Review – Darwin’s Lost World

Posted June 2, 2015 by Nicky in Reviews / 2 Comments

Cover of Darwin's Lost World by Martin BrasierDarwin’s Lost World, Martin Brasier

When I picked this up, I didn’t really register that I’d been disappointed by one of the author’s other books. Good thing it was a library book, because though the topic of the most ancient remains of life is fascinating, Brasier’s account jumps around geologically and logically. There’s no straight progression from idea to idea, era to era, area to area. I kept losing track of where a fossil was and how old it was thought to be, and getting distracted by Brasier’s anecdotes (almost boasting) about places he’d been looking for fossils.

Also, I don’t know if Brasier is English or Welsh or what, but my teeth started slowly grinding when he brought in Arthurian analogies. Arthur never looked for the grail, never. It’s the same issue with basic facts that I found in Secret Chambers when he repeated common apocryphal stories as fact, except even more personally annoying because this is Arthur and I spent most of my degree studying Arthur as deeply as Brasier studies fossils. It’s an idiosyncratic reaction, I know, but it was still annoying. The Arthurian stuff felt weird, shoehorned in, especially when Brasier was doing research for Oxford University in Scotland. I could understand it more if he was a fellow of a Welsh university or something.

Rating: 2/5

Tags: , ,


2 responses to “Review – Darwin’s Lost World

  1. Sounds like one for me to avoid too, Nikki, on both counts; I never can understand slapdash commentary bringing in subject matter so obviously outside the author’s purview, nor poor editing that allows a scientific narrative to be derailed so badly.

    • Exactly! I wouldn’t presume to comment on fossils… Well, actually, with my recent course I might be slightly more qualified to do so than this guy is to make Arthurian references!

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.