that never communicated to the emperor? Not that he ever seems to genuinely doubt the children’s paternity anyway, but that whole bit is never mentioned as a reason why.

…But mostly I just loved it, really. It’s very sweet.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , , ,

Divider