Genre: Graphic Novels

Review – Immortal Red Sonja, vol 2

Posted August 24, 2025 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Immortal Red Sonja, vol 2

Immortal Red Sonja

by Dan Abnett, Alessandro Miracolo

Genres: Arthuriana, Fantasy, Graphic Novels
Pages: 136
Series: Immortal Red Sonja #2
Rating: one-star
Synopsis:

The journey has been long, and the dangers grave - but now, armed with a fuller understanding of the burden she carries, Sonja the Red and her cursed chainmail set off on the final leg of their magical journey through the Dead Lands. What she finds in the endless fog, and the truths that Merlyn reveals, will change her forever - and set the whole world in a new direction!Acclaimed author DAN ABNETT and renowned artist ALESSANDRO MIRACOLO bring their unique new vision of the She-Devil With a Sword to a stunning conclusion in this second volume of Immortal Red Sonja! Collects issues #6-10.

Volume two of Dan Abnett’s Immortal Red Sonja wraps up on the story of the cursed mail shirt, supposedly containing the spirit of King Arthur. I find it a bit disorientating as a fan (and sometime scholar, dissertation and all) of Arthuriana: the cherrypicking and twisting of names and stories is a bit bewildering, and yet there’s clearly knowledge behind it (linking Gawain with the Green Knight, though of course the Green Knight should be Bertilak, not Gawain). Sometimes it was hard to tell if it was deliberate distortion or just random scraps cobbled together without research.

Story-wise, it was fairly unsurprising, and I have some kind of feeling about the idea of Red Sonja, of all people, being a successor to King Arthur. What in the heck. She should be underestimated at your peril, but she’s not High King material, and it’s especially weird to have her be the heir to a Welsh king (prince, in the original, but okay).

In the end, I think my ambiguous feelings about the first volume resolve to oh hell no, not so much because it adapts stories of King Arthur and twists them far out of true, but because it just doesn’t come together.

I’m not a great lover of the art in this particular run, though some of the cover variants are great.

Rating: 1/5 (“didn’t like it”)

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Divider

Review – Fence, vol 3

Posted August 10, 2025 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – Fence, vol 3

Fence

by C.S. Pacat, Johanna the Mad, Joanna LaFuente

Genres: Graphic Novels
Pages: 112
Series: Fence #3
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

From the superstar team of C.S. Pacat (The Captive Prince) and fan-favorite artist Johanna the Mad comes the third volume of this acclaimed, dynamic series.

C.S. Pacat’s Fence series continues to be fun in volume three, still illustrated beautifully by Johanna the Mad and Joana LaFuente. The stakes are high in this volume, with Nicholas’ scholarship hanging in the balance — and that cliffhanger at the end, of course!

I love the character interactions and insights in this volume (ah, Eugene, wow, you’re lovely), even if the beats are still pretty predictable. As I’ve said before, it’s a good kind of predictable, at least to me.

Also, let’s just enjoy Bobby, who just happens to dress in femme clothing, but nobody ever says a word about it. I do love all the character designs a lot, and Bobby’s adorable.

Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)

Tags: , , , , , ,

Divider

Review – The All-Nighter, vol 3

Posted August 5, 2025 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – The All-Nighter, vol 3

The All-Nighter

by Chip Zdarsky, Jason Loo, Paris Alleyne, Frank Cvetkovic, Allison O'Toole

Genres: Fantasy, Graphic Novels
Pages: 114
Series: The All-Nighter #3
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

In this final arc, the staff at The All-Nighter are trying to piece their lives back together in the wake of Alex’s disappearance. They know that Alex would stop at nothing to get any of them back, so they have no choice: it's time to bring this fight to The Takers.

With unexpected new allies, the crew will have to live up to Alex’s dreams of super heroes. If they want to rescue their friend and uncover the mystery of The Takers, they’ll have to do it as a team—or as a family.

The third volume of Chip Zdarsky’s The All-Nighter certainly goes places. Alex’s been kidnapped by the Takers, and everyone else is trying to figure out what the new rules are. The found family splinters for a bit, each trying to figure out a way forward, and God shows up.

Yeah, God. Or at least, the (Christian) God humans tell stories about, in the same way they tell stories about vampires, werewolves, etc. It’s a reasonable development from what we know about how stories work in this world, giving birth to monsters and heroes, but I’m going to guess it’ll make some readers profoundly uncomfortable. However, it doesn’t preclude God really existing, if you read carefully. The “God” we meet as a character is a made creature, but that doesn’t mean there’s no real God in the world of The All-Nighter. It’s pretty wild to speculate about, but Zdarsky didn’t go there.

Anyway! It goes kind of predictably from there, because of course Lucifer shows up, amongst other developments like the found family all saving each other (though not without loss).

