Category: General

Fantasy with Friends: Oz

Posted March 16, 2026 by Nicky in General / 9 Comments

Fantasy With Friends: A Disccusion Meme hosted by Pages Unbound

It’s Monday, so time once more for the Fantasy With Friends discussion meme (hosted at Pages Unbound). This week’s question is as follows…

Do you have a favorite interpretation of Oz? Do you try to fit the different adaptations together, or do you see them as separate entities? (Do you try to make Wicked make sense with The Wizard of Oz? And do you think of the book or the movie versions in those instances?)

I am not actually a huge fan of the Oz books, having only read the first and not really enjoyed the book version of Wicked — I thought it was okay, but I didn’t really feel the hype, I guess! I’ve also not been enough of a fan of any other adaptation to really gain a solid opinion here, to be honest.

That said, I do enjoy the musical version of Wicked, so I promise I’m not a dead loss. I’ve seen it live once with friends, before I really knew it, and since then the songs have been in regular rotation for me. I don’t really watch movies, though, so I haven’t even seen those…

I think I’d view them each as separate entities, albeit ones that have interesting things to say to and about each other. Sometimes it might be fun to try to make it all fit, and sometimes it’s just enjoying each one for what it is.

Are there any adaptations/retellings/etc that people really love? Would y’all urge me to give Oz another shot?

Tags: ,

Divider

Stacking the Shelves & The Sunday Post

Posted March 14, 2026 by Nicky in General / 16 Comments

Hurrah, it’s the weekend! I hope everyone has fun plans.

Books acquired this week

Somehow it’s that time of month again already — my British Library Crime Classic subscription book has arrived! It’s quite the chonker, and not one I’d heard of before. My curiosity is piqued. In addition, two preorders came along, one via the mail and one landing on my ereader: I believe volume 13 wraps up the Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation manhua, while Nobody’s Baby is a sequel to a book I quite enjoyed.

Cover of Airing in a Closed Carriage by Joseph Shearing Cover of Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation manhua vol 13 Cover of Nobody's Baby by Olivia Waite

So I’ll have to get busy to re-clear the decks ready for my graduation spree at the end of the month!

Posts from this week

Time for a roundup! Reviews first:

Other posts:

What I’m reading

As usual, let’s start with what I’ve been reading with a sneak peek at the books I’m going to review on the blog sometime soon:

Cover of Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation manhua vol 10 Cover of The Double Turn by Carol Carnac (AKA E.C.R. Lorac) Cover of Craft Land: A Journey through Britain's Lost Arts and Vanishing Trades, by James Fox Cover of Twig's Traveling Tomes by Gryffin Murphy

Cover of Sky High by Michael Gilbert Cover of A Long and Speaking Silence by Nghi Vo Cover of Nobody's Baby by Olivia Waite

There were a couple of rereads too, as I prepared myself for the newest Singing Hills novella. All in all, a pretty good reading week, even if I had trouble concentrating for a couple of days due to pain after a dental procedure. (I’m doing better now, though it still hurts to chew!)

As for this weekend, I’m planning to read the remaining volumes of the Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation manhua adaptation. I might also start on T. Kingfisher’s Swordheart, since I have Daggerbound to review.

But, as ever… it’ll be down to my whim.

Linking up with Reading Reality’s Stacking the Shelves, Caffeinated Reviewer’s The Sunday Post, the Sunday Salon over at Readerbuzz, and It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? at The Book Date.

Tags: , ,

Divider

Reading Firsts in 2026

Posted March 13, 2026 by Nicky in General / 6 Comments

Tammy posted this book tag over on Books, Bones & Buffy and I couldn’t resist joining in… what are your “firsts” for 2026?

First book read in 2026: vol 4 of Solo Leveling (Chugong)

It’s definitely the first book finished anyway — I suppose in theory I might’ve read a bit of something else before that, because I tend to dual-wield… or triple-wield… or — well, ahem, you get the picture.

