Nothing but the Rain, Naomi Salman
Received to review via Netgalley
If you like to know the whys and wherefores, Nothing but the Rain is not going to be for you. It explains nothing about its central premise, which is that all of a sudden, water (not just rain, but water coming out of the taps as well) induces amnesia in people in a certain town. A droplet of water might take away a few seconds of memory; a sudden inundation might wipe out a person’s entire memory and leave them empty of everything.
And we never find out why! Which I know will be deeply infuriating to some folks, so I mention it first here because it’s important to know. Instead, the story is more about how people might act in this situation, and how one particular person — the narrator — makes her way.
There were a few things other than the basic premise that I feel weren’t thought through. For example, at one point a character does something to the narrator that she should’ve been suspicious about — she has 24 hours of her memory removed, not weeks, so she should notice a particular thing is amiss. (I don’t want to say too much; when this gets posted on my blog [breathesbooks.com], I’ll happily elaborate in comments if anyone else who has read it wants me to point to the thing that bugged me.)
It’s overall an interesting idea and execution, and I don’t actually mind that we don’t know why the situation is happening, but I do mind when things like that don’t connect up. The ending has a nice sting in the tail.
Leave a Reply