The idea behind this series isn’t super original (stuff like American Gods leaps to mind, but also — though not set in our world — Michael Scott’s Paedur the Bard books, and quite a few others that I’m just not retrieving from memory in this second), but it’s a fun enough exploration of it, which maybe nudges the idea in a slightly different direction by having superheroes a la Marvel also be part of the mythology that comes to life.

Rating: 3/5 (“liked it”)

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Divider

Review – Fence, vol 2

Posted July 9, 2025 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – Fence, vol 2

Fence

by C.S. Pacat, Johanna the Mad, Joanna LaFuente

Genres: Graphic Novels
Pages: 112
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Tryouts are well underway at King’s Row for a spot on the prodigious fencing team, and scrappy fencer Nicholas isn’t sure he’s going to make the grade in the face of surly upperclassmen, nearly impossibly odds, and his seemingly unstoppable roommate, the surly, sullen Seiji Katayama. It’ll take more than sheer determination to overcome a challenge this big! From the superstar team of C.S. Pacat (The Captive Prince) and fan-favorite artist Johanna the Mad comes the second volume of this acclaimed, dynamic series.

Book two of C.S. Pacat’s Fence (with art by Johanna the Mad) pretty much straightforwardly follows the first book, without a gap. The art is still gorgeous, the plot/character interactions are still predictable in a way I find pleasant (but won’t be winning points for originality), and it rattles along at a good pace.

I really love the relationship between Harvard and Aiden, which I’m guessing is heading to romance, but which is also just cute as best friends — especially when Aiden dropped everything to go chat to Harvard (and is so sensitive to his every shift of mood, even as he appears to care so little about everyone else).

Nothing startling happening here, but I’m having a lot of fun getting back into it.

Rating: 4/5

Tags: , , , , , ,

Divider

Review – The All-Nighter, vol 2

Posted June 27, 2025 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – The All-Nighter, vol 2

The All-Nighter

by Chip Zdarsky, Jason Loo, Paris Alleyne, Aditya Bidikar, Allison O'Toole

Genres: Fantasy, Graphic Novels
Pages: 119
Series: The All-Nighter #2
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

In the wake of Ian's disappearance, tensions are running high at the diner. Alex and Joy are stuck covering shifts when they'd rather be out fighting bad guys. To make things worse, people start disappearing just as a new super hero team arrives in town--could the two be related?

What if they're dealing with something bigger and more dangerous than super villains--and what if Alex's decision to become Nightshock put it all in motion?

“Season Two” of Chip Zdarsky’s The All-Nighter picks up not long after the first volume, with everyone trying to reckon with the disappearance of Ian at the end of the volume. We see a bit more of the “found family” aspect in this volume, even if it fragments a bit toward the end, and we also see a bit more development of Cynthia as a character.

And of course, come the end of the book there are some preeeetty big consequences for Alex’s actions, and everyone’s thrown into even worse turmoil.

I haven’t said much about the art so far. It doesn’t bowl me over but it works, characters and events are pretty clear and easy to follow.

Overall, the middle volume is okay, and the ending sets things up for an explosive finale.

Rating: 3/5

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Divider

Review – Chef’s Kiss

Posted June 17, 2025 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – Chef’s Kiss

Chef's Kiss

by Jarrett Melendez, Danica Brine, Hank Jones, Hassan Otsmane-Elhaou

Genres: Graphic Novels, Romance
Pages: 153
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Now that college is over, English graduate Ben Cook is on the job hunt looking for something...anything...related to his passion for reading and writing. According to the hiring committees, he doesn't have enough experience. But when he stumbles upon a "Now Hiring—No Experience Necessary" sign outside a restaurant, Ben jumps at the chance to land his first job. He's actually not so bad in the kitchen, plus, he can keep looking for a writing job in the meantime. But when he begins developing a crush on Liam, one of the super dreamy chefs at the restaurant, he'll start to feel torn between wanting to stay and cook and following his original post-college plan to be a writer. Watch things start to really heat up in the kitchen in this queer YA debut graphic novel!

Somehow, this review never got posted when I read the book in 2022, so here’s one from the backlog I guess!

Chef’s Kiss is really, really cute. I like the art style, and found it very easy to follow what was going on, both due to the clarity of the art and a good layout. That’s not always something you can take for granted (and depends strongly on your taste and visual comprehension skills), though it might sound like faint praise! I enjoy graphic novels, but being strongly non-visual, I’m not always the best at following them.