Cover of Solo Leveling (light novel) vol 4, by Chugong

First review of 2026: Fabulous Frocks (Jane Eastoe & Sarah Gristwood)

Cover of Fabulous Frocks by Sarah Gristwood and Jane Estoe

This wasn’t the first review I wrote in 2026, since that almost certainly hasn’t been published on my blog yet — I have somewhere around 60 reviews written and not yet posted, since I read more than a book a day on average, and try to space out reviews to give a variety (while frontloading reviews of ARCs). This was the first review posted, though, and you can find it here.

The first review I wrote for the year is hard to guess, since I read a lot of books at the end of 2025 and wrote reviews for them at the start of 2026. At a guess, though, it might’ve been for volume one of Mone Sorai’s Our Not-So-Lonely Planet Travel Guide, a romance manga.

Cover of Our Not-So-Lonely Planet Travel Guide, vol 1, by Mone Sorai

First debut read in 2026: The Iron Bridge (Rebecca Hurst)

It took me a bit to figure this out, because I don’t pay a lot of attention to stuff like debuts (and publication history for non-fiction writers can be weird), but I remembered I picked up this poetry collection because it in one of the prize categories at my library… and as far as I recall now, it was a prize for being an outstanding first poetry collection. My review is up already here!

Cover of The Iron Bridge by Rebecca Hurst

The first book I was conscious of being a debut was Amy Coombe’s Stay for a Spell, which I received to review and is a fun and cosy romantasy. My review is coming up soon!

Cover of Stay for a Spell by Amy Coombe

First “new-to-me” author of 2026: Adam Aleksic

This may well also have been a debut, but I deliberately skipped the non-fiction writers in the last question because it’s often harder to find out. I had caveats, but found it interesting all the same. My review is here!

Cover of Algospeak: How Social Media is Transforming the Future of Language by Adam Aleksic

First book of 2026 that slayed me: Guardian vol 1 (Priest)

The yearning, my goodness. My review isn’t up yet, but here’s an excerpt:

Shen Wei had been restraining himself for too long. In the perfect silence, he couldn’t help letting go for once. Lying there with Zhao Yunlan so tantalisingly near, his thoughts spun out of control. He imagined gathering that warm body close, pressing kisses to those eyes, that hair, those lips… tasting and partaking of every part.
He imagined possessing Zhao Yunlan utterly.
The fantasy alone was enough to make Shen Wei’s breathing unsteady. He yearned with the desperate fervour of someone dreaming of hot soup as they froze to death.
But he didn’t move a muscle. Just looking at Zhao Yunlan and thinking about him was seemingly enough.

I have my complaints about Guardian, but whatever’s going on between Shen Wei and Zhao Yunlan has me hooked.

Cover of Guardian (light novel) vol 1 by Priest

First book of 2026 that I wish I could get back the time I spent reading it: Longer (Michael Blumlein)

It was a book I’d received ages ago as an ARC and bounced off, so I gave it another shot. I did skim to the end because I don’t like reviewing ARCs without at least a solid feel for the whole book, but I regret every moment. My review is here.

Cover of Longer by Michael Blumlein

I did rate a book as 1-star before that, but while I didn’t think it was very good (and I think it wasted the reader’s time a fair bit), I still thought it had some worthwhile bits. Still, it’s a runner-up: Megan C. Reynolds’ Like: A History of the World’s Most Hated (And Misunderstood) Word. My review is here!

Cover of Like: A History of, Like, the World's Most Hated (and, Like, Misunderstood) Word, by Megan C. Reynolds

First 5-star book of 2026: A History of England in 25 Poems (Catherine Clarke)

I had no 5-star reads in January, but February was a bit stronger. This was the first, though, and is in the running to be one of my favourite reads of the year. Obviously the year is young, though! I’ll be posting my review sometime in the next couple of weeks, probably, but the gist is that I found the selection of poems to discuss really interesting, and it engaged better with England’s colonialism than I’d feared, including understanding that Wales, Scotland and Ireland were also subject to England’s bad behaviour.

