Tag: SF/F

Review – Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint (manhwa), vol 4

Posted November 1, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint (manhwa), vol 4

Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint

by Sleepy-C, Umi, singNsong

Genres: Fantasy, Manga
Pages: 240
Series: Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint (manhwa) #4
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Dokja has his hands full dealing with the relentless monster attacks, as well as Landlord Coalition’s schemes. But when Junghyeok Yu disappears amidst the chaos, he’s faced with a chilling question—when the main character of this universe dies, what happens to the rest of the world...? Not wanting to find out, Dokja sets out to look for the missing Regressor in the Theatre Dungeon!

Volume four of the Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint manhwa (adapted from singNsong’s novel by Umi, illustrated by Sleepy-C) covers the events at Chungmuro Station, as Dokja uses his foreknowledge to protect his little group without committing atrocities and help everyone resolve the scenario. It also features the beginning of the Cinema Dungeon, though there’s more to come.

I really like the Cinema Dungeon part, so I’m looking forward to that, but the whole Chungmuro scenario is pretty fun. We meet Jihye, who has already been recruited by Junghyeok, and she seems pretty cool (though I don’t know a lot about her as this is close to the extent of what the light novels have featured so far in official English translation).

I also really giggled at the extra with Huiwan and Hyeonseong where she guesses that his sponsoring constellation is actually Captain America. I don’t think that’s right, but it’s still funny.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , , ,

Divider

Review – After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine, vol 2

Posted October 28, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine, vol 2

After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine

by Liu Gou Hua

Genres: Fantasy, Historical Fiction, Light Novels, Romance
Pages: 400
Series: After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine #2
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

IS A PROMISE OF PROTECTION ENOUGH?

Jiang Suizhou, a history professor transmigrated into the frail and hated Prince of Jing, has been dealt quite the losing hand. His only bastion of hope? The captured, incapacitated Huo Wujiu, his concubine—and the general whose vengeance will end the Jing dynasty.

But Jiang Suizhou’s not going down with the ship! He joins hands with Huo Wujiu with a promise—protection now for protection in the future—and seeks out a physician to heal Huo Wujiu’s legs. The two men’s bond and trust deepens as they step beyond their mutual obligations to trade blows with Minister Pang, the puppeteer pulling the corrupt court’s strings.

Stained reputations, hidden motivations, and political assassinations abound as Huo Wujiu and Jiang Suizhou fulfill their promise. But is this protection alone enough to keep them both safe…and is it all they seek from one another?

I just had to read the second volume of Liu Gou Hua’s After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine right away, and I wasn’t disappointed — if anything, I think I liked it even more. The slow burn continues, and I’m so glad I could at least get volume three right away as well, even if I have to wait until November (I think) for the last volume.

Volume two features the misunderstandings/miscommunications thickening even more, since people don’t trust each other and don’t know who knows about what. This all pretty much makes sense in context: it’s not a situation where it’d make more sense for people to communicate, because they need to withhold information for safety purposes. There are a couple of cases that could be straightened out sooner, but mostly it all follows logically from the setting and plot. The only one that’s kinda superfluous is Jiang Suizhou’s lie to Meng Qianshan about why he’s interested in Huo Wujiu, but mostly Meng Qianshan’s investment in the relationship as a result of that is just. the. cutest.

I’m finding the slow burn really exquisite, too: the moments where each realises how they’re beginning to feel about the other are lovely, but I also loved the non-romantic scene where they’re celebrating together, Jiang Suizhou gets drunk, and starts telling Huo Wujiu all kinds of stuff, finally sleepily telling him that he’s so glad to be able to talk to him and that he’s been lonely. Just, aaah! So cute.

I’m very curious how this is going to resolve exactly, and how the two of them are going to triumph against their enemies — and whether Jiang Suizhou’s transmigration is ever properly explained, or likely to end?! We don’t know anything about why he transmigrated, really. I really really hope there’s a good happy ending for these two.