The cast of characters is fun: the main character is Ben, of course, who starts out looking for a writing job and then finally finds himself at the end of his tether, right in front of a restaurant that’s hiring. He meets one of the chefs, Liam, who happens to be really cute, and then… then the weirdness starts. The owner of the restaurant seems reluctant to handle hiring, and to almost want to deter Ben, insisting he pass a series of challenges in order to work for them, judged by the restaurant’s official taste tester.

The taste tester is a pig, Watson.

There are lots of silly bits surrounding Watson, but there’s a serious core to the story. Ben has to struggle with what he really wants to do, with what he wants to be, and with what his parents want for him. Fresh out of college, he and the friends he lives with have their whole lives to figure out, including interpersonal issues. And, of course, he has a massive crush on Liam.

The whole thing is pretty light, all the same, with lots of cute moments between Liam and Ben, and between Ben and his friends. There’s even a great scene with the owner of the restaurant that hits a strong emotional note — though that’s all I’ll say about that. I found the story a bit ridiculous, at times, but fun.

If you’ve worked in or adjacent to the industry, I can almost guarantee it will annoy you, though. Even I can tell it’s a whimsical and inaccurate imagining of it.

Rating: 4/5

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Divider

Review – The All-Nighter, vol 1

Posted May 23, 2025 by Nicky in Reviews / 4 Comments

Review – The All-Nighter, vol 1

The All-Nighter

by Chip Zdarsky, Jason Loo, Paris Alleyne, Aditya Bidikar

Genres: Fantasy, Graphic Novels
Pages: 136
Series: The All-Nighter #1
Rating: three-stars
Synopsis:

Welcome to The All-Nighter, the only diner in town where you can get coffee and a meal from sunset to sunrise! The staff are friendly (kind of) and happy to serve you (sometimes), and it would never cross their minds to drink their customers’ blood…

Alex is bored—flipping burgers for strangers all night is no way for a vampire to live. But he and his fellow vampires Joy, Cynthia, and Ian have agreed to blend into human society. Inspired by superhero movies, one of few passions in his un-life, Alex decides to don a cape and start fighting bad guys. But his decision will have bigger consequences than he realizes—for himself and for everyone he wants to protect.

I read all three volumes of Chip Zdarsky’s The All-Nighter in pretty short order, so apologies if I get the events of each book a little overlapped! The basic premise of the series is that stories have the power to create the creatures they discuss — Dracula came into being for real thanks to Bram Stoker, Frankenstein’s monster due to Mary Shelley, etc. They remember their fictional pasts, but they’ve also lived on since then. And there are, of course, rules. They must not reveal themselves, or The Takers come.

So there’s a bunch of vampires running a diner, appearing only at night, and trying to fake that they’re just humans to avoid a run-in with The Takers. This isn’t always a very satisfying life, though, and one of them (Alex) ends up giving into his urge to show off his strength and power by playing the hero and rescuing someone. It turns out to be a loophole: he can pretend to be a superhero, instead, a vigilante hero who works at night, Batman-style…

And obviously things go wrong. There’s a found-family situation at the diner and of course they get dragged into it, though most of them (other than Joy) aren’t fleshed out much in this first volume, which makes it a bit more difficult to care about that.

In the end, they all come together to solve the mess Alex has caused as all kinds of creatures come out of the woodwork using the same loophole of superheroes and supervillains… but obviously the genie can’t be put back in the bottle.

Rating: 3/5

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Divider

Review – The Marble Queen

Posted May 8, 2025 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – The Marble Queen

The Marble Queen

by Anna Kopp, Gabrielle Kari

Genres: Fantasy, Graphic Novels, Romance
Pages: 336
Rating: two-stars
Synopsis:

The Marble Queen is a YA fantasy graphic novel that’s the political drama of Nimona meets the heartfelt romance of The Princess and the Dressmaker, but this time in a sapphic romance surrounded by a mist of magic.

Princess Amelia’s kingdom, Marion, is in shambles after months of their trade routes being ravaged by pirates, and now the only seemingly option left is for her to save it through a marriage alliance. When she gets an exorbitant offer from the royalty of Iliad—a country shrouded in mystery—Amelia accepts without question and leaves her home to begin a new life. But she lands on Iliad’s shores to find that her betrothed isn't the country’s prince, but the recently coronated Queen Salira.

Shocked, Amelia tries to make sense of her situation and her confused heart: Salira has awakened strange new feelings inside her, but something dark hides behind the Queen's sorrowful eyes. Amelia must fight the demons of her own anxiety disorder before she can tackle her wife's, all while war looms on the horizon.

Anna Kopp and Gabrielle Kari’s The Marble Queen has some lovely art and character design (though it didn’t always look consistently great — there are some panels that really lack polish).