Cover of A History of England in 25 Poems by Catherine Clarke

(It’ll be quick, I said. I’ll just knock it out and post it right away, I said. And then I got wordy. Oh well!)

What were your firsts of the year? Feel free to steal this tag just as I did, and drop the link in the comments so I can take a look. You don’t need to be as chatty as me, ahaha.

Tags: ,

Divider

WWW Wednesday

Posted March 11, 2026 by Nicky in General / 2 Comments

Cover of Twig's Traveling Tomes by Gryffin MurphyWhat have you recently finished reading?

The last thing I finished was Gryffin Murphy’s Twig’s Traveling Tomes, which I got as an ARC via Netgalley. The romance didn’t really work for me, since it felt a bit too much like insta-love and I didn’t feel the chemistry, but the book magic was pretty fun. I’d love to have magic that can tell me the perfect book for someone I don’t even know; that sounds pretty darn cool.

Cover of Folk Song in England by Steve RoudWhat are you currently reading?

As ever, I have a couple of books on the go. My current non-fiction read is a chonker by Steve Roud, Folk Song in England. I’ve been a fan of folk music since I was a teen, though Roud is using a stricter definition that excludes singers like Seth Lakeman or bands like Bellowhead (who have done modern interpretations of traditional folk songs, often with a decidedly non-traditional sound). He draws a line at the 1950s and declines to discuss modern stuff for the purposes of his work. Still interesting to me, since many of these traditional songs are sources for the modern folk singers I’ve enjoyed.

I also settled into a classic mystery yesterday while feeling sorry for myself about my dentist visit: Michael Gilbert’s Sky High, which enjoyably features a comfortably middle-aged lady who rides a motorbike, manages the choir, and has some clever ideas about amateur detection. After the last book of Gilbert’s I read (Death in Captivity) I was kind of putting this off in case it was similarly grim, but though it’s haunted by war, it doesn’t have the same feel. I’m enjoying it well enough so far!

Cover of Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation manhua vol 12What will you be reading next?

If I told you, I’d have to kill you…

Nope, as so often, I have no real idea. I’m trying to clear the decks a bit since I’m going to have a few days in London at the end of the month, and undoubtedly that will mean getting some new books. I have a challenge for 2026 (that worked well in 2025) not to have more than 20 books bought in 2026 that I haven’t started yet, plus a goal of generally reading more books than I buy to slowly chip away at the backlog, so I want to create some space there. That means I’ll probably read the rest of the MDZS manhua volumes I have, and maybe start on a couple more ARCs.

Tags: ,

Divider

Top Ten Tuesday: Ordinal Numbers

Posted March 10, 2026 by Nicky in General / 24 Comments

This week’s Top Ten Tuesday theme is books with ordinal numbers in the title, which took me some doing! But I got there in the end, by spelunking through past books read.

Cover of The Eagle of the Ninth by Rosemary Sutcliff Cover of The Fourth Island by Sarah Tolmie Cover of The Ninth Rain by Jen Williams Cover of The Seventh Bride by T. Kingfisher Cover of The Fifth Season, by N.K. Jemisin

  1. The Eagle of the Ninth, by Rosemary Sutcliff.
    This was the first to jump to mind, as it’s a book I’ve loved for a long time. Sutcliff was great at writing historical fiction that was perfect for kids without being patronising and without skimping on detail. The germ of the story for this one is a Roman eagle that was found during an archaeological dig, along with the alleged disappearance of the Ninth Legion (though the status of the Hispana and how it ended are questioned more now, if I understand correctly). Despite that, it’s not meant as a history lesson, and I love Marcus, Esca and Cub, and the story of the Ninth Legion that Sutcliff imagined.
  2. The Fourth Island, by Sarah Tolmie.
    Turns out I never posted my review of this book here, so I’ve added that to my list! I’ve loved several of Tolmie’s novellas, and remember enjoying this a lot — though it’s not a story that comes to many conclusions, but rather one that leaves you with all kinds of questions and things to ponder. As I recall, it’s beautifully written, too!
  3. The Ninth Rain, by Jen Williams.
    This one’s stuck in my head for ages! I’ve been contemplating a reread of this as well, because this trilogy just felt so chewy. I don’t know if that makes sense to say, but there was a lot of worldbuilding, a lot of stuff going on, and I got really attached to some of the characters.
  4. The Seventh Bride, by T. Kingfisher.
    And another one I’d really like to reread! It’s been quite a long time, but I remember finding this a really fun retelling, and there’s a hedgehog! I definitely remember the hedgehog.
  5. The Fifth Season, by N.K. Jemisin.
    I imagine this one is on a lot of fantasy and SF lovers’ lists, because there’s so much going on in this one. It’s hard not to spoiler, honestly, because so much of it should probably just be experienced without knowing, leaving you picking up the pieces… I need to finish the trilogy someday.
  6. The First Ghosts, by Irving Finkel.
    This was a complete impulse read back when I picked it up, and I found it really fascinating. Finkel discusses the ancient sources that tell us what people in ancient Sumeria, Babylon and Assyria believed about ghosts, and digs into what he thinks that means. I felt somewhat differently about that part (which dinged the rating a touch), but I still found it really interesting.
  7. The First Fossil Hunters, by Adrienne Mayor.
    I really enjoyed this one: Mayor digs into what the ancient Greeks and Romans thought about fossils, because obviously they did see fossils in the world and wonder about them and have stories about them. I think at times it goes beyond the evidence a bit, but it’s still really interesting.
  8. The Sixth Extinction, by Elizabeth Kolbert. 
    The sixth extinction is, of course, the one that’s happening now, with massive losses in biodiversity in pretty much every biome. Kolbert’s book is partly a discussion of that, and partly a celebration of biodiversity in hopes that people can be convinced to protect it. Definitely a worthy read.
  9. Fifth Sun: A New History of the Aztecs, by Camilla Townsend.
    This book attempts to look past the Spanish sources that are frequently used to understand the Aztec world, looking for sources written by indigenous people wherever possible and trying to dispell certain myths (like the idea that Moctezuma believed Hernán Cortés was a god). And it finally taught me to pronounce certain Nahautl words, as well; the pronunciation guides were really good.
  10. Third Time Lucky, by Tanya Huff.
    Confession: I don’t really remember this collection, but I thought highly of it at the time, and Huff is a fun writer in general. So I’d probably stand by past-me’s recommendation!

Cover of The First Ghosts by Irving Finkel Cover of The First Fossil Hunters by Adrienne Mayor Cover of The Sixth Extinction by Elizabeth Kolbert Cover of Fifth Sun by Camilla Townsend Cover of Third Time Lucky by Tanya Huff

See? I did it in the end!

Very curious to see others’ choices, and whether everyone struggled as much as I did!

Tags: ,

Divider

Fantasy with Friends: Adaptations of Classics

Posted March 9, 2026 by Nicky in General / 0 Comments

Fantasy With Friends: A Disccusion Meme hosted by Pages Unbound

This week’s Fantasy with Friends discussion (hosted by Pages Unbound) is about adaptations:

What are your thoughts on fantasy adaptations of classic literature that originally had no fantasy elements? (Ex. Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, A Far Better Thing, Kindred Dragons)

I’m fairly ambivalent, I guess? The only one of those examples I knew about is Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, which I thought was a funny concept at the time, but there were a few copycats of that stretched the joke too far (basically just trying to cash in). I think in general I’d judge each book on its own merits, rather than the idea of adapting a classic alone… but I probably wouldn’t actively seek out such books.

One example I can think of that I did enjoy is Jo Walton’s Tooth & Claw, which was spawned (according to her story) when she was reading Trollope and Le Guin at the same time. I haven’t read any Trollope, so I read it as a standalone fantasy novel on its own merits, and had a great time. It’s been quite a while since I last read it, but I view it pretty fondly.

So overall, not something that calls to me greatly, but I wouldn’t say no to trying it either in the right circumstances — mostly, I think, when it adds something genuinely transformative, rather than just using a popular novel as a shortcut for getting people truly invested.

Tags: , ,

Divider

Stacking the Shelves & The Sunday Post

Posted March 7, 2026 by Nicky in General / 23 Comments

Aaand it’s the weekend again!

Books acquired this week

It’s been a quiet week, but my wife did acquire me the new Uketsu novel:

Cover of Strange Buildings by Uketsu

I’ve been wanting to read it basically since I finished Strange Houses, so I was pretty excited and dove in right away.

Posts from this week

As ever, we’ll start with the reviews:

And some other posts…

What I’m reading

First, let’s do the roundup of books I finished this week! I read a lot at the weekend and then a lot less during the week, especially as it wasn’t a great week… but that still added up to a lot of books overall.

Cover of Platform Decay by Martha Wells Cover of Agnes Aubert's Mystical Cat Shelter by Heather Fawcett Cover of The Library of Ancient Wisdom by Selena Wisnom Cover of Solo Leveling (light novel) vol 8, by Chugong

Cover of How to Fake it In Society by KJ Charles Cover of Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint manhwa vol 7, by Umi Cover of Night Shade & Oak, by Molly O'Neill Cover of Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint manhwa vol 8, by Umi

Cover of Guardian (light novel) vol 2 by Priest Cover of Southernmost: Sonnets by Leo Boix Cover of Part of a Story that Started Before Me ed. George the Poet Cover of Strange Buildings by Uketsu

I won’t be doing quite such a reading marathon as last weekend (I finished nine books on the Saturday) but I am looking forward to some reading time… I need to free up some shelf space for the spree I will undoubtedly have while down in London for my graduation. Not sure yet what I’ll focus on, but I hope to finish Carol Carnac’s The Double Turn, and maybe some more of the Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation manhua. I hope my copy of volume 13 ships soon, since it came out earlier this week.

Linking up with Reading Reality’s Stacking the Shelves, Caffeinated Reviewer’s The Sunday Post, the Sunday Salon over at Readerbuzz, and It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? at The Book Date.

Tags: , ,

Divider

WWW Wednesday

Posted March 4, 2026 by Nicky in General / 2 Comments

Cover of Part of a Story that Started Before Me ed. George the PoetWhat have you recently finished reading?

The last thing I finished was George the Poet’s Part of a Story That Started Before Me, a reflection on Black British history through poetry. It has introductions to most sections explaining what we know about Black people in a given period, some of which I didn’t know about already, so it was a worthwhile read for that alone. I wasn’t a huge fan of most of the selections, admittedly, though some of the poems have a heck of a rhythm to them — you can practically hear them spoken, you can’t help it — which was fun.

Cover of Craft Land: A Journey through Britain's Lost Arts and Vanishing Trades, by James FoxWhat are you currently reading?

I finished a lot of the books I had on the go, so I’m onto pastures new! I just started reading James Fox’s Craftland, though so far I’ve only read through (most of) a chapter about dry stone walls and the work that goes into repairing those. I’m curious what other almost-lost crafts he’ll discuss.

I’m also reading the February British Library Crime Classic, Carol Carnac’s The Double Turn. It feels very much an E.C.R. Lorac novel so far, though since it’s under her other name, I think the detectives are likely to hit quite different to her usual MacDonald. I prefer him, somehow; he’s a very humane, ideal detective.

Cover of Strange Buildings by UketsuWhat will you read next?

Probably Uketsu’s Strange Buildings, which is just out. I’ve been anticipating it for a while, and it arrived today, so it’d be nice to dig in right away.

Other than that, I don’t know, though I have my new Book Spin Bingo card ready… so maybe something from that, so I don’t end up reading nine books in one day again as I did on Saturday, stubbornly finishing February’s card.

Tags: ,

Divider

Top Ten Tuesday: Microhistory

Posted March 3, 2026 by Nicky in General / 28 Comments

This week’s Top Ten Tuesday theme is a genre freebie, so I decided to go with a genre I enjoy a lot: microhistory! I’m technically going to use the term somewhat broadly, but the idea is to take a tiny slice of history and zoom in, using analysis of that small aspect to understand bigger themes and trends.

So here we go! Let’s see what I can pull off my shelves.

Cover of A History of England in 25 Poems by Catherine Clarke Cover of A Fatal Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum by Emma Southon Cover of The Notebook: A History of Thinking on Paper by Roland Allen Cover of The Story of the Bayeux Tapestry by David Musgrove and Michael John Lewis Cover of The British Museum by James Hamilton

  1. A History of England in 25 Poems, by Catherine Clarke.
    I read this last month, so my review isn’t up yet, but I think it was my first 5-star read of the year. It does a really good job of staying aware of England’s colonial history (including toward Scotland, Wales and Ireland) and picking poems that aren’t the obvious poems everyone would always pick. I highly recommend it: poetry can tell us a lot about history, because it’s written by the people who lived it.
  2. A Fatal Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum, by Emma Southon.
    This is a book I read quite a while ago, but I think of it very fondly. It digs into Roman society through the lens of what might count as murder — and what was just considered justified. I loved it.
  3. The Notebook: A History of Thinking On Paper, by Roland Allen.
    I really loved the way this book rambled around the history of how people use notebooks, from ledgers to ICU diaries. The idea that something that we might take for granted as much as the idea of keeping a notebook has a whole history behind it is very fun to me.
  4. The Story of the Bayeux Tapestry, by David Musgrove and Michael Lewis.
    Of course, it isn’t really just the history of the object itself, but the events it depicts, and how the events have been understood in the years since, in part because of the tapestry. I really loved this one, because it makes clear that we aren’t always certain about what happened and why.
  5. The British Museum, by James Hamilton.
    The British Museum didn’t just spring into being, it’s a whole institution with a history of its own. I will caveat that this book isn’t a critique of the British Museum; it’s in awe and support of the endeavour, and barely discusses the issues with the British Museum’s practices of cultural theft. But it’s still fascinating to learn about how the building came to be what it is today.
  6. Soda and Fizzy Drinks: A Global History, by Judith Levin.
    I’m letting this book stand in for the whole Edible Series, because I could’ve picked out a whole bunch of those. Food tells us a lot about history: how food traditions travel, whether they’re adopted, imposed or absorbed and changed, tells us a lot about contact between different cultures. (So yes, this particular book discusses “coca-colonisation”.) Sometimes with books in this series, I hadn’t really thought about the history and relevance of that particular food at all, so it’s always nice to dig in.
  7. Chinese Dress in Detail, by Sau Fong Chan.
    This book isn’t exhaustive, because it’s based on the holdings of the Victoria & Albert Museum, which inherently biases collection of European items. Still, I found it a fascinating introduction, and the author makes sure to be clear that “Chinese” is a bit of an umbrella term, also discussing Uyghur clothing history as well. Like food traditions, fashion reflects the periods it comes from, with influence from other countries as well as industrialisation and the changing needs of the population. The other “Fashion in Detail” books from the V&A are similarly fascinating.
  8. The Button Box, by Lynn Knight.
    This was one of the first books I read in this sort of genre: Knight focuses on the buttons she finds in a box of old buttons that has been used and added to by the women of her family, and thus tracks the history of not just fashion, but women’s place in society, technological advances, etc. I reread it semi-recently and didn’t love it as much as I had before, but I still remember it fondly.
  9. Heavenly Bodies: Cult Treasures and Spectacular Saints from the Catacombs, by Paul Koudounaris.
    Prior to reading this, I knew little to nothing about the catacomb saints. It’s not a tradition that particularly speaks to me, but I was fascinated to learn how the practice of venerating and decorating the bones of (supposed) saints reflected people’s faith. The photography for this volume is absolutely stunning, too. Macabre, but riveting.
  10. The Sarpedon Krater: The Life and Afterlife of a Greek Vase, by Nigel Spivey.
    If anything on this list is microhistory, this book’s the one. From a single vase, the scope expands to Renaissance art and modern museum collections (and looting). I didn’t know much about this specific vase before I read it, and I’m not really one for art history so I couldn’t evaluate if it was really as influential as the author says… but I loved the process of learning more about it, and the potential influence it’s had all this time.

Cover of Soda and Fizzy Drinks: A Global History by Judith Levin Cover of Chinese Dress in Detail by Sau Fong Chan Cover of The Button Box by Lynn Knight Cover of Heavenly Bodies: Cult Treasures and Spectacular Saints from the Catacombs, by Paul Koudounaris Cover of The Sarpedon Krater by Nigel Spivey

I ended up with a “shortlist” of at least ten more books, but let’s stop there, before I get too obsessive about pruning the list. Hopefully it’s a nice spread of options for the way histories of objects or types of objects, or seemingly more transient things like fashion and food, can tell us all kinds of things about history!

Tags: ,

Divider

Fantasy with Friends: Magical Schools

Posted March 2, 2026 by Nicky in General / 7 Comments

Fantasy With Friends: A Disccusion Meme hosted by Pages UnboundThis week’s question from Fantasy with Friends is all about magical schools:

Do you enjoy books about schools of magic, or do you think they are overdone? Do you have any favorite magical schools or magical school books?

Which obviously immediately presents the massive Scottish castle in the room, hanging over the discussion. It was a hugely popular school story when I was younger, and it still is, and its fingerprints are inevitably all over a lot of the more recent magical school stories. Given the anti-trans views of the author, the frankly racist worldbuilding and character-naming, and the fact that the author uses her money to fund anti-trans lobbying, needless to say I hold no remaining affection for it. Generally I try to avoid interacting with people who continue to support the author and boost the books, because I don’t feel safe with them.

It gets more complicated when it comes to books that feel informed by the existence of that series. There are several published books lately that are apparently serial-numbers-filed-off fanfics, and I’m not entirely sure how I feel about that. I think… broadly supportive, because I appreciate people taking back their investment and turning it into something of their own. It really depends on how much work has been done to differentiate it from the original source text, and whether it’s fixed some of the underlying issues with it rather than just importing them.

(I’ve also undoubtedly read some without knowing, or at least without knowing before I actually bought it, because I didn’t actually read most of that series, and was never part of the fandom. Some stuff just sails over my head. I wish people would stop assuming the cultural supremacy of that series is so complete that everyone else must be able to recognise it!)

Anyway, to turn the discussion away from That Magic School, I do still enjoy the concept of a magical school story, both the ones that feel informed by the Enid Blyton genre of school story, and the ones that are more American like The Grimoire Grammar School Parent Teacher AssociationI’ve been especially enjoying ones that are told from a more adult point of view, like The Grimoire Grammar School and Emily Tesh’s The Incandescent: it brings a bit of realism to the genre — and frankly, updates it out of the early 1900s nostalgia fest.

It’s also worth remembering that there have always been other wizarding schools, like the school on Roke in A Wizard of Earthsea. That feels to me like it springs from different roots, and I definitely don’t feel like that kind of otherworldly wizarding school is played out as a story, nor so beholden to That Series.

So yeah, ultimately I feel like the subgenre got over-dominated by That Series and responses to it, and I’d love to see more fantasy schools that aren’t essentially based on British boarding schools of the early to mid 1900s… but I’m not averse to the subgenre automatically. Bonus points if you manage to be queer-inclusive!

Tags: , ,

Divider