Happy Monday! Which means it’s time for the Fantasy With Friends discussion post for this week (prompts hosted at Pages Unbound). This week the prompt’s about favourite genres:

Do you have any favorite subgenres of fantasy such as urban fantasy, historical fantasy, etc.?

Sort of! There are subgenres/combinations of genres that will always draw my attention, but I don’t have exclusive favourites, and it’d probably take some working out from the books on my shelves, because I like to try a bit of everything. I think there are some people who find a subgenre they love and just revel in it for months/years/forever, reading little else, and that’s not me — I’m too restless for that and too prone to trying anything and everything I can.

(Which, to be clear, is not intended as a diss for folks who find a genre or a corner of a genre and get themselves entrenched! It’s just not for me.)

As for what draws my attention, I had to actually have a think about it, because it’s definitely been evolving. I think these are the top ones though:

• Fantasy mysteries: I do get a little picky about this genre, because a fantasy mystery has to be careful if it wants to be a fair-play mystery (one where the reader has all the clues). People need to get enough background to the story to be able to theorise for themselves. Even when it’s not intended as a fair-play mystery, the reader shouldn’t be totally blindsided by stuff like special murder magic or something at the end of the story. Still, there are some very fun fantasy mysteries out there: Robert Jackson Bennett’s The Tainted Cup and A Drop of Corruption manage to give you enough detail to the world and magic that you can theorise for yourself, though they aren’t 100% fair-play. Katherine Addison’s The Witness for the Dead is pretty good at that as well. I recently snagged Oliver K. Langmead’s upcoming The Killing of a Chestnut Tree as an ARC exactly because it’s a pastiche of Sherlock Holmes in a fantasy world (and indeed loved it!).
• Cosy fantasy: If anything, I’m even pickier here because sometimes “cosy fantasy” ends up all vibes and no substance, and even interpersonal interactions can get flattened down to keep things low conflict to the point that characters and relationships can end feeling cardboard. Sometimes the happy endings feel too easy to be real, as well. There are cosy/lower-stakes fantasy I’ve loved, though — Legends & Lattes, for example, and The Teller of Small Fortunes.
• Retellings/reinterpretations: There are some ridiculously clever ones that are completely transformative, like T. Kingfisher’s Hemlock & Silver, which is very much a Snow White retelling, but is also full of inventiveness. The mirror monsters are an astounding idea. Shout out too to Jacqueline Carey’s spin on The Lord of the Rings, Banewreaker and Godslayer; it’s been so long since I read those I don’t think I have reviews to link, but which I loved — you wouldn’t think anyone could make Sauron the good guy, and that’s not exactly what Carey does, but you can see the influence. There’s also Jo Walton’s The King’s Peace and sequel, and The Prize in the Game… I’ve been meaning to reread these for quite a while, because they are reflections on Arthurian legends (and The Tain) while being wholly their own thing too. It’s really exciting when people do retellings of less-known stories, too: I’m currently reading Finn Longman’s The Wolf and His King, which retells Marie de France’s ‘Bisclavret’, and I love that.
• Political fantasy: I read Kushiel’s Dart at an impressionable age, and I’ve often looked for similarly rich political intrigue ever since. The Goblin Emperor and The Hands of the Emperor are recent books that scratched the same itch, and I’ve just remembered E.J. Beaton’s The Councillor as well (and sadly learned that the sequel may never be published). In a slightly different way, The Traitor Baru Cormorant digs into this too, though I didn’t get into the follow-up books.
• Historical fantasy: Books like Guy Gavriel Kay’s A Song for Arbonne and Sailing to Sarantium really left their fingerprints on me (and arguably Kushiel’s Dart falls under this heading as well, while many of Kay’s books have political scheming too, like Tigana). I do think this genre can tend to be a bit bland and conjure up a very single-note “history” (i.e. medieval European), so it’s also especially nice when someone goes beyond that (I’d gladly take recommendations on this front!).
• Xianxia and wuxia. I’m combining these because it’s a fairly recent interest of mine (though I’ve read a couple of wuxia-inspired novels here and there before), and mostly in the context of danmei and baihe (which I didn’t want to call a subgenre of fantasy because they don’t have to be fantasy). I have fallen totally in love with stories like The Scum Villain’s Self-Saving System, The Disabled Tyrant’s Beloved Pet Fish (though this isn’t quite xianxia, it’s adjacent) and The Beauty’s Blade, and I’m looking forward to reading more wuxia- and xianxia-inspired novels (like S.L. Huang’s The Water Outlaws).

Okay, I’m going to stop there, but it was fun to think about what exactly draws me in!