Category: General

Fantasy with Friends: Adaptations of Classics

Posted March 9, 2026 by Nicky in General / 0 Comments

Fantasy With Friends: A Disccusion Meme hosted by Pages Unbound

This week’s Fantasy with Friends discussion (hosted by Pages Unbound) is about adaptations:

What are your thoughts on fantasy adaptations of classic literature that originally had no fantasy elements? (Ex. Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, A Far Better Thing, Kindred Dragons)

I’m fairly ambivalent, I guess? The only one of those examples I knew about is Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, which I thought was a funny concept at the time, but there were a few copycats of that stretched the joke too far (basically just trying to cash in). I think in general I’d judge each book on its own merits, rather than the idea of adapting a classic alone… but I probably wouldn’t actively seek out such books.

One example I can think of that I did enjoy is Jo Walton’s Tooth & Claw, which was spawned (according to her story) when she was reading Trollope and Le Guin at the same time. I haven’t read any Trollope, so I read it as a standalone fantasy novel on its own merits, and had a great time. It’s been quite a while since I last read it, but I view it pretty fondly.

So overall, not something that calls to me greatly, but I wouldn’t say no to trying it either in the right circumstances — mostly, I think, when it adds something genuinely transformative, rather than just using a popular novel as a shortcut for getting people truly invested.

Tags: , ,

Divider

Stacking the Shelves & The Sunday Post

Posted March 7, 2026 by Nicky in General / 23 Comments

Aaand it’s the weekend again!

Books acquired this week

It’s been a quiet week, but my wife did acquire me the new Uketsu novel:

Cover of Strange Buildings by Uketsu

I’ve been wanting to read it basically since I finished Strange Houses, so I was pretty excited and dove in right away.

Posts from this week

As ever, we’ll start with the reviews:

And some other posts…

What I’m reading

First, let’s do the roundup of books I finished this week! I read a lot at the weekend and then a lot less during the week, especially as it wasn’t a great week… but that still added up to a lot of books overall.

Cover of Platform Decay by Martha Wells Cover of Agnes Aubert's Mystical Cat Shelter by Heather Fawcett Cover of The Library of Ancient Wisdom by Selena Wisnom Cover of Solo Leveling (light novel) vol 8, by Chugong

Cover of How to Fake it In Society by KJ Charles Cover of Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint manhwa vol 7, by Umi Cover of Night Shade & Oak, by Molly O'Neill Cover of Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint manhwa vol 8, by Umi

Cover of Guardian (light novel) vol 2 by Priest Cover of Southernmost: Sonnets by Leo Boix Cover of Part of a Story that Started Before Me ed. George the Poet Cover of Strange Buildings by Uketsu

I won’t be doing quite such a reading marathon as last weekend (I finished nine books on the Saturday) but I am looking forward to some reading time… I need to free up some shelf space for the spree I will undoubtedly have while down in London for my graduation. Not sure yet what I’ll focus on, but I hope to finish Carol Carnac’s The Double Turn, and maybe some more of the Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation manhua. I hope my copy of volume 13 ships soon, since it came out earlier this week.

Linking up with Reading Reality’s Stacking the Shelves, Caffeinated Reviewer’s The Sunday Post, the Sunday Salon over at Readerbuzz, and It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? at The Book Date.

Tags: , ,

Divider

WWW Wednesday

Posted March 4, 2026 by Nicky in General / 2 Comments

Cover of Part of a Story that Started Before Me ed. George the PoetWhat have you recently finished reading?

The last thing I finished was George the Poet’s Part of a Story That Started Before Me, a reflection on Black British history through poetry. It has introductions to most sections explaining what we know about Black people in a given period, some of which I didn’t know about already, so it was a worthwhile read for that alone. I wasn’t a huge fan of most of the selections, admittedly, though some of the poems have a heck of a rhythm to them — you can practically hear them spoken, you can’t help it — which was fun.

Cover of Craft Land: A Journey through Britain's Lost Arts and Vanishing Trades, by James FoxWhat are you currently reading?

I finished a lot of the books I had on the go, so I’m onto pastures new! I just started reading James Fox’s Craftland, though so far I’ve only read through (most of) a chapter about dry stone walls and the work that goes into repairing those. I’m curious what other almost-lost crafts he’ll discuss.

I’m also reading the February British Library Crime Classic, Carol Carnac’s The Double Turn. It feels very much an E.C.R. Lorac novel so far, though since it’s under her other name, I think the detectives are likely to hit quite different to her usual MacDonald. I prefer him, somehow; he’s a very humane, ideal detective.

Cover of Strange Buildings by UketsuWhat will you read next?

Probably Uketsu’s Strange Buildings, which is just out. I’ve been anticipating it for a while, and it arrived today, so it’d be nice to dig in right away.

Other than that, I don’t know, though I have my new Book Spin Bingo card ready… so maybe something from that, so I don’t end up reading nine books in one day again as I did on Saturday, stubbornly finishing February’s card.

Tags: ,

Divider

Top Ten Tuesday: Microhistory

Posted March 3, 2026 by Nicky in General / 28 Comments

This week’s Top Ten Tuesday theme is a genre freebie, so I decided to go with a genre I enjoy a lot: microhistory! I’m technically going to use the term somewhat broadly, but the idea is to take a tiny slice of history and zoom in, using analysis of that small aspect to understand bigger themes and trends.

So here we go! Let’s see what I can pull off my shelves.

Cover of A History of England in 25 Poems by Catherine Clarke Cover of A Fatal Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum by Emma Southon Cover of The Notebook: A History of Thinking on Paper by Roland Allen Cover of The Story of the Bayeux Tapestry by David Musgrove and Michael John Lewis Cover of The British Museum by James Hamilton

  1. A History of England in 25 Poems, by Catherine Clarke.
    I read this last month, so my review isn’t up yet, but I think it was my first 5-star read of the year. It does a really good job of staying aware of England’s colonial history (including toward Scotland, Wales and Ireland) and picking poems that aren’t the obvious poems everyone would always pick. I highly recommend it: poetry can tell us a lot about history, because it’s written by the people who lived it.
  2. A Fatal Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum, by Emma Southon.
    This is a book I read quite a while ago, but I think of it very fondly. It digs into Roman society through the lens of what might count as murder — and what was just considered justified. I loved it.
  3. The Notebook: A History of Thinking On Paper, by Roland Allen.
    I really loved the way this book rambled around the history of how people use notebooks, from ledgers to ICU diaries. The idea that something that we might take for granted as much as the idea of keeping a notebook has a whole history behind it is very fun to me.
  4. The Story of the Bayeux Tapestry, by David Musgrove and Michael Lewis.
    Of course, it isn’t really just the history of the object itself, but the events it depicts, and how the events have been understood in the years since, in part because of the tapestry. I really loved this one, because it makes clear that we aren’t always certain about what happened and why.
  5. The British Museum, by James Hamilton.
    The British Museum didn’t just spring into being, it’s a whole institution with a history of its own. I will caveat that this book isn’t a critique of the British Museum; it’s in awe and support of the endeavour, and barely discusses the issues with the British Museum’s practices of cultural theft. But it’s still fascinating to learn about how the building came to be what it is today.
  6. Soda and Fizzy Drinks: A Global History, by Judith Levin.
    I’m letting this book stand in for the whole Edible Series, because I could’ve picked out a whole bunch of those. Food tells us a lot about history: how food traditions travel, whether they’re adopted, imposed or absorbed and changed, tells us a lot about contact between different cultures. (So yes, this particular book discusses “coca-colonisation”.) Sometimes with books in this series, I hadn’t really thought about the history and relevance of that particular food at all, so it’s always nice to dig in.
  7. Chinese Dress in Detail, by Sau Fong Chan.
    This book isn’t exhaustive, because it’s based on the holdings of the Victoria & Albert Museum, which inherently biases collection of European items. Still, I found it a fascinating introduction, and the author makes sure to be clear that “Chinese” is a bit of an umbrella term, also discussing Uyghur clothing history as well. Like food traditions, fashion reflects the periods it comes from, with influence from other countries as well as industrialisation and the changing needs of the population. The other “Fashion in Detail” books from the V&A are similarly fascinating.
  8. The Button Box, by Lynn Knight.
    This was one of the first books I read in this sort of genre: Knight focuses on the buttons she finds in a box of old buttons that has been used and added to by the women of her family, and thus tracks the history of not just fashion, but women’s place in society, technological advances, etc. I reread it semi-recently and didn’t love it as much as I had before, but I still remember it fondly.
  9. Heavenly Bodies: Cult Treasures and Spectacular Saints from the Catacombs, by Paul Koudounaris.
    Prior to reading this, I knew little to nothing about the catacomb saints. It’s not a tradition that particularly speaks to me, but I was fascinated to learn how the practice of venerating and decorating the bones of (supposed) saints reflected people’s faith. The photography for this volume is absolutely stunning, too. Macabre, but riveting.
  10. The Sarpedon Krater: The Life and Afterlife of a Greek Vase, by Nigel Spivey.
    If anything on this list is microhistory, this book’s the one. From a single vase, the scope expands to Renaissance art and modern museum collections (and looting). I didn’t know much about this specific vase before I read it, and I’m not really one for art history so I couldn’t evaluate if it was really as influential as the author says… but I loved the process of learning more about it, and the potential influence it’s had all this time.