Story-wise, the pace is a bit meh, since we’re meant to believe that Amelia and Salira are in love really quickly, enough to overrule Salira’s love for the woman she meant to marry instead. (This is kind of “handled” in that Salira says that she no longer loves that woman because of the circumstances, but it comes across as pretty thin.)

It’s a fun concept: Amelia is the princess of a kingdom practically besieged by pirates, married off in order to cement an alliance. To her surprise, she’s married to Queen Salira… and unable to ever leave the country again because of magical reasons. She accepts all this remarkably quickly, manages to notice plots that Salira was completely oblivious to, etc, etc, saves the day, etc, etc, happy ending.

It all just goes too fast, probably not helped by the format (it’s harder to do lots of quiet pining scenes in a graphic novel). Even when something goes wrong and Amelia is imprisoned, it’s literally just for a night and suddenly everything is fine again in the morning.

There are upsides — Salira and Amelia are adorable. There’s also some discussion of Amelia’s anxiety, which is represented throughout the story by briars grabbing hold of her, and a little bit of Salira’s. Ultimately, though, the book just doesn’t linger with any of its themes, and the more I think about it, the more it crumbles.

Rating: 2/5

Tags: , , , , , ,

Divider

Review – I Feel Awful, Thanks

Posted May 3, 2025 by Nicky in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review – I Feel Awful, Thanks

I Feel Awful, Thanks

by Lara Pickle

Genres: Fantasy, Graphic Novels
Pages: 216
Rating: two-stars
Synopsis:

Joana has dragons inside her. Can she tame them before they burn her life down?

Joana is a young witch who secured her dream job with a coven in London, her favorite city, where she can dedicate herself to creating potions, her favorite activity! However, she will soon discover the reality of city life is not so idyllic. Finding a flat is an ordeal, her “dream job” is stressful, and she’s totally alone. Little by little, she makes her place, but fatigue, sadness, and doubts threaten to topple her hard-earned success... until she starts talking to a professional who helps her realize in order to take care of herself, she must know herself.

Lara Pickle’s I Feel Awful, Thanks comes out to being a depiction of anxiety and therapy in a fantasy world where emotions manifest near-physically, and turn into dragons if shut in a box and ignored. It’s, ah, not subtle. At all.

The fantasy world is one where magic is basically taken for granted: everyone can do a little, and some can do a lot more than most. Otherwise, it’s very much like our world, and the main character Joana goes from Spain to the UK for a first job helping to create new potions. Her work is stolen by her team leader, she makes some friends but falls into terrible patterns of bad communication with her boyfriend, and slams all her feelings into a box with predictable consequences.

As a discussion of how anxiety (and other feelings) can get bottled up and how you can treat yourself poorly in the process, it’s not bad. It’s a bit overly simplistic, of course, and it feels like Joana’s journey is vastly exaggerated as far as speed of recovery goes — but it does mention genuine techniques that you can try, and Joana and her friends are relatable and likeable enough to spend the time with.

Rating: 2/5

Tags: , , ,

Divider

Review – If You’ll Have Me

Posted March 27, 2025 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – If You’ll Have Me

If You'll Have Me

by Eunnie

Genres: Graphic Novels, Romance
Pages: 336
Rating: four-stars
Synopsis:

Momo Gardner is the kind of friend who’s always ready to lend a helping hand. She’s introverted, sensitive, and maybe a little too trusting, but she likes to believe the best in people. PG, on the other hand, is a bit of a lone wolf, despite her reputation for being a flirt and a player. Underneath all that cool mystery, she’s actually quick to smile, and when she falls for someone, she falls hard.

An unexpected meet-cute brings the two together, kicking off the beginning of an awkward yet endearing courtship—but with their drastically different personalities, Momo’s overprotective friend, and PG’s past coming back to haunt her, Momo and PG’s romance is put to the test.

Eunnie’s If You’ll Have Me is a really sweet book with cute character designs and a fairly simple story. Momo and PG meet at college: PG’s known for seducing every pretty girl she meets, while Momo’s never had a girlfriend. Inevitably, they meet, and PG starts to pay a lot of attention to Momo — going to events with her, comforting her when she has a bad day, replacing the charm on her bag when she loses it, etc.

Inevitably, they eventually kiss… and inevitably, their pasts get in the way. Momo’s afraid that no one will ever be interested in her because she’s not special, while PG’s been burned in the past by someone she loved assuming she was just messing around with them as well (because she didn’t speak up and say how she was feeling).

They each hurt each other in the traditional misunderstanding, and get back together in the traditional reconciliation; it’s not groundbreaking, but it’s cute, and I really like the character designs. Momo’s insecurity is well portrayed, as is PG’s sadness about not being seen for who she is. It’s a pretty quick read, and doesn’t bog down too much around the misunderstanding.

Rating: 4/5

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider