Category: Reviews

Review – Off the Shelf

Posted October 31, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Off the Shelf

Off the Shelf: A Celebration of Bookshops in Verse

by Carol Ann Duffy (editor)

Genres: Poetry
Pages: 80
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

In Off the Shelf: A Celebration of Bookshops in Verse, Poet Laureate Carol Ann Duffy has commissioned a selection of the UK's most loved and lauded poets to each write a poem in celebration of books and bookshops--the worlds they hold, the freedoms they promise, and the memories they evoke. From a basement of forgotten books to the shelves of a cramped Welsh arcade, from the poetry corner of the local bookstore to the last bookshop standing in a post-apocalyptic world, these are poems that pay tribute to all the places that house the stories we treasure. With poems from Carol Ann Duffy, Scottish Makar Jackie Kay, National Poet of Wales Gillian Clarke, as well as Clive James, Michael Longley, Don Paterson, Patience Agbabi, and many more, this beautiful anthology is a heart-warming reminder of how books nourish us, save us, and inspire us.

Off the Shelf is a collection of poems edited by Carol Ann Duffy in celebration of bookshops. I’d note that it isn’t strictly just that: it’s a collection of poetry about bookshops, and sometimes the theme is quite loosely interpreted, meaning it doesn’t just mean a bunch of poems like “bookshops are great, libraries are too, without good books I’d sure be blue” or something like that.

One of my favourites was (predictably) Gillian Clarke’s contribution, which references the Welsh arcades — the poem is set many years before I was visiting the arcades, but I did visit Troutmark Books a lot when I was visiting my family and when I became a student in Cardiff!

The poems weren’t all for me, which is one of the risks and joys of an anthology.

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , ,

Divider

Review – Cryptic

Posted October 30, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – Cryptic

Cryptic: From Voynich to the Angel Diaries, the Story of the World's Mysterious Manuscripts

by Garry J. Shaw

Genres: History, Non-fiction
Pages: 331
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Books can change the world. They can influence, entertain, transport, and enlighten. But across the centuries, authors have disguised their work with codes and ciphers, secret scripts and magical signs. What made these authors decide to keep their writings secret? What were they trying to hide?

Garry J. Shaw tells the stories of nine puzzling European texts. Shaw explores the unknown alphabet of the nun Hildegard of Bingen; the enciphered manuscripts of the prank-loving physician Giovanni Fontana; and the angel communications of the polymath John Dee. Along the way, we discover how the pioneers of science and medicine concealed their work, encounter demon magic and secret societies, and delve into the intricate symbolism of alchemists searching for the Philosopher's Stone.

This highly enjoyable account takes readers on a fascinating journey through Europe's most cryptic writings--and attempts to shed new light on the biggest mystery of all: the Voynich Manuscript.

Garry J. Shaw’s Cryptic looks at various manuscripts that are a bit weird or difficult to understand or outright mysterious, starting with Hildegard of Bingen’s litterae ignota and going through the Voynich manuscript, the Rohonc Codex, Dee’s papers, etc. There are illustrations dotted throughout (mostly in black and white) to illustrate the points, and a good chunk of references etc at the back.

Part of the point is to contextualise these cryptic manuscripts and figure out whether the Voynich manuscript is something that can realistically be decrypted or just a hoax, and I will say that when Shaw gets to the conclusion, it’s easy to agree with him because he really has provided good context and discussion, and his ideas make sense.

The mysteries of these manuscripts are really quite tantalising, which is why I couldn’t resist picking up the book. I didn’t start out with an opinion on the Voynich manuscript, and wouldn’t have minded if Shaw hadn’t tried to be conclusive, because the whole thing is really interesting — in many ways, the Voynich manuscript is the least interesting book of those discussed here, because e.g. Dee’s story is absolutely wild, and I knew nothing about Michael Meier, Heckius or Giovanni Fontana.

Fascinating and very readable, do recommend!

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Chinese Maze Murders

Posted October 29, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – The Chinese Maze Murders

The Chinese Maze Murders

by Robert van Gulik

Genres: Crime, Historical Fiction, Mystery
Pages: 336
Series: Judge Dee Mysteries #1
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Poisoned plums, a cryptic scroll picture, passionate love letters, and a hidden murderer with a penchant for torturing and killing women lead Judge Dee to the heart of the Governor’s garden maze and the answers to three interwoven mysteries. The Chinese Maze Murders represents Robert van Gulik’s first venture into writing suspense novels after the success of Dee Gong An, his translation of an anonymous Chinese detective novel from the sixteenth century.