Cover of Soda and Fizzy Drinks: A Global History by Judith Levin Cover of Chinese Dress in Detail by Sau Fong Chan Cover of The Button Box by Lynn Knight Cover of Heavenly Bodies: Cult Treasures and Spectacular Saints from the Catacombs, by Paul Koudounaris Cover of The Sarpedon Krater by Nigel Spivey

I ended up with a “shortlist” of at least ten more books, but let’s stop there, before I get too obsessive about pruning the list. Hopefully it’s a nice spread of options for the way histories of objects or types of objects, or seemingly more transient things like fashion and food, can tell us all kinds of things about history!

Tags: ,

Divider

Fantasy with Friends: Magical Schools

Posted March 2, 2026 by Nicky in General / 7 Comments

Fantasy With Friends: A Disccusion Meme hosted by Pages UnboundThis week’s question from Fantasy with Friends is all about magical schools:

Do you enjoy books about schools of magic, or do you think they are overdone? Do you have any favorite magical schools or magical school books?

Which obviously immediately presents the massive Scottish castle in the room, hanging over the discussion. It was a hugely popular school story when I was younger, and it still is, and its fingerprints are inevitably all over a lot of the more recent magical school stories. Given the anti-trans views of the author, the frankly racist worldbuilding and character-naming, and the fact that the author uses her money to fund anti-trans lobbying, needless to say I hold no remaining affection for it. Generally I try to avoid interacting with people who continue to support the author and boost the books, because I don’t feel safe with them.

It gets more complicated when it comes to books that feel informed by the existence of that series. There are several published books lately that are apparently serial-numbers-filed-off fanfics, and I’m not entirely sure how I feel about that. I think… broadly supportive, because I appreciate people taking back their investment and turning it into something of their own. It really depends on how much work has been done to differentiate it from the original source text, and whether it’s fixed some of the underlying issues with it rather than just importing them.

(I’ve also undoubtedly read some without knowing, or at least without knowing before I actually bought it, because I didn’t actually read most of that series, and was never part of the fandom. Some stuff just sails over my head. I wish people would stop assuming the cultural supremacy of that series is so complete that everyone else must be able to recognise it!)

Anyway, to turn the discussion away from That Magic School, I do still enjoy the concept of a magical school story, both the ones that feel informed by the Enid Blyton genre of school story, and the ones that are more American like The Grimoire Grammar School Parent Teacher Association. I’ve been especially enjoying ones that are told from a more adult point of view, like The Grimoire Grammar School and Emily Tesh’s The Incandescent: it brings a bit of realism to the genre — and frankly, updates it out of the early 1900s nostalgia fest.

It’s also worth remembering that there have always been other wizarding schools, like the school on Roke in A Wizard of Earthsea. That feels to me like it springs from different roots, and I definitely don’t feel like that kind of otherworldly wizarding school is played out as a story, nor so beholden to That Series.

So yeah, ultimately I feel like the subgenre got over-dominated by That Series and responses to it, and I’d love to see more fantasy schools that aren’t essentially based on British boarding schools of the early to mid 1900s… but I’m not averse to the subgenre automatically. Bonus points if you manage to be queer-inclusive!

Tags: , ,

Divider

February Reading Wrap-Up

Posted March 1, 2026 by Nicky in General / 8 Comments

Field of daffodils

Dydd GĆ”yl Dewi Hapus — Happy St David’s Day! I can’t believe it’s 1st March already, and time for month #2 of my reading wrap-up. For now it’s mostly the same stats and format as last month, but still excited to hear if anyone has any fun ideas for additions.

February in general:

February involved quite a bit of gaming, so a quick shoutout for the new-to-me games I was really loving: Loophole (a fun puzzle game with time travel and tricky paradoxes) and The Chef’s Shift (a typing game that’s also a restaurant management sim). I’ve been trying to do better at getting 100% achievements in the games I pick up and not consigning games to oblivion half played, so I really got stuck into those and got 100% on both, plus a few games I’d been neglecting for a while, like Fossil Corner (a game where you sort fossils, and find fossils matching people’s requests).

My wrist was pretty painful and stiff early in the month, but I kinda figured out why and gave myself a bit of a break, and was able to get back to physio without too many problems. I don’t know if it’s helping, but I’m giving it a bit more time before I go back to the GP, since I know I was (accidentally) doing some stuff that hurt my wrist in the last couple weeks.

I also sorted out my attendance at both my graduations: I’ll be graduating with an MSc in Infectious Diseases from the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine at the end of March, and then from the University of London at the end of April. I’m in one of the last few cohorts to do so, since University of London shut down the course and LSHTM decided to keep it going by themselves. It’s kinda nice that I still get to graduate from both, as it means I’m graduating from the same university as my mum did (albeit in different subjects/from different schools, as she’s a doctor).

Alright, now let’s talk about the really important stuff: books!

Reading stats:

StoryGraph reading stats for February 2026: 37 books, 8,660 pages, average rating of 3.61. My top rated reads included Catherine Clarke's A History of England in 25 Poems, Julie Leong's The Keeper of Magical Things, and Amy Coombe's Stay for a Spell. The number of pages I read per day varied all month, but was always 100+. There was a massive uptick on the last day! More reading stats for February 2026: I read 72% fiction, 28% non-fiction, and 76% of my books were under 300 pages long, with 24% between 300 and 500 pages. I read 81% in print and 19% in digital editions, and my top genres were fantasy (21), LGBT (14), manga (12), romance (12) and poetry (10).

Total books read: 37
Total pages read: 8,660
Rereads: 1
ARCs: 6
Series finished/up to date: 2
Books owned pre-2026: 8
Books owned from 2026:
18
Borrowed books: 10

Fiction: 24
Non-fiction:
4
Poetry:
9
Comics, manga, manhwa, etc: 12

I’m ending the month ahead on my yearly reading goal, wooo. One major cause of that was mainlining the manhua adaptation of Mo Xiang Tong Xiu’s Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation. I read the light novel recently, but reading an adaptation is always a little different, and I found it helped bits and pieces of the story come together for me that hadn’t really clicked before. Volume 13 should finish off the story, and is out in March, so I’m looking forward to finishing the series.

I read less non-fiction than I expected, but more poetry. I’m still enjoying exploring more poetry!

Progress on reading goals:

Overall total books read: 68/400 (2 books ahead)
Overall total pages read: 15,966/100,000 (472 pages behind)
Books read from backlog: 21/100
Books owned since 2026 and not yet started: 12/20

Good progress here, really! I was a few books behind (and further behind on pages) until I did a marathon of reading yesterday to finish off my BookSpinBingo card. I actually managed it, finishing nine books in a single day, which was a lot of fun but not something I want to do often, ahaha.

I need to work more on getting the number of books I’ve bought this year and not started doooown, since my graduation this month means a trip to London and therefore to a bunch of bookshops.

Blogging stats:

Views: 13.7k
Visitors: 11.9k
Likes: 353
Comments: 389
Reviews: 28
Other posts: 16

A busy month! I’m not entirely sure why, though I’m sure bots are a part of it. Still, all the numbers are up, including likes and comments, so I don’t think it’s just bots. It’s probably also the fact that I took part in Top Ten Tuesday and added a new weekly meme I participate in (Fantasy with Friends), plus trying to be generally active and add fun blogs to my own RSS feed.

Most viewed posts:

I continue to get a fair bit of traffic to reviews of The Other World’s Books Depend on the Bean Counter, which I guess is due to the anime. I wonder if I’ll see more for Heaven Official’s Blessing, given the release of the new short film, though I think the audience for the short films are already pretty locked in and don’t need to read book reviews to know that Hualian invented love…

My own favourite posts:

Posts I loved from elsewhere:

Alright, that’s me for February! Time to go and start on that March reading.

Tags: ,

Divider

Stacking the Shelves & The Sunday Post

Posted February 28, 2026 by Nicky in General / 20 Comments

Woooo, weekend time! And I have plans. Reading plans.

Books acquired this week

First up, some poetry via the library:

Cover of Southernmost: Sonnets by Leo Boix

It seems to be really popular — I had to put a hold on it (and I was third in the queue), and there’s one person after me, so I should get to this soon. From my (short) experience of being a National Poetry Library member, it’s rare to need to put a hold on books (even award winners), much less see multiple holds on it, so I’m very curious about why. My hopes are high!

I did also get a review copy this week; I hesitated over accepting it because it’s a PDF, and because I don’t always get on with modern crime/mystery stories… but I figured I’d give it a shot.

Cover of Murder Like Clockwork by Nicola Whyte

Though I don’t know when I’ll get to it, ahaha.

Posts from this week

Let’s start with the review roundup, as usual:

Aaand the other posts:

What I’m reading

I’ve read quite a bit this week, but I haven’t finished many books (I expect that to happen in a marathon this weekend, ahaha). So it’s a short round-up of books I’ve finished this week:

Cover of Domination by Alice Roberts Cover of Stay for a Spell by Amy Coombe Cover of The Keeper of Magical Things by Julie Leong

If I want to get a blackout on my BookSpinBingo card (and I do!) then today will be spent reading a lot. I first plan to finish up reading the new Murderbot, Platform Decay, and (finally) Heather Fawcett’s Agnes Aubert’s Mystical Cat Shelter, but I have a few books close to finished, so they won’t be the only ones.

I’m rather looking forward to my marathon reading today, but probably tomorrow I’ll chill with video games a bit more, ahaha.

Linking up with Reading Reality’s Stacking the Shelves, Caffeinated Reviewer’s The Sunday Post, the Sunday Salon over at Readerbuzz, and It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? at The Book Date.

Tags: , ,

Divider

WWW Wednesday

Posted February 25, 2026 by Nicky in General / 4 Comments

Cover of The Keeper of Magical Things by Julie LeongWhat have you recently finished reading?

I finished up The Keeper of Magical Things the day before yesterday; I didn’t love it as much as I loved Julie Leong’s previous book, because I felt the magic was a little less interesting (or a bit less of a unique angle, anyway). Still, it was cute and fun, and I’m glad I finally settled in and got round to it!

Cover of Agnes Aubert's Mystical Cat Shelter by Heather FawcettWhat are you currently reading?

A few books at once, as always. I’ve finally got back to Heather Fawcett’s Agnes Aubert’s Mystical Cat Shelter; I’d actually hoped to finish it yesterday, but I didn’t manage to settle down into quiet reading time early enough to have a chance. I still think it has such Howl’s Moving Castle vibes.

I’m also now reading Selena Wisnom’s The Library of Ancient Wisdom, which I started a while back and then stalled on because it was quite dense and I was in the middle of exams. It’s really interesting, because working from the starting point of discussing the library of Ashurbanipal means the author is able to dig into various aspects of ancient Mesopotamian beliefs and knowledge. I didn’t know (for instance) that they were actually really good on hygiene and quarantining the sick: it might sound a little patronising to be surprised that they washed their hands with soap and had good hygiene around sick people, but when you consider that in the 1800s Ignaz Semmelweis was treated as a literal madman for suggesting washing your hands between doing autopsies and delivering babies… welp.

Cover of Night Shade & Oak, by Molly O'NeillWhat will you be reading next?

Definitely Molly O’Neill’s Nightshade and Oak, and probably also Martha Wells’ Platform Decay, since they’re both on my BookSpinBingo list! I’ve been more into reading again in the last couple of days, so I’m still hopeful of finishing most of it.

Tags: ,

Divider

Top Ten Tuesday: Quotations

Posted February 24, 2026 by Nicky in General / 28 Comments

I don’t actually save quotations from books very often, so for this we’re reaching for some snippets I remember (or at least half remember, enough to look them up) to see what’s made an impression on me… let’s see what I can rustle up. Some of these I’ve surely posted before (and am posting again because they remain as vital to me as ever), but some are definitely newer.

Cover of Everything is Tuberculosis by John Green Cover of The Goblin Emperor by Katherine Addison Cover of Heaven Official's Blessing vol 6 by MXTX Cover of Heaven Official's Blessing vol 8 by MXTX Cover of volume one of Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation by Mo Xiang Tong Xiu

  1. From John Green’s Everything is Tuberculosis, because TB remains a terrible and destructive disease that we must all take responsibility for:  
    We cannot address TB only with vaccines and medications. We cannot address it only with comprehensive STP programs. We must also address the root cause of tuberculosis, which is injustice. In a world where everyone can eat, and access healthcare, and be treated humanely, tuberculosis has no chance. Ultimately, we are the cause.

    We must also be the cure.
  2. From Katherine Addison’s The Goblin Emperor, because Maia’s efforts to be better than what was done to him (without it being easy) make him a wonderful character:
    “In our inmost and secret heart, which you ask us to bare to you, we wish to banish them as we were banished, to a cold and lonely house, in the charge of a man who hated us. And we wish them trapped there as we were trapped.”
    “You consider that unjust, Serenity?”
    “We consider it cruel,” Maia said. “And we do not think that cruelty is ever just.”
  3. From Mo Xiang Tong Xiu’s Heaven Official’s Blessing, because Xie Lian’s strong determination to save whoever he can is something I aspire to:
    “If a day isn’t enough, let it take a month. If a month won’t do, then two months, three months! If I can’t save ten thousand, then I’ll save a thousand. If I can’t save a thousand, then I’ll save a hundred, or ten, or even just one!”
  4. From Mo Xiang Tong Xiu’s Heaven Official’s Blessing, because it struck a chord for me in emphasising choice:
    “I might not be able to decide whether the road is easy or not, but whether I walk it is entirely up to me.”
  5. From Mo Xiang Tong Xiu’s Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation, because this scene is actually really important, and we really do have to know when to say sorry:
    Wei Wuxian strode over with his hands clasped behind his back. “Young man, sometimes in life, there are a few sappy things one must say.”
    “What?” Jin Ling asked.
    “‘Thank you’ and ‘I’m sorry’,” Wei Wuxian replied.
    Jin Ling clicked his tongue. “Well, I refuse. What’re you gonna do about it?”
    “There’ll come a day when you’ll say them through tears,” Wei Wuxian said.
    Jin Ling scoffed, and Wei Wuxian suddenly said it himself.
    “I’m sorry.”
  6. From Susan Cooper’s Silver on the Tree, because it’s easy to wait for someone else to save us:
    For Drake is no longer in his hammock, children, nor is Arthur somewhere sleeping, and you may not lie idly expecting the second coming of anybody now, because the world is yours and it is up to you. Now especially since man has the strength to destroy the world, it is the responsibility of man to keep it alive, in all its beauty and marvelous joy.
    And the world will still be imperfect, because men are imperfect. Good men will still be killed by bad, or sometimes by other good men, and there will still be pain and disease and famine, anger and hate. But if you work and care and are watchful, as we have tried to be for you, then in the long run the worse will never, ever, triumph over the better.”
  7. From Ursula Le Guin’s A Wizard of Earthsea, because this is the turning-point of the story, and in a way taught me to be less anxious by facing my fears:
    “You must hunt the hunter.”
  8. From Ursula Le Guin’s A Wizard of Earthsea, because it’s true but hard to learn:
    “Only in silence the word, only in dark the light, only in dying life: bright the hawk’s flight on the empty sky.”
  9. From Dorothy L. Sayers’ The Unpleasantness at the Bellona Club, so that not all of these are serious (and because this, too, is true!):
    “Books are like lobster shells, we surround ourselves with ’em, then we grow out of ’em and leave ’em behind, as evidence of our earlier stages of development.”
  10. From Dodie Smith’s I Capture the Castle, because it’s a good one to end on, and a line I will never forget:
    Only the margin left to write on now. I love you, I love you, I love you.

Cover of Silver on the Tree, by Susan Cooper Cover of A Wizard of Earthsea by Ursula Le Guin Cover of The Unpleasantness at the Bellona Club by Dorothy L. Sayers Cover of I Capture the Castle by Dodie Smith

With apologies to those who could’ve predicted the inclusion of those quotes from Cooper, Le Guin, Addison, Smith and Sayers…

Tags: ,

Divider

Fantasy With Friends: The Chosen One

Posted February 23, 2026 by Nicky in General / 4 Comments

Fantasy With Friends: A Disccusion Meme hosted by Pages Unbound

It’s Monday, so time for more of the Fantasy With Friends discussion meme (hosted at Pages Unbound). This week’s discussion theme iiiis:

“The Chosen One” is an often-mocked trope in fantasy literature. Do you frequently run across this trope in the books you read, or has it been a while since you encountered it? Do you dislike it, or do you think it can be done well? Are there any interesting twists on the Chosen One you’ve seen?

I think the “Chosen One” trope can be a lot of fun whether it’s played straight, subverted, or dissected. I’m actually having trouble thinking up examples right now where it’s played straight, because that was more common in a different era of my reading, and it also depends on how literal you want to be. To hark back to Tolkien, since we were talking about it last week, was Frodo chosen, as Gandalf suggests? Or did he just put his hand up and take it on because he was a good person? Is it kinda both? I know a lot of people read it as Frodo being Chosen, but does that mean he doesn’t have a choice…?

Playing it straight but digging into what it might mean to be Chosen, Seanan McGuire’s Wayward Children books try to examine the impact on the the type of Chosen Ones who travel to another world (like the Pevensie kids in the Narnia books, and other portal fantasies), and what happens once their part in the stories is done. What happens if they stop fitting the role, or falter, or slip out of their world?

In more recent reading, I liked the way that Caitlin Rozakis’ The Grimoire Grammar School Parent Teacher Association handled it. There’s a prophecy, there’s a constant stream of large and small disasters, and the protagonist’s kid is being whispered about as a bringer of calamity (while others are being positioned as potentially Chosen Ones to act in opposition to her). But (spoilers ahead) the prophecy isn’t like that at all, the kids are all just kids, and someone’s benefiting from pretending things might be otherwise.

Another way to play with the Chosen One trope is the accidentally Chosen One. I’m thinking of The Other World’s Books Depend on the Bean Counter, where the magical kingdom of Romany use magic to snatch a girl from modern Japan. She’s their Chosen One, but they inadvertently bring along Seiichirou Kondou as well because he sees her being dragged into a magical portal and begging for help, and goes to rescue her. In the end, he’s as instrumental as she is to solving the problem they needed a Chosen One for, if not more — and he makes sure they will never need to do so again, fixes the kingdom’s finances, and pushes along massive technological advances.

Along the way, Seiichirou also warns the girl who is the Chosen One not to blindly help the kingdom without examining what they’re asking of her, which… she doesn’t take well, but is actually a good point. What if you’re chosen for something awful? I think “the Chosen One doesn’t want to be a Chosen One” (for whatever reason) is probably a bit overplayed itself by now in simple forms, but I can think of a bunch of fun ways to play with it still…

On another tangent, I love that in Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint, Huiwon gets sponsored by a righteous “constellation”, and gets a skill called “Time of Judgement”, which allows her to fight and destroy evildoers. It’s not quite the same as the Chosen One trope, but she’s chosen by the constellation and essentially becomes his incarnation, so it’s close. The problem is, “Time of Judgement” will only activate when approved by her sponsor and constellations aligned with him, and Huiwon’s definition of evil and evildoers is different from theirs. Early in the story, she frequently tries to call on “Time of Judgement” and is declined, even when she sees things she feels are deeply wrong. So what if you’re a Chosen One, but your intentions don’t fully align with those of whoever is doing the choosing?

So… I think there are reasons to mock or avoid the trope, because it can be really overused and under-examined. For me, though, there are so many ways to put a fun spin on it, or dig into what it might actually mean for the characters, and otherwise do surprising and interesting things with it. I won’t say I’d never read stuff with a Chosen One trope, but I do prefer it when people are consciously playing with it and teasing out the implications!

Tags: ,

Divider