And please, a happy ending for the side characters too! Meng Qianshan, Gu Changyun and Xu Du, and even the friend from the Ministry of Rites who likes novels — please, please let them all come out okay.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Divider

Fantasy with Friends: Magical Realism

Posted October 26, 2026 by Nicky in General / 8 Comments

Fantasy With Friends: A Disccusion Meme hosted by Pages Unbound

Monday means Fantasy with Friends time! All the prompts are hosted at Pages Unbound, if you’d like to join in. This week’s prompt is about whether fantasy is about magical realism:

Do you see magical realism as related to fantasy? Do you enjoy reading it? Why or why not?

I think this question means to ask about “magical realism” as in the off-brand, non-Latin American stuff that gets used to spice up literary and contemporary fiction sometimes. As far as the “original”(?) stuff goes, I don’t know a lot about the Latin American literary tradition of magical realism, and though I’ve read (and largely enjoyed) my Gabriel García Márquez, I haven’t read a lot of magical realism that actually stems from that tradition. As such, discussing that aspect would feel pretty out of my lane as a white Welsh person living in the UK and not well-versed in the tradition, even with two literature degrees.

It’s my understanding that magical realism as a tradition is considered to be separate from fantasy, anyway; what I’ve read about it and what I quickly revised about it before writing this post makes me think that that explanation is using a very specific definition of fantasy that I don’t necessarily endorse… but at the same time, “fantasy” can still be a pretty white space with a lot of baggage and assumptions, so I can understand drawing lines around magical realism to make it clear it’s something else. Plus, there’s definitely a different feel to the OG magical realism to most fantasy: magical and surreal occurrences just happen in magical realism, and the point isn’t to get to what and why, as it might be in fantasy.

There is a fair bit of magical realism that isn’t Latin American, of course, and for me that usually seems to be at the very least fantasy-adjacent. Maybe a matter of degree, sometimes; whether it’s a light touch of magic, or something that’s dug into and which the narrative tries to understand… stuff like Before the Coffee Gets Cold could arguably be called magical realism. I think that same lack of interest in understanding why the magic is happening or what the magic is doing, etc, is often the marker of something that’s more “magical realism” than “fantasy”.

And sometimes it seems like a matter of deciding what awards you want to be eligible for: the Booker prize or the Hugos, or whatever: if you want one, you’ll call it magical realism and literary fiction, and if you want the other, you’ll probably call it fantasy.

(Of course publishers are also involved there.)

I’ve enjoyed some magical realism, both the actual Latin American magical realism and the Starbucks version that’s borrowed the term, but that’s not a surprising statement to anyone who knows the range of genres I read. That said, I’m not a huge fan of postmodernism, so some of the more postmodernist writers don’t work for me.

Tags: , , ,

Divider

Review – The Double Dorothy

Posted October 23, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 4 Comments

Review – The Double Dorothy

The Double Dorothy

by Olivia Waite

Genres: Crime, Mystery, Science Fiction
Pages: 112
Series: Dorothy Gentleman #3
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Becky Chambers meets Miss Marple in the third entry of this cozy sci-fi mystery series, helmed by a formidable no-nonsense auntie of a detective.

As the Fairweather approaches the halfway point of its journey, Dorothy Gentleman may have reached the end of hers…

It’s been a long lifetime, and Dorothy’s current body is on its last legs. With a new terminal diagnosis from Medical, she’s counting the days until her next reembodiment. But then a young man with someone else’s face sits down and claims he is Dorothy’s next embodiment — someone has triggered the system early, using the memory-book Dorothy last updated over a month ago.

Meaning that according to the laws, when Dorothy dies this time — it will be permanent.

Now Dorothy and her doppelganger must sift through that last month of memories, looking for a secret someone’s trying to erase. And all the threads lead back to the very first murder that happened on the Fairweather, five hundred years ago. A case which remains unsolved — and in which Dorothy was a witness, not a detective. All while an old enemy finally dares to step out of the shadows…

I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

Olivia Waite’s The Double Dorothy is the third book of the series, and she’s certainly not happy to simply relax into things: this book introduces another new character, of a sort, because Dorothy’s been re-embodied while still alive — in the body of a young man — presumably because of something she’s learned since her last memory book update. The two Dorothys have got to work out what that is exactly, and also deal with the whole problem of having two of them alive at the same time.

In the process, we learn a little more about the embarkation of the ship, the first murder that occurred on board, and yes, finally, a significant amount more about Violet. All in all, it kept adding stuff to the world and was a really fun read.

I think there are some problems it didn’t really reckon with — look away if you don’t want any spoilers, though I’ll try to keep things general! — like the fact that “Uncle Dorothy” was going around in the body of another person, which is briefly alluded to as a logistical problem, but handwaved in the denouement, despite the fact that his fingerprints will be identical to those of the other version of that body. Or like the fact that Uncle Dorothy is also attracted to Violet, and has much more recent memories with her than with Celia… but also any gender dysphoria that they might feel is fairly handwaved, even though they reference finding it weird to be taller than usual.

I get that that isn’t super cosy, but given that gender and sex are a big deal to many, many people, it felt weird to have both Celia and Uncle Dorothy handwaving it, without a larger previous context of people just choosing to try out other bodies and everyone being blasé about it (unless it was there previously and I missed it?). It’d make a certain amount of sense, but then I’m a bit confused about Dorothy having been so thrown by Gloria’s body in the first book.

Anyway, I don’t want that to overshadow the fact that I really enjoyed this — I think I might’ve read it faster than either of the previous books! It was definitely enjoyable, and I’m curious what happens with “Uncle Dorothy” in future books.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

Fantasy with Friends: Real Things

Posted October 19, 2026 by Nicky in General / 9 Comments

Fantasy With Friends: A Disccusion Meme hosted by Pages Unbound

Monday means Fantasy with Friends time! All the prompts are hosted at Pages Unbound, if you’d like to join in. This week’s prompt is about whether fantasy is about “real things”:

Some people argue that fantasy isn’t worth reading because it’s not about real things. What is your response?

Mostly, I think that if fantasy isn’t for you — if you can’t suspend disbelief, or you argue too much with basic premises, or can’t keep the worldbuilding straight, or whatever it is — then… don’t read it, that’s no skin off my nose!

But I do think fantasy is still about real things. It’s written by people, and inevitably it’s about people, even if those people have pointy ears or fangs or transform into werewolves or have implausible monarchies or whatever it is. I think there are probably some exceptions, because there always are, but we’re a pretty self-centred species and I think it’s often about us, really, and the themes and plotlines are generally things of interest to humans — just wrapped up in a fantasy setting.

And like I said, I can get if that’s not your jam, absolutely, but I don’t think it’s factually correct to say that “fantasy isn’t about real things”. On a superficial level, sure, it’s about potions, spells, fantastical beasts, transformations, fairies, etc, etc. But that’s just the way we dress it up; it isn’t just about that. Even the simplest fantasies aimed at kids get at real human things that kids are interested in!

Tags: , ,

Divider

Review – Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint (manhwa), vol 3

Posted October 16, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint (manhwa), vol 3

Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint

by Sleepy-C, Umi, singNsong

Genres: Fantasy, Manga
Pages: 248
Series: Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint (manhwa) #3
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

With all the food destroyed by the goblin, Dokja’s group is forced to venture into the dark tunnels teeming with vicious creatures. But in the cruel new world, monsters are not the most dangerous enemies. When the atrocities committed by the “Major Group” come to light, chaos ensues in Geumho Station. And amidst the bloodshed, Huiwon’s true power awakens...the Time of Judgment is nigh!

The third volume of the Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint manhwa covers the aftermath of the group’s arrival at the next station, and their trek to Chungmaro Station. The pacing and storyline all feel pretty much the same as the light novel, so you could almost read them interchangeably (except that the volume numbers don’t match up due to the formats, and maybe missing out on some of Dokja’s internal monologue here and there).

I really love Huiwon; though she’s introduced through a “damsel in distress” type situation where sexual assault has been attempted and she’s in bad shape, that’s a key part of how her character evolves and why she gains the abilities she does. It doesn’t feel gratuitous to me, though I’ve seen some other people complaining about it; amongst all the other violence in Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint, it feels significant that it’s mostly not sexual. The story doesn’t want to focus on that, even while we’re seeing a post-apocalyptic breakdown of society: it’s just important that Huiwon was so vulnerable, that people were so vile to her, more so than stealing food or attacking her or something like that.

Still, your mileage may vary and it’s worth keeping in mind that that’s part of Huiwon’s origin story, and may be touched on again.

I continue to enjoy Dokja’s scheming, of course, and I look forward to getting to the “cinema” section in the manhwa (maybe next volume? or the one after?).

N.B. This is being posted a couple months after I read it and I’ve actually read up to volume 10 by now and have 11 coming up on my TBR.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , , ,

Divider

Fantasy with Friends: Fantasy Worlds to Live in

Posted October 12, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 4 Comments

Fantasy With Friends: A Disccusion Meme hosted by Pages Unbound

Monday means Fantasy with Friends time! All the prompts are hosted at Pages Unbound, if you’d like to join in. This week’s prompt is about fantasy worlds you’d want to live in:

What fantasy world(s) would you want to live in? Why?

None, really. I know that’s a really boring answer, and it’s also the same answer I give to questions about what period you’d like to travel to. I like where I am, mostly! Obviously there’s things I’d change in the wider socioeconomic and political environment, if I could wave a magic wand, but I have few regrets about my life, where I live, what I do, etc.

I suppose if I’m to play the game here and pick, it’d have to be something with portal fantasy: I can be here, but I can also visit a fantasy world. Preferably one without dire events, thanks: Narnia or Fionavar in times of peace and plenty, say. I’m a wuss!

If the question were about visiting other fantasy worlds for some brief period, if I could get a safe conduct so I’ll be totally fine… well, there’s plenty. Middle-Earth, for one.

But mostly, I like this world, even with all its flaws.

Tags: , , ,

Divider

Review – After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine, vol 1

Posted October 8, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine, vol 1

After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine

by Liu Gou Hua

Genres: Fantasy, Historical Fiction, Light Novels, Romance
Pages: 378
Series: After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine #1
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

A strange thesis becomes one professor’s reality when he’s transmigrated to the past and awakens as a doomed prince in this hit danmei (Boys’ Love)!

When an outrageous thesis hits the desk of esteemed history professor Jiang Suizhou, his initial reaction is pure skepticism. Dubiously sourced, this thesis tells the story of the legendary General Huo Wujiu, a man renowned for his valor—that is, until he was captured. Stripped of his rank and incapacitated, the general suffered further humiliation by serving as a gift and concubine to his enemy’s brother—the cut-sleeve prince. For three grueling years, Huo Wujiu lived as a prisoner until he finally escaped and sought vengeance against those who dared to torment him.

Convinced this story is purely fiction, Jiang Suizhou brands the thesis a failure–does his student think he was born yesterday?! But Jiang Suizhou quickly learns that it was no mere tall tale when he wakes up as the cut-sleeve prince himself!

Now, stuck lording over his concubine and prisoner, Huo Wujiu, Jiang Suizhou must navigate a treacherous imperial court and avoid the general’s future wrath–lest he wind up with his head dangling from the turrets. His only option? Ally himself with Huo Wujiu. Using his vast knowledge of history, the clever professor devises strategies to shield the incapacitated former general, all while treating him with the utmost care. Yet, Jiang Suizhou’s strategy could backfire if Huo Wujiu were to get the wrong idea about his intentions…

I wasn’t entirely sure what to expect with volume one of Liu Gou Hua’s After the Disabled God of War Became My Concubine; it’s not one I’d seen other readers talking about, or seen people posting fic about, or anything like that. It was a bit of an impulse-buy based on the storyline… I’ve read several transmigration type stories now and it’s not quite that that attracted me, but more the fact that essentially the “disabled god of war” of the title is a disabled prisoner of war being humiliated, and how the author managed to make a romance work in that context.

I am pleased to report that it’s fairly slow-burn, and we’re not being expected to believe that everything’s fixed at first sight! Things aren’t even fixed by Jiang Suizhou turning up in the historical prince’s body. Thankfully, he’s not set up to arrive after things have gone wrong already (as per Shen Yuan turning up after Shen Jiu has already been abusing Luo Binghe in The Scum Villain’s Self-Saving System, or Jing Shao’s do-over in The Wife Comes First which comes after he’s already carelessly hurt Mu Hanzhang in bed), so he manages to avert outright atrocities, meaning it all feels a bit more realistic that Huo Wujiu could eventually trust him.

I do know that Huo Wujiu’s injuries are actually going to be healed, despite their extensiveness now, and I’m not entirely sure how I feel about that — magically healing disabilities is an awkward topic, though I don’t know how much Chinese society or Chinese writers have reckoned with stuff around disability. My impression/understanding is “really not much at all”, so that is worth knowing going in. Huo Wujiu manages to be pretty badass from the wheelchair.

Anyway, things proceed slowly but surely, mostly focusing on the political aspects, Jiang Suizhou’s new body’s health (he’s actually pretty frail, essentially chronically ill himself) and only gradually bringing the two of them closer. They’re definitely not confiding in each other yet, even.

I also quite enjoyed that Jiang Suizhou does not really do a lot to hide that he’s no longer the same guy, at least around some members of his household who seem like potential allies. He’s smart: he could probably have figured out how to fool them. But he chooses instead to confide in them enough to make better allies of them, and I’m very curious how that’s going to turn out in the longer run in this story.

All in all, a lot of elements I find interesting, and I’d say the writing/translation feels a touch better than The Wife Comes First, which was my other recent danmei read, which is nice — I’m starting to get a feel for what I like/don’t like in danmei and English translations thereof!

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , , ,

Divider

Fantasy with Friends: Over the Years

Posted October 5, 2026 by Nicky in General / 0 Comments

Fantasy With Friends: A Disccusion Meme hosted by Pages Unbound

Monday means Fantasy with Friends time! All the prompts are hosted at Pages Unbound, if you’d like to join in. This week’s prompt is about fantasy as a genre over the years:

How do you think the fantasy genre has changed over the years? Is there a particular time period of fantasy writing that you particularly enjoy?

I have a pretty good knowledge of some genres/eras within certain genres because I studied them, so I’m a bit scared of this question: it’s not really my area at all! I haven’t brought a lot of my academic practice to the fantasy genre at all, and it feels like my personal knowledge is coloured as much by just growing up and the natural change/growth in my interests as by real trends and changes.

Obviously there’s stuff like the rise of cosy fantasy and romantasy (though there were low-stakes fantasies before the trend, and plenty of romance in fantasy before it became a named subgenre), and the grimdark fantasy that came some years before it — but I think that it’s probably much like fashion, and some things go around and come back in later.

I can’t think of really good rigorous examples, but I also think there are things my generation loved at children that are surfacing in adult fiction. I haven’t thought this through on a serious level, but… is dark academia in fantasy perhaps a response (at least for some of us) to the magical school we may’ve loved as kids, and what’s become of that for many of us? And even if we didn’t love it, was it popular enough to weave its way though our psyches and shape what we want to write and read about anyway? I think it’s likely.

Anyway, to the point about what we enjoy, I really enjoy a lot of cosy fantasy and romantasy: there’s plenty of it that feels a bit cookie-cutter, or not polished, or naive, but that’s the nature of any trend. Standalone books are also a joy — I don’t know if I’m right that there’s been more of that and fewer automatic trilogies, though. But I’m also a fan of older fantasies like Guy Gavriel Kay’s The Fionavar Tapestry, Tad William’s Memory, Sorrow and Thorn… they really had a lot to sink your teeth into. Long story short, perhaps I’m easy to please.

Overall, probably an unsatisfying answer, I’m afraid; I don’t think about things this way, it seems! At least when it comes to fantasy, unless it’s related to Tolkien or Arthuriana, I think I’ve kept my academic life out of it — helped by the fact that I finished my MA over a decade ago now, and switched away from the arts to science for a while.

Tags: , , ,

Divider

Review – Apparently, Sir Cameron Needs To Die

Posted October 4, 2026 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Apparently, Sir Cameron Needs To Die

Apparently, Sir Cameron Needs to Die

by Greer Stothers

Genres: Fantasy
Pages: 383
Rating: one-star
Synopsis:

In this hilarious, off-the-wall queer fantasy romance, a reclusive sorcerer is forced to protect a cowardly knight after a prophecy ties their fates together.

Funny, touching and inventive, this book is perfect for fans of A Marvellous Light and Dreadful.

All his life, Sir Cameron has tried to stay as far away from danger as possible. But when the Church hands down a prophecy to his fellow knights predicting that the only way to defeat their nemesis, the mad sorcerer Merulo, is to kill Sir Cameron, he finds himself in a situation too sticky for even his considerable wiles. Short of ideas, Cameron throws himself on the mercy of the one person who now actually wants him to survive: the mad sorcerer.

Merulo isn't thrilled to be babysitting a spoilt, attention-seeking knight, but fate has tied them together. And transmogrifying Cameron into a vulture is at least a great source of entertainment. Cameron, meanwhile, is on a voyage of self-discovery. It turns out he's really, really into surly sorcerers who lock him up and tell him what to do. Who knew?

As a legion of knights surround their stronghold, led by an angry concussed elf—which definitely isn't in any way Cameron's fault—the sorcerer's poisonous ambitions draw ever closer to fruition. Cameron is quite invested in not dying, but he finds he's also invested in Merulo. And sometimes, supporting the sorcerer you care about means taking an interest in their hobbies. Even if their hobby is trying to kill God.

Even if it might get you killed, too.

I was quite interested in Greer Stothers’ Apparently, Sir Cameron Has To Die from early buzz, though I think the summary I read is not the one on the back cover or the current one on store-fronts: I’d probably have known it almost certainly wasn’t for me if I’d seen it referred to as “hilarious” and “off-the-wall”. That’s really the primary problem with this book for me: I bounced off fairly early on because it’s trying so hard to be funny, and the scatological humour actually isn’t the height of wit that it seems to think it is.

Before we go on, it’s my understanding that I need to point out that I’m writing this review for other readers, not to target Stothers, because apparently they’ve been posting bad reviews on their Tumblr and responding to them. I have found no direct evidence of this myself, but I also haven’t looked for long, and I can definitely tell that Stothers is Very Extremely Tumblr so it doesn’t… surprise me.

I also had some issues with Sir Cameron’s anxiety being treated as a joke and as cowardice. I know that’s the character’s and world’s framing, not the author’s (necessarily), but it just crosses a personal line. Being afraid of dying isn’t cowardice. Wanting to avoid fighting in a war isn’t, in fact, unreasonable (though unless I missed it, I think there was no real explanation there as to why Sir Cameron is a knight at all given he doesn’t want to fight). It was… unpleasant, to read that constantly being viewed as just cowardice, even given the bounds of the setting.

Then there’s everything pointed out in other reviews: weird gender essentialism, unnecessary fetishism about women’s bodies, utter disgust and horror about menstruation, Glenda the cartoon-level bigot who we are forced to spend a fair bit of time with, the “tawny-skinned” female character with her “wild” hair and bulging muscles, attitudes toward disability (and assistive technology)…

And on top of all that, there is zero (zero) chemistry between the characters, even in scenes where the author firmly wants us to believe there is. It’s just awkward and out of the blue.

In fairness, some of this is a “your mileage may vary” sort of thing depending on how you feel about some story/setting choices, some of it is well-intentioned, and I think some of it is just accidental… but the sum of all those parts is not (for me) an enjoyable read, and I definitely understand that it feels like the author is, whether blunderingly or deliberately and with whatever motives, engaging in bigoted stereotypes.

Rating: 1/5 (“didn’t like it”)

Tags: , , , ,

Divider