I was very curious about Robert van Gulik’s The Chinese Maze Murders after reading a little bit about how they came to be: after translating Dee Goong An, van Gulik was very interested in bringing classic Chinese detective stories to a modern audience, but found the stories (according to his preface to this volume) lacking in interest for a modern audience, either Chinese or Western. As a result, he wrote this book, which was then translated into Japanese and published in Japan, before being translated into Chinese. Only later was this English version released.

I think he does a fairly good job of using traditional Chinese stories and motifs while writing something that feels culturally comprehensible and interesting. There are various parts of the structure that are traditional, like the resolution of all the cases at once and the chapter featuring the punishment of the culprits, while he steered away from too much magic (which would’ve frequently been a part of the original stories).

Obviously, it’s hard to judge this in terms of the Chinese antecedents, but relating it to the crime fiction of his contemporaries, it fits in reasonably well — maybe a little old-fashioned and more akin to Sherlock Holmes than to other 1950s crime, but it doesn’t feel like it’d be unrecognisable or difficult to read at all (except maybe some issues keeping track of names; I didn’t have trouble, given I read danmei so I’m in practice).

A note on content, though: there is a plot in which an older woman tries to imprison younger girls out of sexual interest, which the author discusses in a note. Apparently it’s a not uncommon plot element, and he puts the prevalence of “sapphism” (that’s the term he uses) down to polygyny. There’s also sexual slavery and in general not amazing attitudes toward women, which again is I think related mostly but not wholly to the source stories and what van Gulik felt was fitting. There are also some stereotypes about and othering of Uighurs .

Overall, I found it really interesting, and I enjoyed learning about the context of it as well.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Review – After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine, vol 2

Posted October 28, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine, vol 2

After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine

by Liu Gou Hua

Genres: Fantasy, Historical Fiction, Light Novels, Romance
Pages: 400
Series: After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine #2
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

IS A PROMISE OF PROTECTION ENOUGH?

Jiang Suizhou, a history professor transmigrated into the frail and hated Prince of Jing, has been dealt quite the losing hand. His only bastion of hope? The captured, incapacitated Huo Wujiu, his concubine—and the general whose vengeance will end the Jing dynasty.

But Jiang Suizhou’s not going down with the ship! He joins hands with Huo Wujiu with a promise—protection now for protection in the future—and seeks out a physician to heal Huo Wujiu’s legs. The two men’s bond and trust deepens as they step beyond their mutual obligations to trade blows with Minister Pang, the puppeteer pulling the corrupt court’s strings.

Stained reputations, hidden motivations, and political assassinations abound as Huo Wujiu and Jiang Suizhou fulfill their promise. But is this protection alone enough to keep them both safe…and is it all they seek from one another?

I just had to read the second volume of Liu Gou Hua’s After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine right away, and I wasn’t disappointed — if anything, I think I liked it even more. The slow burn continues, and I’m so glad I could at least get volume three right away as well, even if I have to wait until November (I think) for the last volume.

Volume two features the misunderstandings/miscommunications thickening even more, since people don’t trust each other and don’t know who knows about what. This all pretty much makes sense in context: it’s not a situation where it’d make more sense for people to communicate, because they need to withhold information for safety purposes. There are a couple of cases that could be straightened out sooner, but mostly it all follows logically from the setting and plot. The only one that’s kinda superfluous is Jiang Suizhou’s lie to Meng Qianshan about why he’s interested in Huo Wujiu, but mostly Meng Qianshan’s investment in the relationship as a result of that is just. the. cutest.

I’m finding the slow burn really exquisite, too: the moments where each realises how they’re beginning to feel about the other are lovely, but I also loved the non-romantic scene where they’re celebrating together, Jiang Suizhou gets drunk, and starts telling Huo Wujiu all kinds of stuff, finally sleepily telling him that he’s so glad to be able to talk to him and that he’s been lonely. Just, aaah! So cute.

