
Puzzles of the Parish
by Martin Edwards (editor)
Genres: Crime, Mystery, Short StoriesPages: 333
Series: British Library Crime Classics
Rating:
Synopsis:A pernicious parson outwits the thieves of a priceless chalice from the parish treasury. A beloved vicar contemplates a perfect crime when a blackmailer comes knocking. Poisoned pen letters lead to a fall from grace for a rector’s wife, and a suspicious fall from the second storey for the rector.
Gathered here in this new collection are some of the greatest mystery tales in which the tendrils of crime steal into the churchyard, featuring clergymen and nuns as victims, amateur sleuths and villainous perpetrators of the devil’s work. Replete with a fascinating introduction and notes from one of the guiding lights of crime fiction, Martin Edwards, this anthology delivers cosy brainteasers and fiendishly-fashioned stories with a sting in the tail, from a congregation of writers including Joyce Porter, H. C. Bailey, Cyril Hare and Edmund Crispin.
Puzzles of the Parish is the latest collection of short stories edited by Martin Edwards for the British Library Crime Classics series, and as usual it’s an interesting survey of short stories on the topic (churches, clergymen, etc), ordered from oldest to newest in a way that lets you see, if you’re interested, the way the genre was developing.
The authors represented include some of the usual suspects, of course. I did find that the selection of several quite modern stories raised my eyebrows a bit, honestly; I know it’s 2026 already, but a story published in 2006 is not a classic and I’m really not sure how it can be included… but this series has been tending this way a bit, perhaps by way of providing variety. There are plenty of genuine classics, though, and I wish they’d stick to them or admit the series has lost its purpose.
All that said, I found it an enjoyable collection. For me, there’s always a part of my mind looking at it in an academic sort of light, when it comes to classic mysteries, so there’s that level of entertainment for sure… but also there are genuinely interesting/fun stories here with interesting detectives/mysteries/culprits/scenarios. I had fun.
Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)




















































