Brigands & Breadknives
by Travis Baldree
Genres: FantasySeries: Legends & Lattes #3
Rating:
Synopsis:Fern has weathered the stillness and storms of a bookseller's life for decades, but now, in the face of crippling ennui, transplants herself to the city of Thune to hang out her shingle beside a long-absent friend's coffee shop. What could be a better pairing? Surely a charming renovation montage will cure what ails her!
If only things were so simple...
It turns out that fixing your life isn't a one-time prospect, nor as easy as a change of scenery and a lick of paint.
A drunken and desperate night sees the rattkin waking far from home in the company of a legendary warrior surviving on inertia, an imprisoned chaos-goblin with a fondness for silverware, and an absolutely thumping hangover.
As together they fend off a rogue's gallery of ne'er-do-wells trying to claim the bounty the goblin represents, Fern may finally reconnect with the person she actually is when there isn't a job to get in the way.
I hesitated about starting Travis Baldree’s Brigands & Breadknives for a while: the first book came at a perfect moment for me and was delightfully cosy, but the second book (the prequel) didn’t quite hit the same spot, so I wasn’t sure where this one would fall. Ultimately, I didn’t like it as much as I like Legends & Lattes, but I think the choice to avoid sticking too close to the template of the first one and go for a less cosy, more quest-like adventure brought with it a breath of fresh air.
Which is not to say that it abandoned one of the things I like a lot about Legends & Lattes: the book follows Viv as she tires of being a mercenary and turns to something else that’s calling her more, and that’s essentially what’s happening for Fern here as well. Baldree could’ve written essentially the same story again, with Fern settling into the bookshop next door to Viv and finding contentment in a change of pace and location, but instead he chose something truer to the spirit of the original: Fern’s lost, and her relationship to her work has changed, and so she ends up setting out to seek something new.
There are elements of the way things turned out that I’d predicted, but also some differences — which I won’t say too much about, to avoid spoilers! I liked that it somewhat ducked my expectations, but in a way that beautifully made sense of everything.
Overall, I didn’t love it as much as Legends & Lattes, but I did enjoy it a lot. The characters are fun (I love Zyll most of all), we get to see more of the world, and we do see glimpses of Viv, Tandri, et al.
One sour note: a character declares they don’t go by a particular name anymore, and everyone continues to use it. It doesn’t matter why someone wants to change their name, even if you think it’s silly. If the name is upsetting for them or doesn’t fit with who they are in any way, then the right thing to do is accept that change. I didn’t enjoy this element being continuously ignored and used for humour, at all. Names are important. It wasn’t funny.
Rating: 4/5 (“really liked it”)
Yayy, Zyll was my favorite character too! I don’t remember about the character not wanting to go by a name; I’m not sure if I missed it (I listened to it on audio and often miss details) or if I just forgot since it’s been a while, but I agree that it’s not funny to use as a joke. Boo for that. I’m glad you enjoyed most of it though!
Haze @ The Book Haze recently posted…Top Ten Tuesday | Books I HAD to Have Immediately but Still Haven’t Read
It was the knife, which everyone insisted on calling “Breadlee”. It was mostly played for laughs but it annoyed me because it was basically like, “You have to have a better reason for wanting to change your name than just wanting to,” and nope!
You hit on something that I didn’t really connect when I read this one: this is Fern’s version of Viv’s journey in Legends & Lattes. Just because *I* want to settle down in a fantasy world bookshop doesn’t mean that Fern would want that. I do appreciate that the book stayed true to its series origins.
Nicole @ BookWyrm Knits recently posted…Top Ten Tuesday ~ Books I HAD to Have but Still Haven’t Read
Yeah, it felt really congruous when I viewed it like that, even though it’s more… traditional with the journey structure and all.
I’ve only read the prequel and I really enjoyed it. So I might even love Legends & Lattes and B&B more. I love that the characters are setting off on an adventure. And weird about the character’s name change being used as a joke!
I love Legends & Lattes so much.
I think it’s considered “acceptable” by most readers because the character who wants to change their name is doing so for kinda… egotistical reasons, I guess? But you shouldn’t need to have a “good enough” reason that everyone else likes for changing your name.
I think I’ve decided that I’m happy with Legends and Lattes. I’m happy for Baldree, and love how many people are enjoying the series, I’m just not ready to take the plunge into more
Cosmic recently posted…Books I Couldn’t Wait to Buy, but Still Haven’t Read Yet!
That makes sense! It stands alone beautifully.
I know what you mean about Breadlee, a tricky moment there in the books in general which are usually very inclusive. I did like this one and I read the short story too which now appears in a proper short story collection I have on NetGalley but haven’t read yet …
Yeah, it sat oddly and I think it’s really because Baldree didn’t think it through and just thought it would be a joke. But… names are trickier than that.