The Lord Won’t Mind, Gordon Merrick
Received to review via Netgalley
This is a really quick read, though I confess I ended up skimming a bit. There’s a lot of sex scenes and a lot of drama: if it weren’t a popular early gay story it wouldn’t mean very much, I think. But it was one of the earliest novels to feature gay characters who struggle with their identity and have a happy ending, and I was surprised at how quickly it got to that, too. Our sympathies are unequivocally with Peter and his desire for commitment, his passionate love for Charlie; while Charlie’s struggles are treated with some understanding, it’s not as though the narrative treats him as “in the right” for wanting to hide the relationship. In that sense, it’s a celebration of queerness, of love (and yeah, sex) between two men, from a time when that was hard to find. No wonder it was popular.
On the other hand, there’s plenty of unpleasantness here — domestic violence, Charlie wanting to hurt various women and sometimes Peter, racism, homophobia from a few characters, internalised homophobia on Charlie’s part, etc. No matter how good it was for gay people to read a passionate love story for them at the time, there’s a lot that’s problematic and off-putting.
And, frankly, for me the writing wasn’t that good. Situations were contrived, there was a lot of repetition, and I didn’t really believe in the sudden intensity of feeling from Peter — Charlie’s more grudging love was a little easier to believe in, but even so, they went into it at an amazing pace.
Still, it’s kind of fun in a trashy way, and it is nice to have that happy end.
Rating: 3/5
When was it first published?
1970, I think.
So E.M. Forster’s Maurice would have been written much earlier but published (I think) the same decade.
I think so, yeah. I still need to read that. Argh so much to read!
It’s one of his earliest novels and probably joint weakest with Where Angels Fear to Tread – I don’t think he really hit his stride until A Room with a View. He had an arrangement with his publisher to have it released only once he was deceased – hence it being the earliest explicitly gay novel I’ve ever heard of.
Yeah, I mostly want to read it because it’s one of the earliest bits of LGBT literature — I’m not actually a great fan of Forster.