I’m very curious how this is going to resolve exactly, and how the two of them are going to triumph against their enemies — and whether Jiang Suizhou’s transmigration is ever properly explained, or likely to end?! We don’t know anything about why he transmigrated, really. I really really hope there’s a good happy ending for these two.

And please, a happy ending for the side characters too! Meng Qianshan, Gu Changyun and Xu Du, and even the friend from the Ministry of Rites who likes novels — please, please let them all come out okay.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Divider

Review – Yankee & Carameliser

Posted October 27, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Yankee & Carameliser

Yankee & Carameliser

by Chiuko Umeshibu

Genres: Manga, Romance
Pages: 164
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

Take one influencer and one bad boy extraordinaire, whisk in a sprinkling of sweets, a scoop of social media and you get...? Maki and Akito's love story, hot out of the oven! After all, even though Maki might have a bit of a bad rep, the guy must be just as gooey on the inside as the glorious goodies he posts all over social media. So when Akito gets a taste of how dangerously delicious his desserts are, he can't help wanting a taste of the man himself...

Chiuko Umeshibu’s Yankee & Carameliser is pretty cute: a bad boy teenager, Maki, gets caught anonymously posting images of gorgeous desserts by his classmate, Akito. Akito eagerly encourages him to post videos and talk more about how he makes food, drawing him out of his shell, and as they work together on that, Maki quickly falls in love.

There’s a pretty standard misunderstanding bit when Akito runs into Maki coming out of a love hotel with another man; Maki thinks Akito’s relieved when he says he didn’t have sex with the guy because Akito thinks that means he’s not gay (and to be fair, Akito’s sentiments are extremely badly expressed), while Akito simply means that he’s glad that (older) guy didn’t do anything to him that he didn’t end up wanting.

There’s also a bit of homophobia/transphobia in the air, since Maki’s cultivated the bad boy image to look ‘less weird’, after a childhood interest in playing cooking and liking cute things. He blames himself for his parents’ breakup after they caught him wearing lipstick. This is handled relatively lightly and isn’t addressed specifically between Akito and Maki: Akito just keeps being enthusiastic and loving Maki’s baking, thinking he’s cute, and eventually realising that he returns his feelings.

The result is a short-and-sweet love story that doesn’t really dig into the darker stuff implied at its edges. The relationship maybe feels a tiny bit rushed, but the chemistry does genuinely feel real, and Maki’s embarrassment at his growing feelings (and Akito’s returning them) is adorable.

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – Tigress

Posted October 26, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Tigress

Tigress

by Jessica Mookherjee

Genres: Poetry
Pages: 70
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

Jessica Mookherjee, highly commended in the 2017 Forward Prizes, presents her second collection of poems, Tigress. Mixing myth, magic and migration, these poems explore the impact of choice upon our lives and concentrate their magnificent, kaleidoscopic imagination on the intricate and often fraught nature of childhood and family, selfhood and womanhood.

Fierce, often funny, always charged and revealing, Mookerjee’s acute attention to detail tracks lives lived between Bengal, Wales and London. In exploring the intense displacement and loss that marks the experience of migration, the poems move into territories of danger and safety, illness and heartbreak, and ultimately into self-discovery; a rich and sensual moonlit menagerie of bears, big cats, wolves, and ‘forest mothers’. At every step, Tigress is wildly inventive, elegant and utterly distinctive.

I quite like Jessica Mookherjee’s Tigress, particularly the title poem — I saved this snippet, for example, which really jumped out for me:

Caged deep inside her chest,
she sedates it every morning and every night
before bed. Around tea-time,
her eyes flick open

as her heart-beat quickens.
[…]

Behind her husband’s back,
she plans an attack.
Until it starts to get dark. Until it’s time
to take her pills.

It helps as well that she knows Wales (I think grew up there?) and mentions places I know, little familiar things, along with the darker and sadder stuff about mental illness and family troubles. I don’t know how much of it is persona and how much is autobiography, but the poems were pretty powerful, and I like Mookherjee’s verse.

I’d definitely read more by her!

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , ,

Divider

Review – Servus

Posted October 25, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Servus

Servus: How Slavery Made the Roman Empire

by Emma Southon

Genres: History, Non-fiction
Pages: 448
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

We associate the Romans with majesty and greatness: we marvel at their straight roads and innovative underfloor heating, at the dominance of their army and navy, at the grandeur of their palaces and temples. But the Romans were also enslavers. They built an empire on the backs of millions of people snatched from their homes in the aftermath of war, kidnapped from the streets, sold into slavery as punishment or, simply, born enslaved.

Servus takes us into the invisible spaces of the Roman world, where millions of enslaved lives were unwillingly dedicated to the perpetuation of the empire that owned them. From the fields of wheat required to give every Roman their daily bread, to the actors and gladiators who provided their circuses, and the miners who kept Rome a city of gold and marble, enslaved people were the bedrock of the Roman Empire. These enslaved people were ubiquitous, but silenced. Through the fragments they left behind, historian Emma Southon traces the pain and tragedy of their lives alongside the love stories, lifelong friendships, small victories and hard-won freedoms.

Servus tells the truth about the Roman empire and the unseen lives that made it so dominant.

I’ve enjoyed Emma Southon’s books on ancient Rome quite a bit, and that’s partly due to her writing style (well evidenced but fairly flippant) and partly due to her particular angle, which often focuses on women. I actually originally got Servus to review, but didn’t finish it before I lost access to the ARC, so my reading was pretty drawn out.

Which honestly helped a little in one way, because this history of slavery in the Roman Empire is really horrifying. Southon spares little detail — indeed, to the point where it begins to feel a touch fetishistic, wallowing in the misery, though I do believe that the intention is to highlight how truly awful it was and make it clear that the claims of Roman slavery being remarkably tolerable are bullshit. It definitely succeeds at that.

For me, though, the level of detail and the number of times Southon reiterated that we don’t have direct evidence but this is what slavery in America was like all sort of wore on me. There are definitely interesting things and things I didn’t know, but less so than in her other books, perhaps because I’m fairly familiar with evidence about slavery in ancient Rome and I knew very little about murder in ancient Rome or about Agrippina.

And… given the heaviness of the topic, repeatedly emphasised, sometimes the flippant tone I usually enjoy didn’t entirely work for me here.

It’s definitely a detailed look at slavery in ancient Rome, and it’s plentifully furnished with citations, but it didn’t quite hit the spot for me.

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Abbey Court Murders

Posted October 25, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – The Abbey Court Murders

The Abbey Court Murder

by Annie Haynes

Genres: Crime, Mystery
Pages: 217
Series: Inspector Furnival #1
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

“A crime of a peculiarly mysterious nature was perpetrated some time last night in a block of flats called Abbey Court.”

Lady Judith Carew acted furtively on the night of the Denboroughs’ party. Her secret assignation at 9:30pm was a meeting to which she took a loaded revolver. The Abbey Court apartment building would play host to violent death that very night, under cover of darkness. The killer’s identity remained a mystery, though Lady Carew had a most compelling motive – and her revolver was left in the dead man’s flat…

Enter the tenacious Inspector Furnival in the first of his golden age mysteries, first published in 1923. Though there are many clues, there are just as many red herrings and the case takes numerous Christie-esque twists before the murderer can be revealed.

Annie Haynes is a writer I hadn’t come across before, so I was quite interested to read her biography. I wonder why her books were forgotten so quickly? Perhaps in part it’s to do with the fact that she got quite severely ill quite young, and spent a lot of her time housebound. I was also interested to note that she moved in with a friend, Ada Heather-Bigg, and stayed there for years as a “guest”; one is definitely tempted to speculate about a romantic relationship between the two!

In any case, despite the comparisons to Christie, I do think Haynes was a slightly better writer, though The Abbey Court Murder does have quite the share of melodrama (e.g. a child falling conveniently ill just at the moment it heightens tension, and lots of fainting and so on) — to me her characters felt a bit more real, though that’s partly because she focuses more on that than the mystery.

The mystery itself was relatively obvious from the clues, some of which I think were maybe given a little too early if it was supposed to be hanging onto the tension of what evidence might arise to exonerate the main couple. We don’t see a lot of the process of solving, so most of the tension relies on the characters waiting breathlessly, believing themselves to be doomed, and that’s helped along when there’s less explanation of the detective’s methods.

Overall, it’s not 100% to my taste, but I did enjoy it, and I’d try more of Haynes’ work!

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Double Dorothy

Posted October 23, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 4 Comments

Review – The Double Dorothy

The Double Dorothy

by Olivia Waite

Genres: Crime, Mystery, Science Fiction
Pages: 112
Series: Dorothy Gentleman #3
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Becky Chambers meets Miss Marple in the third entry of this cozy sci-fi mystery series, helmed by a formidable no-nonsense auntie of a detective.

As the Fairweather approaches the halfway point of its journey, Dorothy Gentleman may have reached the end of hers…

It’s been a long lifetime, and Dorothy’s current body is on its last legs. With a new terminal diagnosis from Medical, she’s counting the days until her next reembodiment. But then a young man with someone else’s face sits down and claims he is Dorothy’s next embodiment — someone has triggered the system early, using the memory-book Dorothy last updated over a month ago.

Meaning that according to the laws, when Dorothy dies this time — it will be permanent.

Now Dorothy and her doppelganger must sift through that last month of memories, looking for a secret someone’s trying to erase. And all the threads lead back to the very first murder that happened on the Fairweather, five hundred years ago. A case which remains unsolved — and in which Dorothy was a witness, not a detective. All while an old enemy finally dares to step out of the shadows…

I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

Olivia Waite’s The Double Dorothy is the third book of the series, and she’s certainly not happy to simply relax into things: this book introduces another new character, of a sort, because Dorothy’s been re-embodied while still alive — in the body of a young man — presumably because of something she’s learned since her last memory book update. The two Dorothys have got to work out what that is exactly, and also deal with the whole problem of having two of them alive at the same time.

In the process, we learn a little more about the embarkation of the ship, the first murder that occurred on board, and yes, finally, a significant amount more about Violet. All in all, it kept adding stuff to the world and was a really fun read.

I think there are some problems it didn’t really reckon with — look away if you don’t want any spoilers, though I’ll try to keep things general! — like the fact that “Uncle Dorothy” was going around in the body of another person, which is briefly alluded to as a logistical problem, but handwaved in the denouement, despite the fact that his fingerprints will be identical to those of the other version of that body. Or like the fact that Uncle Dorothy is also attracted to Violet, and has much more recent memories with her than with Celia… but also any gender dysphoria that they might feel is fairly handwaved, even though they reference finding it weird to be taller than usual.

I get that that isn’t super cosy, but given that gender and sex are a big deal to many, many people, it felt weird to have both Celia and Uncle Dorothy handwaving it, without a larger previous context of people just choosing to try out other bodies and everyone being blasé about it (unless it was there previously and I missed it?). It’d make a certain amount of sense, but then I’m a bit confused about Dorothy having been so thrown by Gloria’s body in the first book.

Anyway, I don’t want that to overshadow the fact that I really enjoyed this — I think I might’ve read it faster than either of the previous books! It was definitely enjoyable, and I’m curious what happens with “Uncle Dorothy” in future books.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Review – Cat + Gamer, vol 8

Posted October 22, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Cat + Gamer, vol 8

Cat + Gamer

by Wataru Nadatani

Genres: Manga
Pages: 160
Series: Cat + Gamer #8
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

Office worker Riko Kozakura lives to play video games, but her life changes forever when she adopts a kitten! Soon, she has two playful cats and takes lessons from video games to help raise them.

Riko Kozakura has been level grinding as a pet owner for a while now, and has learned many new skills. Life continues in the Kozakura household with two cats and one videogaming-obsessed human in this finale to the popular manga series! “Leveling up” in skills, surprises, and adventures, Riko discovers how to adjust her apartment and daily habits for two cats!

I can’t believe volume 8 of Cat + Gamer ends the series! It seems like one that could go on forever — but then, maybe that’s why it’s a good thing that it ends, rather than spinning out the idea into infinity and maybe getting a bit (whisper it) boring/repetitive.

Volume 8 is more of the same sort of story, but features Riko making some big life decisions… with some help (comically, as you’d expect) from the cats. There are other aspects of it, like the cats getting a spa day, and Riko playing along with cat trends… but it also draws the series to a close in a way, though I won’t spoiler.

I did wonder… Riko’s fairly openly talking about the cats in the office in this volume. When did she stop being worried about her coworkers working out that she was the author of the kitty account posting Musubi pictures?! That feels like it just faded out. Or did I miss something…?

Anyway, still cute/silly, and I’ll kinda miss the series, even if it’s very simple.

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , ,

Divider